You know those days when you’re driving through central Jersey, specifically that stretch near the Turnpike where everything starts to look like a blur of suburban strip malls and brick storefronts, and you just want a meal that doesn't taste like it came out of a corporate freezer? That's basically the vibe surrounding Anthony's Chicken & Grill Hightstown NJ. It isn't trying to be a Michelin-star bistro or a high-concept fusion experiment. It’s a local staple. A place where the scent of charcoal and marinated poultry hits you before you even kill the ignition. Honestly, if you live anywhere near East Windsor or Hightstown, you’ve likely seen the sign a thousand times, but there’s a nuance to what they do that keeps people coming back for years.
It’s about the grill.
Specifically, it’s about that intersection of Peruvian-style rotisserie and a broader American grill menu that somehow manages to satisfy both the person craving a salad and the person who wants to eat half a chicken with their bare hands.
What's Actually on the Menu at Anthony's Chicken & Grill Hightstown NJ?
If you walk into Anthony’s expecting a five-page book of options, you’re missing the point. They keep it focused. The star of the show is the charcoal-broiled chicken. This isn't the limp, salty bird you find under heat lamps at the grocery store. We’re talking about skin that’s been rendered until it’s thin and flavorful, with meat that actually holds onto its juice because of the way they manage the heat.
The menu leans heavily into the "Grill" part of its name. You’ll find things like:
- Whole and half chickens served with those classic sides (rice, beans, yuca).
- Lomo Saltado, which is a nod to the Peruvian roots of this style of cooking—stir-fried beef with onions, tomatoes, and fries.
- Classic American fare like burgers and wraps for the kids or the less adventurous.
- Fresh salads that actually feel like they were chopped today, not three days ago.
One thing people get wrong is thinking it’s just a takeout joint. While the takeout business is booming, sitting in gives you that immediate heat from the kitchen that you just can't replicate after a 15-minute drive home in a cardboard box.
The Magic is in the Sauces
Let's talk about the green sauce. If you know, you know. Every serious rotisserie chicken spot in this vein lives or dies by its aji verde. At Anthony's Chicken & Grill Hightstown NJ, the sauce has that perfect kick—creamy but sharp enough to cut through the richness of the dark meat. It’s got cilantro, maybe some jalapeño, and a blend of spices that they probably wouldn't tell you even if you asked nicely.
Some people prefer the yellow sauce, which is milder and hit with a bit more of a mustard or mayo base, but the green is the true litmus test. Pro tip: ask for extra. You'll regret it if you don't.
Why Location Matters in Hightstown
Hightstown is a weird, wonderful little borough. It’s historic. It’s walkable. It’s surrounded by the sprawling suburban mass of East Windsor, but it maintains this distinct "small town" feel. Located right on Stockton Street, Anthony’s fits into that local fabric perfectly. It’s the kind of place where the staff might recognize your face after three visits.
In a world where private equity is buying up every fast-food chain and turning them into soulless kiosks, there’s something deeply comforting about a grill where you can see the flames and hear the clinking of tongs.
Is it Healthy?
Sorta. It can be. That’s the beauty of it. If you grab a half chicken and swap the fries for a double order of salad or steamed vegetables, you’ve got a high-protein, relatively clean meal that beats a protein shake any day of the week. But, let's be real—those fries soak up the chicken drippings in the best way possible. It’s a balance.
✨ Don't miss: Why a Refrigerator Built into Cabinets is the Hardest Kitchen Decision You’ll Ever Make
Comparing Anthony’s to the Competition
New Jersey is arguably the rotisserie capital of the Northeast. You have Peruvian spots in Paterson, Elizabeth, and even further south. So, how does Anthony's Chicken & Grill Hightstown NJ stack up against the heavy hitters?
It holds its own because of consistency.
I’ve been to places where the chicken is incredible on a Tuesday and bone-dry on a Friday. Anthony’s seems to have their timing down to a science. They understand the turnover. They know when the lunch rush from the local offices is going to hit and when the family dinner crowd will start rolling in. That means the food isn't sitting. It's moving.
🔗 Read more: Why the Nor-Tech 390 Sport Still Dominates the Center Console Market
The Service Vibe
Don't expect white tablecloths or a sommelier. This is counter-service-forward, efficient, and direct. It’s "What can I get for you?" and "Here’s your food." Some people find that jarring if they’re looking for a pampered experience, but if you’re hungry and want quality, it’s exactly what you need.
Actionable Tips for Your First Visit
If you're planning to head over to Stockton Street soon, here is the move to ensure you don't look like a total amateur:
- Check the Daily Specials: Sometimes they have items that aren't on the permanent board.
- The Yuca Swap: If you’re bored of regular fries, get the fried yuca. It’s starchier, crunchier, and stands up better to the sauces.
- Call Ahead: If you’re doing a large family order (like two whole chickens and four sides), call it in. It’s a popular spot, and the wait can creep up during the 6:00 PM rush.
- The Rice and Beans Factor: Don't skip these. They aren't an afterthought. The beans are seasoned well, and the rice is the perfect vessel for any leftover sauce.
A Quick Note on Parking
Parking in downtown Hightstown can be a bit of a localized nightmare depending on the time of day. There’s street parking, but you might have to walk a block or two. Just treat it as a way to burn off a few calories before you faceplant into a plate of Lomo Saltado.
Anthony's Chicken & Grill Hightstown NJ represents what local dining should be: reliable, flavorful, and rooted in the community. It’s not flashy, but it doesn't need to be. The smoke coming out of the vent tells you everything you need to know.
Next Steps for the Hungry Traveler
- Verify current hours: While they are generally open for lunch and dinner, it’s always smart to check their Google Business Profile or call (609) 443-4411 before making a long drive.
- Plan your order: Browse the digital menu if available to see the current pricing for family combos, as these offer the best value for groups of four or more.
- Explore the neighborhood: If you’re eating in, take a five-minute walk over to Peddie Lake afterward to catch the sunset; it’s one of the best views in the county.