The era of Aaron Rodgers and Jets football was supposed to be a Broadway revival. Instead, it felt like a gritty, low-budget indie film that ended with the lead actor walking off set and joining a different production in Pittsburgh.
Honestly, looking back at the timeline from 2023 to early 2026, the narrative is messy. People love to say it was a total failure. But was it? It’s complicated. If you look at the raw numbers from the 2024 season—Rodgers' only full year in green—he actually put up some of the best passing stats in franchise history. 3,897 yards. 28 touchdowns. In the context of a team that has historically struggled to find a steady hand under center, those are borderline legendary figures.
Yet, the Jets finished that year 5-12.
That is the paradox. You have a four-time MVP playing at a high level individually, while the collective ship just... sank. It wasn't just the Achilles tear in 2023 that defined this era. It was the strange, simmering tension between a legendary quarterback and an organization that seemed to be in "complete disarray," according to various league agents. By the time Rodgers took his final snaps in New York and headed to the Steelers for the 2025 season, the breakup wasn't just inevitable; it was a relief for everyone involved.
The 2024 Season: A Statistical Mirage?
When we talk about Aaron Rodgers and Jets history, 2024 is the only real data point we have for a healthy season. And it’s a weird one.
Rodgers started all 17 games. He stayed upright after the devastating 2023 injury. He even managed to crack the top three in the Jets' all-time single-season leaderboards for passing yards and touchdowns. If you were just looking at a box score, you’d think the Jets were a playoff lock.
They weren't.
The offense finished 24th in the league in yards per game. Why? Because the "magic" wasn't there. The explosive, off-platform plays that defined his time in Green Bay were replaced by a shorter, more conservative passing attack. His average target depth dropped. He was sacked 40 times. The Jets’ offensive line struggled to protect a 40-year-old quarterback who, understandably, wasn't as mobile as he used to be.
It’s easy to blame Rodgers. It’s also easy to blame the coaching staff. The reality is likely a mix of both. Reports surfaced about "leaks in the boat" and a building where the vibe was, frankly, terrible. Players like Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall were producing, but the team couldn't string together wins. They lost five straight at one point, including a demoralizing 25-22 loss to the Patriots.
By the end of that 5-12 campaign, the writing wasn't just on the wall; it was neon.
The Divorce and the Pittsburgh Pivot
The jump to the Pittsburgh Steelers for the 2025 season felt like a classic "it's not me, it's you" moment.
Rodgers didn't just leave; he made sure to highlight the difference in culture. He praised Mike Tomlin and the Steelers organization for being "the antithesis" of the Jets. He talked about how nice it was to be in a place with "no leaks in the boat."
It’s a pointed jab.
And for a while, it looked like he was right. In Pittsburgh, he led the team to a 10-7 record and an AFC North title. He looked rejuvenated. But then, the 2025 playoffs happened. Facing the Houston Texans in the Wild Card round, Rodgers struggled mightily. 17 of 33 passes. 146 yards. No touchdowns. A QBR of 14.3.
It was a reminder that even for a first-ballot Hall of Famer, Father Time eventually catches up. The Steelers were bounced 30-6, and Rodgers' season ended with him taking one last "subtle jab" at the Jets, stating he was thankful to have played for two "special places"—meaning the Packers and Steelers—pointedly leaving New York out of the list.
What the Jets Gained (and Lost)
- The Financial Hit: The Jets are still dealing with the fallout. They have a massive dead money hit of $35 million on their 2026 cap because of the way the contract was structured.
- Draft Capital: They traded away multiple picks, including a conditional second-rounder that would have been a first if Rodgers had played more in 2023.
- Culture Shift: The Rodgers experiment forced the Jets to go "all in." When that failed, it led to a total clearing of the house, including the arrival of Aaron Glenn as head coach to pick up the pieces.
Why the Experiment Failed
Maybe it was never going to work.
The Jets tried to build a "Packers East" environment, hiring Nathaniel Hackett and bringing in Rodgers' friends like Allen Lazard. But you can't just transplant a culture. The Jets were a team with a long history of losing and a hungry, young core. Rodgers was a veteran with a very specific way of doing things.
When the wins didn't come, the "outsized influence" Rodgers had over the organization became a talking point rather than a benefit. Agents and insiders spoke of a building in disarray.
Basically, the Jets bet the house on a single window. And then the window got smashed four plays into the first game of 2023. They spent the next two years trying to fix the glass, but the house was already cold.
Moving Forward: The Jets After Rodgers
Today, in early 2026, the Jets are finally looking toward the future. The Rodgers era is officially a closed chapter, albeit an expensive one. With young stars like Sauce Gardner and Garrett Wilson still in their prime, the focus has shifted to "sustainable team building" rather than the "quick fix" of a superstar veteran.
Rodgers himself is at a crossroads. He’s 42. He just finished a season where he ranked 29th out of 38 qualified quarterbacks in QBR. He’s mentioned that retirement is a conversation he’ll have with his wife, Brittani.
If this is the end, the Jets' stint will be remembered as a strange, star-crossed detour. A "what if" that produced some great stats, a lot of headlines, and very few wins.
👉 See also: Week 15 RB Rankings: Why Your Playoff Life Depends on These Matchups
Lessons for the Future
- Don't build for one person: The "wish list" of players and coaches tailored specifically to one veteran rarely works long-term.
- Health is the ultimate wildcard: You can't plan for an Achilles tear, but you can plan for the depth behind a 40-year-old QB.
- Culture is top-down: If there are "leaks in the boat," no amount of talent under center can plug them.
To truly understand the impact of the last three years, keep a close eye on the Jets' 2026 draft and free agency strategy. They are currently rebuilding their cap health after the $35 million dead money hit, and the focus is clearly on younger, more mobile assets at the quarterback position. The "win-now" pressure has been replaced by a "build-right" mentality.
If you're following the team's recovery, watch the upcoming NFL Combine reports to see how they prioritize offensive line depth—a glaring hole that contributed to the stagnation of the Rodgers era. This transition period will define whether the Jets have actually learned from the "Broadway Aaron" saga or if they're destined to repeat the cycle with the next available veteran.