When the bell rang in Miami Beach on February 25, 1964, almost nobody in the building thought Cassius Clay was going to leave with his head attached to his shoulders. Sonny Liston wasn't just a champion; he was a walking nightmare. He had hands the size of dinner plates and a stare that supposedly made grown men cry in the locker room.
The betting odds were 8-to-1 against the young guy from Louisville. People were literally worried Clay might get killed.
But history isn't written by the bookies. It’s written by the guy who doesn't know when to shut up. That night, the Ali vs Liston saga didn't just change boxing; it shattered the way we look at athletes forever. If you think it was just about a "phantom punch" or a fixed fight, you're missing the real story.
The Night the Bear Met the Butterfly
Cassius Clay—who would become Muhammad Ali just days later—wasn't just fast. He was "scared-to-death" fast, at least at first.
In the opening round, Ali looked like he was running for his life. Honestly, he kind of was. Liston came out swinging like he wanted to end the world. But then something weird happened. Liston kept missing. He lunged, he puffed, and he swung at air. By the end of the first three minutes, the "Big Ugly Bear" looked tired.
Then came the "juice."
In the fourth round, Ali returned to his corner screaming that he couldn't see. His eyes were stinging. It’s one of those moments in sports history that sounds like a movie script. His trainer, Angelo Dundee, basically shoved him back out there, telling him to just run. There’s been a ton of talk over the years about Liston’s corner putting liniment on his gloves to blind the kid. Whether it was intentional or just a messy accident from treating Liston’s own cuts, Ali fought round five almost completely blind.
And he survived.
By round six, the stinging stopped. Ali started landing at will. When the bell rang for the seventh, Liston just... stayed there. He sat on his stool and quit. The world was in shock.
That Infamous Second Fight in Lewiston
If the first fight was an upset, the rematch on May 25, 1965, was a circus.
It didn't even happen in a big city. Because of all the drama surrounding the first fight and Ali’s conversion to the Nation of Islam, most states wouldn't touch the rematch. They ended up in a high school hockey rink in Lewiston, Maine.
You’ve seen the photo. It’s the most famous picture in sports: Ali standing over a fallen Liston, muscles tensed, screaming at him to "Get up and fight, sucker!"
That moment happened less than two minutes into the first round.
The "Phantom Punch" is what they called it. Most of the crowd didn't even see it land. Even today, if you watch the grainy footage, it looks like a short, chopping right hand that barely grazed Liston's chin. Liston went down, rolled around, and the referee—Jersey Joe Walcott—lost his mind. He never actually counted Liston out because he was too busy trying to get Ali to a neutral corner.
Was it a Fix?
Look, people love a good conspiracy. Liston had ties to the mob. That’s not a secret; it’s a fact. Frankie Carbo and Blinky Palermo basically owned his contract early on. Some say the mob wanted Liston to lose so they could cash in on the long odds for Ali. Others think Liston was terrified of the Nation of Islam after Malcolm X had been assassinated just months earlier.
But if you talk to boxing purists, they’ll tell you something else.
👉 See also: Who is the starting QB for the Seahawks? What the Depth Chart Really Looks Like
Liston was old. His shoulders were shot. He hadn't trained right. When that short right hand hit him—an "anchor punch" Ali claimed he learned from Stepin Fetchit—it might have actually hurt. Or maybe Liston just saw a way out and took it. Either way, the Ali vs Liston rematch remains the most scrutinized two minutes in the history of the ring.
Why This Rivalry Still Matters in 2026
We’re still talking about this 60-plus years later because it wasn't just about boxing.
- The Birth of the Icon: This was the moment Cassius Clay died and Muhammad Ali was born. He proved that an athlete could be political, religious, and loud without apologizing.
- The Death of the "Old Guard": Sonny Liston represented the old-school, mob-controlled era of boxing. Ali represented the future.
- The Psychological War: Ali showed that you could win a fight before you even stepped into the ring. He got inside Liston's head so deep that the champion was frustrated before the first bell even rang.
The tragedy of the whole thing is Sonny Liston. He was a man of incredible talent who was never really allowed to be anything other than a villain. He died a few years later in Las Vegas under mysterious circumstances, a lonely end for a guy who once ruled the world.
How to Understand the Legacy
If you really want to get what happened during the Ali vs Liston era, don't just look at the highlights. Look at the context. This was 1964 and 1965. The Civil Rights movement was exploding. The Vietnam War was looming.
Ali didn't just beat a boxer; he beat a system that told him to stay in his place.
If you’re a student of the game, watch the first fight in its entirety. Skip the "Phantom Punch" for a second and watch how Ali moves in the first meeting. It’s a masterclass in lateral movement. He turned the most feared puncher in history into a guy who looked like he’d never worn gloves before.
Your next move for digging deeper:
- Watch the raw footage of Round 1 (1964): Focus only on Ali's feet. Don't look at the punches. Watch how he keeps his lead foot outside Liston's to negate the power jab.
- Read "King of the World" by David Remnick: It’s arguably the best book ever written on the cultural shift that happened because of these two specific fights.
- Analyze the "Phantom Punch" in slow motion: Look for the "snap" in Liston's head. Whether he stayed down on purpose or not, the punch definitely connected with more force than the ringside reporters originally thought.
The Ali vs Liston fights weren't just sporting events; they were the hinges upon which the 20th century swung. Ali didn't just win a title; he changed the definition of what it means to be a champion.