The energy at Raymond James Stadium on November 10, 2024, was basically a powder keg. If you’ve followed the San Francisco 49ers lately, you know their season has been a bit of a rollercoaster—brilliant one moment, baffling the next. Then you have the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, a team that somehow manages to look like a Super Bowl contender and a rebuilding squad in the same sixty minutes of football.
When the 49ers vs Tampa Bay Buccaneers matchup kicked off, the narrative was supposed to be about Christian McCaffrey’s big return. Honestly, though? The real story was much messier. It was a game defined by missed kicks, sideline shoves, and Baker Mayfield doing things with a football that defy physics.
The McCaffrey Factor and the Offensive Grind
Everyone was staring at number 23. Christian McCaffrey hadn't touched the field since the Super Bowl because of some nasty Achilles tendinitis. Kyle Shanahan didn't ease him in, either. He gave him the ball on the very first play.
McCaffrey finished with 107 total yards, which sounds great on paper, but he looked a little rusty. He averaged about 3 yards a carry. That’s not exactly "CMC" levels of dominance. But his presence changed the gravity of the field. Suddenly, the Bucs had to respect the check-down, which opened up lanes for Brock Purdy to slice through the secondary.
Purdy was efficient, throwing for 353 yards. No interceptions. He looked like the guy who led them to the Super Bowl, especially when he found Ricky Pearsall for a 46-yard touchdown. You have to love that story—Pearsall getting his first NFL score just months after surviving a shooting. It’s the kind of thing that makes you remember these guys are human.
Why the Scoreboard Didn't Tell the Whole Story
If you just looked at the 23-20 final score, you'd think it was a clean, back-and-forth battle. It wasn't. It was chaotic.
Jake Moody, the 49ers kicker, had a day he’d probably like to forget—until the very last second. He missed three field goals. Three! One was wide left from 49 yards, another from 50, and then he pushed a 44-yarder wide right with three minutes left.
The tension on the sideline was real. Deebo Samuel actually got into it with long snapper Taybor Pepper and Moody after that third miss. Cameras caught a bit of a shove. People on social media went nuts, calling it a "meltdown," but in a locker room that competitive, sometimes things boil over.
On the other side, Baker Mayfield was basically a magician. There was this one play where Nick Bosa—who is basically a human mountain—had Mayfield wrapped up. Baker somehow stayed upright and flipped the ball to Rachaad White for a first down. It shouldn't have worked. The math doesn't add up. But that's the Baker experience. He keeps the Bucs in games they have no business being in.
📖 Related: Jordan Spieth Score Today: Why the 2026 Sony Open Debut is Making Us Nervous
Breaking Down the All-Time Series
The 49ers vs Tampa Bay Buccaneers rivalry isn't exactly a rivalry in the traditional sense, mostly because San Francisco has historically dominated.
- Total Meetings: 35 games.
- San Francisco Wins: 25.
- Tampa Bay Wins: 10.
- Recent Trend: The 49ers have won four of the last five.
Historically, the Bucs’ only real "claim" over the Niners is in the postseason. They’ve met twice in the playoffs, and Tampa won both times. But in the regular season? It’s usually a bloodbath for the Bucs. This 2024 game was actually one of the closest we've seen in a while, largely because the Niners kept shooting themselves in the foot with penalties and special teams blunders.
Defensive Standouts and Statistical Oddities
While the quarterbacks get the headlines, the defenses were doing some heavy lifting.
The Bucs were missing Mike Evans, which is like a chef trying to cook without salt. They still managed to keep it close by focusing on the run. Bucky Irving has been a revelation for them. He’s got this low center of gravity that makes him a nightmare to tackle in the open field.
Meanwhile, Fred Warner was doing Fred Warner things. He’s basically a heat-seeking missile at linebacker. The 49ers' defense held the Bucs to just 215 total yards. Think about that. Tampa had almost half the yardage of San Francisco but was tied with 41 seconds left. That tells you everything you need to know about how many opportunities the Niners wasted.
The Redemption Arc at Raymond James
With 41 seconds left, the game was tied 20-20. Brock Purdy had to get his team into field goal range. Again.
He went 4-for-4 on that final drive. He found Jauan Jennings—who had a massive game with 93 yards—and Pearsall to move the chains. They set up Moody for a 44-yarder. Same distance as the one he just missed.
He nailed it.
The walk-off win moved the 49ers to 5-4 and kept their playoff hopes alive. It was a "relief" win more than a "statement" win. For the Bucs, it was their fourth straight loss, dropping them to 4-6. Todd Bowles looked like a man who had seen this movie before—playing hard enough to win, but not smart enough to finish.
✨ Don't miss: Man Utd Spurs Live: Why This Matchup Just Hits Different in 2026
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're looking at what this game means for the future of both franchises, here are the real takeaways:
- Trust the Process with McCaffrey: Don't panic about his low yards-per-carry. The fact that he played almost the entire game without a setback is the win. His efficiency will return as his timing improves.
- Monitor the 49ers Special Teams: Jake Moody is talented, but three misses in one game is a mental hurdle. Watch how they handle long-snapping and holding in the coming weeks; chemistry there is clearly fragile.
- The Bucs Need a Secondary Option: With Mike Evans out, they are too reliant on Baker Mayfield’s "hero ball." They need a consistent threat on the perimeter to take the pressure off Bucky Irving and the run game.
- Purdy is Elite Under Pressure: Despite the noise, Brock Purdy remains one of the best "clutch" quarterbacks in the league. His ability to ignore the chaos and execute a 40-second drill is why the Niners are still dangerous.
The 49ers eventually look to stabilize their season, while the Bucs have to find a way to stop the bleeding before the NFC South slips away from them entirely.