When you hear the title 2-Headed Shark Attack, you basically know what you’re getting into. It’s one of those classic "The Asylum" productions that thrives on being exactly what it says on the tin. If you're looking for Citizen Kane, you’re in the wrong place. But if you’re looking for a specific kind of low-budget, creature-feature fun from 2012, this cast actually brought some surprisingly recognizable faces to the Florida Keys.
Honestly, the 2-Headed Shark Attack movie cast is a weirdly perfect snapshot of early 2010s reality TV and "B-movie" royalty.
The Big Names Leading the Buffet
Most people recognize the leads immediately. You've got Carmen Electra playing Dr. Anne Babish. By this point in her career, Electra was already a household name from Baywatch and various spoof movies. In this film, she’s the wife of the professor, and while she’s top-billed, she’s sort of stuck in a secondary role for a lot of the runtime. She spends a good chunk of the movie on the boat or the dock, looking like she’s in a completely different, much more glamorous movie than the one where people are getting chomped.
Then there’s Brooke Hogan.
As the daughter of wrestling legend Hulk Hogan, she was coming off the heat of Hogan Knows Best and her own music career. She plays Kate, one of the students, and she’s arguably the real hero of the story. Unlike some of the other characters who mostly just scream, Kate gets proactive. She’s the one actually getting in the water with a knife to take on the beast. It’s a physical role, and you can tell she’s putting in the work, even if the shark heads occasionally look like they're made of rubber. Because, well, they were.
The Professor and the Students
Charlie O’Connell steps in as Professor Franklin Babish. If the name sounds familiar, it's because he’s the brother of Jerry O'Connell. Charlie was also a lead on The Bachelor (Season 7), so he was a familiar face for TV junkies back then. He plays the "responsible" adult leading a Semester at Sea program that goes horribly wrong when their ship hits a dead shark and they get stranded on a sinking atoll.
The student body is a massive list of doomed characters. Here’s a quick look at who stayed alive (for a while):
- David Gallegos as Paul: He’s Kate’s main ally and a central figure in the survival group.
- Christina Bach (credited as Christina Bach Norman) as Dana: She’s one of the primary students caught in the chaos.
- Geoff Ward as Cole: He provides some of the typical "jerk" energy you need in a horror movie.
- Mercedes Young as Liza: She’s one of the first to realize that things are going South.
- Gerald Webb as Han: Interestingly, Gerald Webb was also the casting director for the film. He’s a staple in The Asylum’s world.
Why This Specific Cast Worked (And Why It Didn't)
There’s a certain charm to how this group interacts. You’ve got professional actors mixed with reality stars and newcomers like Marckenson Charles (Ryan) and Amber English (Alison), who were making their film debuts here.
The acting is... well, it's what you'd expect. Charlie O’Connell gives it a real "earnest professor" try, even when he’s delivering lines about a shark with two heads. The chemistry between the students feels like a real group of college kids, which makes it slightly more impactful when the shark starts picking them off two at a time. One head for each snack.
Behind the Scenes Trivia
Did you know the shark wasn't originally supposed to look like that?
👉 See also: Why The Voyage Home by Pat Barker Might Be Her Best Greek Myth Retelling Yet
The producers initially wanted the two heads to be stacked—one on top of the other like a double-decker bus. It was the creature designer, Cleve Hall, who convinced them that side-by-side heads would look way more menacing (and probably easier to build). They filmed the whole thing in the Florida Keys over about three weeks. If you look closely at the "educational boat" they're on, you can see signs that say "deep sea fishing." They didn't have the budget to cover it up, so they just rolled with it.
The Fate of the Characters
Without spoiling a decade-old movie too much, the casualty rate is high. That's the point of these movies. The 2-Headed Shark Attack movie cast dwindles fast once the atoll starts sinking.
The climax involves a lot of "zigging when they should have zagged." Carmen Electra and Charlie O’Connell’s characters eventually face the shark on a collapsing dock, leading to one of the most "Asylum-style" deaths in the film. It's melodramatic, it's goofy, and it's exactly what the audience paid (or clicked) to see.
✨ Don't miss: Why Almost Got 'Im Is Still the Best Episode of Batman: The Animated Series
Actionable Insights for Fans of the Genre
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific brand of "Shark Cinema," here’s how to get the most out of it:
- Watch the Sequels: This movie actually kicked off a whole franchise. You’ve got 3-Headed, 5-Headed, and even 6-Headed Shark Attack. The casts get even wilder, including people like Danny Trejo and Karrueche Tran.
- Look for the Cameos: Since The Asylum uses a lot of the same crew, you’ll see people like Gerald Webb popping up in dozens of other movies like Sharknado.
- Check the Credits: Notice the director, Christopher Ray. He’s the son of Fred Olen Ray, a legendary exploitation filmmaker. The B-movie business is a family affair.
To really appreciate what the cast did here, you have to watch it with the right mindset. It’s not about high drama; it’s about watching Brooke Hogan try to outswim a CGI nightmare. Once you accept that, the 90 minutes fly by.
If you’re planning a movie night, try pairing this with Sand Sharks or Mega Shark vs. Giant Octopus. You'll start to see the same names appearing in the credits, creating a weirdly interconnected universe of low-budget creature features that actually have a lot of heart behind them.