You’re standing in front of the fridge, hand hovering over a cold can of seltzer. You’ve heard the rumors. Maybe your dentist mentioned enamel. Perhaps your aunt insists it causes "bone thinning." Or you're just wondering why you feel like a balloon after three glasses of Perrier. It’s a fair question: are sparkling drinks bad for you, or are they just water with a better personality?
Honestly, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. It depends entirely on what else is hiding in that can besides the bubbles.
The Science of the Fizz
Carbonated water is made by dissolving carbon dioxide gas into plain water under pressure. This creates carbonic acid ($H_2CO_3$). That’s what gives you that sharp, refreshing bite on the tongue. Some people think this acidity is basically liquid battery acid for your stomach. It isn't. Your stomach is already full of hydrochloric acid, which is way more intense than anything you’ll find in a Bottle of Topo Chico.
The bubbles are mostly harmless for your gut. In fact, a study published in the European Journal of Gastroenterology & Hepatology actually found that carbonated water helped people with indigestion and constipation. It kind of "wakes up" the digestive system. But for some, it’s a one-way ticket to Bloat Town. If you have Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), those bubbles can get trapped in your digestive tract, leading to some pretty uncomfortable gas.
Does Carbonation Trash Your Teeth?
This is usually the biggest concern people have when asking if are sparkling drinks bad for you. Here is the reality: plain sparkling water is slightly more acidic than flat water, but it’s nowhere near as destructive as soda or orange juice.
According to the American Dental Association (ADA), sparkling water is generally fine for your teeth. However—and this is a big however—the "flavor" matters. If your sparkling water is infused with citric acid for that "zesty lemon" taste, the erosion potential goes up significantly. Citric acid is a beast when it comes to enamel. If you’re sipping on flavored seltzers all day long without ever drinking plain water, you might be slowly softening your tooth surface.
Dr. Edmond Hewlett, a professor at the UCLA School of Dentistry, notes that while plain carbonated water is much safer than soda, the frequency of sipping matters most. If you take three hours to finish one can, your teeth are essentially sitting in an acidic bath the whole time.
The "Bone Thinning" Myth
Let's kill this one right now. There is zero credible evidence that plain carbonated water leaches calcium from your bones.
This myth started because of a 2006 study (the Framingham Osteoporosis Study) that linked cola consumption to lower bone mineral density in women. The researchers found that the phosphorus in colas was the likely culprit, not the carbonation itself. Phosphorus can interfere with calcium absorption if you aren't getting enough Vitamin D and calcium in your diet. Plain seltzer doesn't have phosphorus. Your skeleton is safe.
The Satiety Secret (and the Hunger Trap)
One weird thing about sparkling water is how it affects your appetite. For some, the volume of the gas makes them feel full. It’s a classic dieting trick—drink a big glass of sparkling water before a meal to eat less.
But there is a bit of a plot twist.
A small study involving rats (and a tiny sample of humans) suggested that carbonation might increase a "hunger hormone" called ghrelin. The theory is that the CO2 gas puts pressure on the stomach lining, triggering cells to release ghrelin, making you want to raid the pantry. It’s not a settled science yet, but if you find yourself starving after a LaCroix, that might be why.
When Sparkling Drinks Actually Become "Bad"
We’ve established that plain bubbles are mostly a win. But the beverage industry loves to blur the lines. When people ask are sparkling drinks bad for you, they are often drinking "sparkling beverages" that are basically soda in a fancy trench coat.
Watch out for these additions:
- Artificial Sweeteners: Aspartame, sucralose, and acesulfame potassium can mess with your gut microbiome.
- Sodium: Some club sodas add a surprising amount of salt for taste. If you're watching your blood pressure, it adds up.
- Sugar: "Sparkling juice" is often just soda with a better marketing team.
- Tonic Water: People think this is just bitter water. It’s not. A standard bottle of tonic has nearly as much sugar as a Coke.
The Hydration Factor
Good news: sparkling water hydrates you just as well as still water.
A 2016 study from the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition compared the hydration index of several different drinks. Plain water and sparkling water were essentially identical. If the bubbles help you drink more water because you find flat water boring, then sparkling water is actually good for you in that context. Most of us are walking around chronically dehydrated anyway.
🔗 Read more: Close up big boobs and the heavy reality of macromastia
Real-World Advice
If you want to keep enjoying your fizz without the guilt, just follow a few common-sense rules.
First, look at the ingredients. If it says anything other than "carbonated water" and "natural flavors," put it back. Second, try to drink it with meals rather than sipping it solo all day; the saliva you produce while eating helps neutralize the acids. Third, if you have a history of kidney stones, check the mineral content. Some sparkling mineral waters are high in calcium or oxalates, which can be a factor for certain people.
Switching from a daily 12-pack of Diet Coke to a 12-pack of plain seltzer is one of the best moves you can make for your health. You’re cutting out chemicals, dyes, and phosphoric acid while keeping the ritual of the "crack and hiss" of a cold can.
Actionable Steps for the Health-Conscious Drinker
- Check the label for Citric Acid: If you’re worried about your teeth, stick to plain or "essence" flavors that don't use concentrated citrus juice.
- Use a Straw: If you are a heavy sipper, using a straw bypasses the teeth and sends the bubbles straight to the back of the throat.
- The "Rinse" Rule: After finishing a sparkling drink, have a quick swig of regular tap water to rinse the acidity off your enamel.
- Listen to your Gut: If you struggle with bloating or acid reflux, try cutting back on the bubbles for a week to see if your symptoms clear up.
- Ditch the Tonic: Swap your gin and tonic for a gin and soda with a squeeze of fresh lime. You'll save about 30 grams of sugar per drink.
The bottom line is that for the vast majority of people, sparkling water is a fantastic, healthy alternative to sugary drinks. It provides the same hydration as flat water with a very minimal risk to your teeth or bones. As long as you aren't using it to replace every single drop of still water in your life, you can keep popping those tabs without worry.