You’ve finished the Common App personal statement. You’re exhausted. Then, you see the list of American University supplemental essays waiting for you on the portal. It’s usually just one or two prompts, but honestly, these can make or break your application more than the main essay ever could.
Why? Because American University (AU) is obsessed with fit. They don't just want smart kids; they want "Eagle" energy. If you write a generic "I like DC because politics" essay, you’re basically asking for a waitlist spot. I’ve seen brilliant students with 1500+ SAT scores get rejected because their supplements sounded like a brochure.
The "Why AU" Trap and How to Avoid It
Most people approach the American University supplemental essays by Googling "American University facts" and pasting in the first three things they find. Don't do that. The admissions officers already know they are located in Washington, D.C. They know they have a great School of International Service (SIS). Telling them what they already know is a waste of your word count.
🔗 Read more: Is the New Moon Eyeshadow Palette Actually Worth the Hype?
Specifics matter.
Think about the "Changemaker" culture. AU brands itself on this. But "being a changemaker" is a vague, annoying phrase if you don't back it up. You need to connect your past weird hobbies or local volunteer work to a specific AU resource. Maybe it’s the Antiracist Research & Policy Center or a very niche club like the AU Beekeeping Society.
If you’re applying to the School of Public Affairs, don't just say you want to study politics. Talk about the First-Year Seminar you saw in the course catalog that deals with a hyper-specific issue like urban transit or digital privacy. Show them you’ve actually spent twenty minutes on their website instead of just looking at photos of the quad on Instagram.
It’s About "The Why," Not "The What"
I once talked to a student who wanted to write about wanting to be a lawyer. Boring. Every third applicant to AU wants to be a lawyer or a diplomat. We dug deeper. It turned out she was obsessed with the ethics of AI in legal discovery. That’s an AU essay. It’s nerdy, it’s specific, and it connects to the interdisciplinary vibe the school loves.
The supplemental prompts change slightly year to year, but the core remains the same: How will you use our specific campus to change something?
AU is a "private university with a public soul." That’s their whole thing. Your essay needs to reflect that soul. If you’re a business major, talk about social entrepreneurship. If you’re a film major, talk about the power of documentary to shift public opinion.
Breaking Down the Common Prompts
Sometimes they ask about your community. Other times, it's just a straightforward "Why us?"
When they ask about community, they aren't looking for a list of your identities. They want to see how you interact with people who disagree with you. D.C. is a polarized place. AU wants to know if you can sit in a seminar room with someone from across the aisle and not lose your mind. Mentioning a time you navigated a difficult conversation in a club or at a job is gold here.
The DC Factor: A Blessing and a Curse
Living in the District is a massive part of the AU experience. You’re at the end of the Red Line. You’re near Tenleytown. You have access to the most powerful internship market in the world.
But here’s the kicker: AU wants to know you'll actually stay on campus too.
If your entire American University supplemental essays focus on how much you love the Smithsonian or the Capitol, the admissions team might wonder why you aren't just applying to George Washington University or Georgetown. You have to mention the AU-specific flavor. Mention the Auerbach Arena or the specific feel of the Kogod School of Business.
Highlight the "Wonk" identity. Years ago, AU leaned hard into the "Wonk" branding. It’s a bit dated now, but the spirit remains. They want people who are obsessively informed. If you can prove you’re a wonk about something—whether it’s 18th-century poetry or the mechanics of a supply chain—you’re in a good spot.
Facts and Realities of the AU Admissions Process
Let’s look at some actual numbers to give this context. For the Class of 2028, American University saw a significant number of applications, and their acceptance rate has hovered around 40-45% in recent years, though it gets much tighter for specific programs like the BA/JD 3-year program.
🔗 Read more: Sketch of a Witch: Why Your Drawings Always Look the Same (and How to Fix It)
- ED Advantage: If AU is your top choice, Early Decision is a huge boost. Their ED acceptance rate is significantly higher than Regular Decision.
- Test-Optional: AU is test-optional and has been for a long time. This means your supplements carry even more weight. If there’s no SAT score to look at, they are reading every word of that essay to see if you’re a "fit."
- Demonstrated Interest: AU cares about this. They track if you opened their emails, if you visited, and if your supplemental essay sounds like a template.
Writing Style: Keep It Real
Stop trying to sound like a textbook.
Admissions officers read hundreds of these a day. If you use words like "multifaceted" or "plethora," they will glaze over. Use your actual voice. Use short sentences. Use a fragment for emphasis. It’s okay.
A great way to test your essay is to read it out loud. Does it sound like you? Or does it sound like a robot trying to win a Pulitzer Prize? If it's the latter, delete it and start over. Talk about the time you failed at something. Talk about a specific conversation that changed your mind. AU loves intellectual humility.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- The "History Lesson": Don't spend half the essay talking about the history of the school. They know it.
- The "Resume Repeat": If it's on your honors list, don't just list it again in the essay. Tell the story behind the honor.
- The "Wrong School" Error: People literally forget to change the name of the school in their supplements. If you submit an essay to American University that mentions how much you love the "Hoya" spirit, you’re done. It happens more often than you think.
- Vagueness: Saying "I want to take advantage of the many internship opportunities in D.C." is meaningless. Saying "I want to intern at the Wilson Center to study transatlantic policy" is a plan.
The Hidden Power of the "Addendum"
Sometimes AU gives you space for "anything else." Use this wisely. If your grades dipped sophomore year because of a family situation, tell them. If you have a hobby that doesn't fit anywhere else—like you’re a competitive chess player or you restore vintage motorcycles—this is the place. It adds "texture" to your application.
AU is a school that values the "whole person." They are less likely to "stat-snub" you if your story is compelling.
Actionable Steps for Your AU Supplements
- Audit your "Why": Go through your draft and circle every sentence that could apply to any other university in D.C. Delete those sentences. Replace them with AU-specific programs, professors, or traditions.
- Find a Professor: Look up the faculty in your intended major. Read a summary of their recent research. Mentioning how Professor X’s work on [Topic] aligns with your interests shows a level of depth that 90% of applicants won't bother with.
- Check the "Changemaker" Box: Ensure your essay highlights an active role. You shouldn't just be a student who "learns"; you should be a student who "does."
- Proofread for Tone: Ask a friend to read it. If they say, "This sounds like a brochure," you have work to do. If they say, "This sounds exactly like you talking about your favorite subject," you’re on the right track.
- The "So What?" Test: After every paragraph, ask yourself "So what?" If the paragraph doesn't explain why you’d be a great addition to the AU campus, it’s filler.
The American University supplemental essays are your chance to move from a pile of numbers to a living, breathing human being that an admissions officer actually wants to meet. Don't waste it by being boring. Be specific, be passionate, and for heaven's sake, be yourself.
Success here isn't about being the "perfect" candidate. It's about being the right candidate for AU’s unique, politically charged, service-oriented culture.
Get to work.
Final Checklist Before You Hit Submit
- Did you mention at least two AU-specific resources (clubs, classes, centers)?
- Is your tone conversational yet professional?
- Did you avoid the "D.C. is the capital of the world" clichés?
- Does the essay reflect the "Changemaker" or "Wonk" spirit without being cringe?
- Have you verified that "American University" is the only school mentioned?
Focus on these, and your application will stand out in a sea of generic "I love politics" submissions. AU is looking for the spark—find yours and put it on the page.