Google made a mess. Honestly, that’s the easiest way to describe the transition between the classic three-button layout we all loved and the modern, fluid gestures we use on the Pixel 9 today. In the middle of that awkward puberty phase was Android 9 Pie. It introduced the Android P navigation bar, a weird, pill-shaped hybrid that tried to please everyone and ended up confusing quite a few. It was the era of the "pill."
Remember the back button? It didn't even stay on the screen half the time. It was a ghost.
When Dave Burke took the stage at Google I/O 2018, the tech world was obsessed with the iPhone X. Apple had killed the home button, and Google felt the heat. They needed a "modern" way to navigate tall screens, but they weren't ready to go full gesture yet. So, we got this middle-ground solution. It replaced the square "Recents" button with a gesture, kept a tiny back arrow that only appeared when needed, and turned the home circle into a little white lozenge. It was a bold move. It was also incredibly polarizing.
The Mechanics of the Android P Navigation Bar
The "pill" wasn't just a visual change; it changed how we interacted with the kernel of the OS. In the old days, you tapped. Tap home for home, tap square for apps. Simple. The Android P navigation bar asked you to slide. You’d flick the pill up to see your recent apps. You’d flick it further up to see your app drawer. This felt intuitive to some, but to others, it was like learning to ride a bike with one training wheel missing.
One of the most underrated (and actually useful) features was the "scrubbing" gesture. You could press down on the pill and slide your thumb to the right. This allowed you to scroll through your open apps like a Rolodex. If you were quick, it was faster than anything we have now. But if your thumb slipped? You’d end up three apps past where you wanted to be, staring at a half-loaded Instagram feed instead of your work email.
Why Google Kept the Back Button
This is where things got clunky. Google didn't have a side-swipe gesture for "back" yet. That didn't arrive until Android 10. So, the Android P navigation bar had this asymmetrical look. If you were on your home screen, you just saw the pill. Open an app, and suddenly a small, minimalist back arrow would materialize on the left.
It looked lopsided. Design purists hated it. From a functional standpoint, it meant your thumb still had to travel to the bottom corner for one specific action while using gestures for everything else. It was a half-measure. It’s the primary reason many users immediately went into settings to see if they could toggle the old three buttons back on. On the Pixel 3, you actually couldn't—Google forced the pill on you.
The Technical Shift Behind the UI
Under the hood, this wasn't just about pretty icons. Android Pie was a massive shift in how the system handled "Recents." Before Pie, the overview screen was handled by the SystemUI. With the Android P navigation bar, Google moved the horizontal app switcher into the Pixel Launcher (or whatever default launcher you used).
This is why, if you ever tried to use a third-party launcher like Nova or Action Launcher back in 2018, the animations felt janky. The "handshake" between the navigation bar and the launcher was broken. It took years for Google to fix the gesture API for developers who didn't want to use the stock Google setup. This technical debt is something power users still talk about on subreddits like r/Android.
Comparison: Android P vs. Modern Android 14/15
If you pick up a Pixel 3 today running Pie, the navigation feels sluggish compared to the seamless swipes of a modern device.
In Android 14, the "pill" is gone. We have a thin line, or "handle," and the back gesture is a universal swipe from either edge of the screen. It's symmetrical. It's clean. But the Android P navigation bar had one advantage: it didn't interfere with "hamburger" menus. You know those three-line menus in the top left of apps? In modern Android, trying to swipe those open often triggers the "back" gesture instead. In the Android P era, that was never an issue because the back button was still a dedicated tap target at the bottom.
Sometimes, "old" isn't "worse." It's just different.
How to Get the Pill Back (If You’re Into That)
Surprisingly, there is still a small cult following for this specific era of navigation. People liked the tactile feel of the pill. If you are on a modern device, you usually can't just flip a switch to bring back the Android P navigation bar. Google stripped the code out of the AOSP (Android Open Source Project) over time to lighten the system.
However, if you are rooted or using a custom ROM like LineageOS, you can often find "legacy navigation" settings. There are also third-party apps like "Navigation Gestures" by XDA, though they've become harder to use as Google tightens permissions on the Accessibility API. Most people just move on. It’s easier to adapt to the new way than to fight the OS.
The Legacy of the 2018 Design Language
We can’t talk about the navigation bar without talking about Material Design 2.0. This was the era of white backgrounds, rounded corners, and "Google Sans" font. The pill was the centerpiece of this aesthetic. It represented a shift toward a more "organic" UI.
Google was trying to make phones feel less like computers and more like tools.
The Android P navigation bar was the first time we saw the "Smart Selection" feature in the overview screen. You could flick up to the pill, see your apps, and then long-press text inside a window without even switching to that app. This was genius. It’s one of the few features from that era that has survived and improved in the current builds of Android. It showed that the navigation bar wasn't just a way to move around; it was a portal to the phone’s intelligence.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Best Apache Attack Helicopter Pictures: What Aviation Photographers Actually Look For
Common Frustrations and Fixes
If you're stuck on an older device or a specific enterprise build that still uses this layout, you might run into the "disappearing back button" bug. Usually, this happens when an app doesn't report its state correctly to the OS. A quick fix is usually just swiping up to the recents and back down, which forces the UI to redraw.
Another gripe was the height. The Android P navigation bar took up a lot of screen real estate. Unlike the modern "thin line" gesture bar, the Pie bar was a thick horizontal strip of black or white. It felt like wasted space on the new bezel-less displays that were coming out at the time, like the OnePlus 6T.
Moving Forward
Looking back, Android Pie was the "Windows Vista" of mobile operating systems—a necessary, if awkward, bridge to something better. It taught Google that users didn't want a mix of buttons and swipes. They wanted one or the other. By the time Android 10 rolled around, the pill was mostly dead, replaced by the fully gestural system we know today.
But the pill paved the way. It tested the waters for haptic feedback during swipes. It introduced us to the idea that the bottom of our screen could be a multi-functional slider rather than a static row of icons.
Actionable Insights for Modern Users:
- Check your settings: If you're on a device running Android 10 through 15 and hate gestures, you can almost always return to the "3-button navigation" in Settings > System > Gestures.
- Master the "Quick Switch": Even without the P pill, you can swipe horizontally along the very bottom edge of your screen to jump between apps. This is the direct evolution of the P "scrubbing" gesture.
- Third-party launchers: If you use Nova Launcher or Niagara, be aware that gesture navigation can still occasionally glitch. If you want the smoothest experience, the "3-button" layout is still the most stable for non-stock launchers.
- App Compatibility: If you find the "back" gesture annoying when trying to open side menus, try swiping at a 45-degree angle or using two fingers. This bypasses the system gesture and tells the app you're trying to open its menu.
The Android P navigation bar was a weird experiment, a transitionary fossil in the history of mobile tech. It wasn't perfect, but it was the start of the fluid, fast Android we use today. If you still have a phone with the pill, enjoy the scrubbing—it's a piece of UI history that we probably won't see again.