You’d think a guy who stands 6-foot-7 and hits 50 home runs like it’s a casual weekend hobby wouldn’t be "underrated."
But honestly, he is.
We’ve reached a point with Aaron Judge of the Yankees where his greatness has become a sort of background noise. It’s expected. When he launches a 450-foot bomb into the bleachers at the Stadium, fans don't drop their hot dogs in shock anymore. They just nod.
"Oh, Judge did it again."
That’s the danger of being this good for this long. As of early 2026, Judge isn't just a power hitter; he’s a three-time American League MVP (2022, 2024, 2025) who just keeps getting better at the age of 33. Most players start their "graceful decline" here. Judge? He just won his first batting title last year by hitting .331.
The Evolution of the 99
When Judge first showed up in 2016 and 2017, he was basically a human skyscraper with a strikeout problem. He’d swing so hard the air in the Bronx would move, but he’d miss. A lot.
Fast forward to now. He’s the most disciplined hitter in the game.
Opposing pitchers are terrified of him, and for good reason. In 2025, his OBP was a staggering .457. That’s basically reaching base half the time you step up to the plate. It’s video game stuff. If you throw it in the zone, he hits it into another zip code. If you throw it outside, he just stares at you until you walk him.
The narrative used to be that he was "just a slugger." That’s dead. He’s a pure hitter who happens to have the strength of a Norse god.
Why the 2024 Season Changed Everything
A lot of people forget how 2024 started. It was ugly. Through April of that year, Judge was hitting .207. People were whispering about his big toe injury from 2023. Was he washed? Was the $360 million contract a mistake?
Then he went on a tear that literally changed the record books.
He became the fastest player in MLB history to reach 300 career home runs. He finished that year with 58 homers and 144 RBIs, leading the Yankees back to the World Series for the first time in 15 years. They didn't win it all—falling to the Dodgers—but Judge proved he could carry the heaviest franchise in sports on his back.
The "Captain" Factor
Being the Captain of the New York Yankees is different. It’s not just a patch on a jersey. It’s a job description that involves managing the most intense media market on the planet.
🔗 Read more: Who Is the Cleveland Browns Starting Quarterback? What Most Fans Get Wrong Right Now
Judge is the 16th captain in team history. He’s the first since Derek Jeter.
Think about that pressure.
Jeter was "The Captain." He was the gold standard for leadership. But Brian Cashman has gone on record saying Judge might be the most inclusive and effective leader the team has had in decades. He doesn't lead by shouting; he leads by being the first guy in the building and the last one to leave.
Leadership in the Clubhouse
He’s the guy who goes to dinner with the new arrivals. When the Yankees traded for Juan Soto, Judge didn't see him as a threat to his "alpha" status. He saw him as a partner. They became a duo that rivaled the legendary Mantle and Maris.
And it's not just the superstars. Judge spends time with the rookies, the guys on ten-day contracts, the bullpen arms who just got called up from Scranton. He protects them. He’s been known to stare down cameras or talk to the media specifically to take the heat off a teammate who had a bad night.
The Physical Toll and the "Big Toe"
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room: health.
When you’re 282 pounds, your body takes a beating. The 2023 toe injury—the one where he ran through a fence at Dodger Stadium—is something he has to manage every single day. He’s said it himself: "It's going to be a constant maintenance for the rest of my career."
He’s playing smarter now.
You’ll notice he doesn't dive into walls quite as recklessly. He’s moved from center field back to right field more frequently to save his legs. But even with the "limitations," he played 158 games in 2024 and stayed just as durable in 2025.
The Mental Game
Judge uses a specialized mental conditioning routine. Before every game, he watches a highlight reel of himself. It’s not an ego thing. It’s about "visualizing success." He watches himself making perfect swings, making diving catches, and trotting the bases.
It clearly works.
📖 Related: Who Did The Dallas Cowboys Play Yesterday? Why MetLife Was A Nightmare
What’s Next: The 2026 World Baseball Classic
As we sit here in January 2026, the buzz isn't just about Spring Training. It’s about the World Baseball Classic.
Judge was recently named the Captain of Team USA.
He skipped the last WBC to focus on the Yankees. This time, he’s leading the charge. We’re likely looking at a collision course with Japan and Shohei Ohtani. It’s the matchup the world wants to see: the two greatest players of this generation facing off with national pride on the line.
For Judge, a gold medal would be another jewel in a crown that’s only missing one thing.
A ring.
The Legacy Question
Aaron Judge is signed through 2031. He’ll be 39 when that contract ends.
Right now, he has 368 career home runs. If he stays healthy—and that’s a big "if" for a man his size—he’s looking at 500 home runs easily. Maybe 600. He’s already a Hall of Famer in the eyes of many scouts.
But in New York, stats are secondary to championships.
He knows it. The fans know it.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're following Judge's career or looking at it from an investment perspective, here is what actually matters right now:
- Watch the Strikeout Rate: Judge's true "secret sauce" isn't his power; it's his eye. As long as his walk rate stays above 15%, he remains the most dangerous hitter in baseball because he forces pitchers to play his game.
- The WBC Impact: His sports card market and global "brand" are expected to spike during the 2026 WBC. Being the face of Team USA puts him in front of an international audience that doesn't always watch 162 Yankees games.
- Health over Homers: Don't obsess over him hitting 60 homers again. If Judge plays 145+ games, the Yankees win the division. His value is in his availability.
- Foundation Focus: If you want to see the "real" Judge, look at his ALL RISE Foundation. He’s deeply involved in youth literacy and leadership programs in California and New York. It’s not just a tax write-off; it’s his actual passion.
Aaron Judge isn't just the biggest guy on the field. He’s the smartest. And in 2026, he’s still the mountain everyone else is trying to climb.