If you grew up in the 1950s, you didn't just watch TV; you lived it. And for a lot of little girls—and plenty of boys, too—there was one person who mattered more than anyone else in the Wild West. Her name was Gail Davis, but to millions of fans, she was simply Annie Oakley.
The Annie Oakley TV show cast didn't just create a Western; they built the first real female-led action series in television history. It was a big deal. Before Gail Davis stepped into those fringed buckskins, Westerns were a man’s world. You had Roy Rogers, Gene Autry, and Hopalong Cassidy. Then came Annie, pigtails flying, outshooting every outlaw who dared step into the fictional town of Diablo, Arizona.
But here is the thing: if you go back and watch the show now, you might realize it wasn't exactly a documentary. In fact, it basically ignored almost every real fact about the historical Annie Oakley’s life.
👉 See also: Why The Hollow 2016 Still Creeps People Out
The Core Trio: Who Actually Ran Diablo?
The show centered on a very specific dynamic. You had the sharpshooter, the lawman, and the kid brother. It was a formula that worked for 81 episodes between 1954 and 1957.
Gail Davis as Annie Oakley
Gail Davis wasn't just some actress who learned to hold a gun for a role. She was a legitimate rider and a crack shot in real life. Gene Autry—the "Singing Cowboy" himself—discovered her. He once said that while many girls could ride and many could act, finding one who could do both was nearly impossible until he met Davis.
She was tiny. Barely five feet tall and under 100 pounds. But on screen? She was a giant. She did most of her own stunts, which was almost unheard of for women in the mid-50s. She became such a symbol of the "cowgirl" image that she actually spent the rest of her life being Annie. Even after the show ended, she toured with Autry’s rodeo, billed as the legendary sharpshooter.
Brad Johnson as Deputy Sheriff Lofty Craig
Every hero needs a sidekick, or in this case, a "silent suitor." Brad Johnson played Lofty Craig. Lofty was the muscle. While Annie was busy outthinking the bad guys or shooting the guns out of their hands, Lofty handled the "fisticuffs."
There was always this subtle, wholesome romantic tension between Annie and Lofty. It never really went anywhere—this was 1950s TV, after all—but you knew they had each other's backs. Sadly, Brad Johnson passed away at the relatively young age of 56 in 1981, leaving behind a legacy as the dependable lawman of Diablo.
👉 See also: Fargo TV Series on FX: Why This "True Story" Is Still the Best Thing on Television
Jimmy Hawkins as Tagg Oakley
Then there was Tagg. He was the "little brother" who was always getting into trouble or trying to help when he should have been staying in town. Jimmy Hawkins played Tagg in 80 of the 81 episodes.
Interestingly, if you watch the pilot episode, "Bull's Eye," you’ll see a different face. Billy Gray (who later became famous as Bud on Father Knows Best) played Tagg first. He jumped ship for the other show, and Hawkins stepped in. It turned out to be a career-defining move for Hawkins, who later moved into producing and even wrote books about It's a Wonderful Life.
What Most People Get Wrong About the History
Honestly, the biggest misconception about the Annie Oakley TV show cast and characters is that they represented the real woman. They didn't. Not even close.
- The Real Annie Oakley had no "Tagg." The historical Annie (born Phoebe Ann Mosey) had many siblings, but "Tagg" was a complete invention of the writers to give the show a "family" feel.
- The Marriage. The real Annie Oakley was famously married to Frank Butler, a marksman she beat in a shooting match. In the show, Frank doesn't exist. Instead, we get the "silent suitor" Lofty Craig.
- The Location. The show is set in Diablo, Arizona. The real Annie Oakley was a star of Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show and lived much of her life in the East and Midwest.
The show was produced by Gene Autry's Flying A Productions. They weren't looking for a biography; they were looking for a hero. They wanted someone who could teach kids about "honor, dignity, and courage."
The Supporting Players You Might Recognize
While the main trio stayed the same, the guest stars were a "who’s who" of Western character actors. You’d see faces like Fess Parker (before he was Davy Crockett) playing a newspaper editor, or Stanley Andrews as the hotel owner.
Even the horses were part of the cast. Annie rode a Palomino named Target. Tagg had a horse named Pixie, and Lofty rode Forest. In the world of 1950s Westerns, the horse was often just as famous as the actor.
A Lasting Legacy in a Man’s World
Gail Davis once mentioned that her favorite part of playing Annie was the letters from young girls. They finally had someone to look up to who wasn't just a "damsel in distress." She proved a woman could run a ranch, take care of her brother, and keep the peace in a rough territory without losing her "ladylike" charm.
It’s easy to dismiss these old black-and-white shows as cheesy. But at the time, this was groundbreaking. When the show went into syndication, it made over $10 million in merchandise sales in 1955 alone. That’s massive. We’re talking lunchboxes, cowgirl outfits, and cap guns.
How to Revisit the World of Diablo
If you’re looking to dive back into the series or see the Annie Oakley TV show cast in action, here is how to get the most out of it:
- Look for the Colorized Episodes: While originally shot in black and white, several episodes have been colorized, which really brings the Alabama Hills (where it was filmed) to life.
- Check the Pilot: Compare Jimmy Hawkins to Billy Gray. It’s a fun piece of TV trivia to see how the "brother" dynamic changed between the very first episode and the rest of the series.
- The Andy Griffith Connection: For a real treat, find Gail Davis’s final acting appearance. She appeared in a 1961 episode of The Andy Griffith Show titled "The Perfect Female." She plays—you guessed it—a sharpshooter who outshoots Andy.
The show officially ended its run in 1957, but it lived on for decades in reruns. It remains a snapshot of a specific era in American television where the lines between "hero" and "role model" were one and the same.
If you want to understand the impact of the show, look up the National Cowgirl Hall of Fame. Gail Davis was inducted there not just because she was an actress, but because she became the embodiment of the Western spirit for an entire generation of women who were told they couldn't play with the boys. She proved they could. And she did it with a pair of pigtails and a .22 rifle.
To explore more about this era of television, your next step should be researching the production history of Flying A Productions. Understanding how Gene Autry built his TV empire provides essential context for why shows like Annie Oakley and The Range Rider looked and felt so distinct from the gritty Westerns that followed in the 1960s.