Honestly, if you grew up with a television in the house between the sixties and the eighties, you know the sound. That crisp, rhythmic clack-clack-clack echoing over a bubbly orchestra. It was more than just background noise for your grandparents’ Saturday night. It was the sound of Arthur Duncan, the most famous tap dancer on Lawrence Welk, literally making history in a tuxedo and a smile that never seemed to fade.
Most people remember the bubbles and the polka. But Duncan? He was something else. He wasn't just a "member of the musical family," as Welk liked to call his cast. He was a pioneer. He stood out in a show that was, let’s be real, incredibly traditional and often criticized for being behind the times.
The Man Who Broke the Color Barrier with a Shuffle
Arthur Duncan didn't just stumble onto the set of the most wholesome show in America. He fought for it. Long before he was the resident tap dancer on Lawrence Welk, he was making waves on The Betty White Show back in 1954.
People forget this.
Betty White actually took a massive amount of heat for having Duncan on her show. Southern stations threatened to boycott. They wanted him off the air. Betty, being the legend she was, basically told them to "deal with it." She kept him on. That moment made Duncan the first African-American regular on a variety TV program.
By the time he joined Lawrence Welk in 1964, he was a seasoned pro. He had toured with Bob Hope’s USO troupe and played all over Europe. But the Welk show was different. It was a 18-year marathon. From 1964 until the show finally stopped production in 1982, Duncan was the heartbeat of the program’s rhythm section.
Why Arthur Duncan Was Different From Other Dancers
If you watch old clips now, you’ll notice something. Duncan’s style was incredibly clean. He wasn't doing the gritty, improvisational "hoofing" you might see in modern tap like Savion Glover. He was an "entertainer's entertainer."
💡 You might also like: Patrick Ball: Why the Star of The Pitt is Finally Getting His Due
- Precision: Every tap was audible and distinct, even over a full big band.
- The Look: He always looked like he was having the time of his life, even though the physical demand of those routines was brutal.
- Pre-taping: Here’s a little insider secret—Duncan often pre-taped his dance routines. Why? Because he was a perfectionist. He didn't want a single slip or a missed beat to ruin the "champagne music" vibe.
There were other dancers, sure. Bobby Burgess and his partners did the ballroom thing. Jack Imel was the "tap-dancing marimba player" who brought a bit of vaudeville chaos to the stage. But Arthur Duncan was the specialist. He was the one people waited for when they wanted to see pure, unadulterated footwork.
The Struggles Behind the Smiles
It wasn't all bubbles and applause.
Duncan was the only Black performer on the show for a very long time. In the midst of the Civil Rights movement, he was performing on a show that felt like a time capsule of 1940s Americana. Some critics at the time felt he was "too safe" or that his presence was a rebuke to the radical social progress happening outside the TV studio.
But talk to any tap historian today, and they’ll tell you he kept the art form alive. During the 60s and 70s, tap was dying. Broadway was moving toward jazz and contemporary dance. Hollywood had stopped making big movie musicals. Arthur Duncan was, quite literally, the only person bringing tap dance into millions of American living rooms every single week.
The Other "Hoofers" in the Welk Family
While Duncan was the king of the solo tap, he wasn't the only one with rhythm in his shoes. The show was a variety powerhouse, and the dance floor was rarely empty.
Bobby Burgess is the name most people pair with Duncan. Bobby came from the original Mickey Mouse Club (yeah, he was a Mouseketeer) and brought a very athletic, bouncy style to the show. He and his partners—Barbara Boylan, then Cissy King, then Elaine Balden—mostly focused on ballroom and "challenge" dances.
Then there was Jack Imel. Jack was a character. He’d play the marimba, then jump over it, then start tapping. He and Duncan occasionally did "challenge" routines together, which were some of the most high-energy moments in the show's history. It was a friendly rivalry, Indiana-born Imel versus California-born Duncan, but the respect was always there.
Life After the Champagne Music Stopped
When the show ended in 1982, Arthur Duncan didn't just hang up his shoes. He was 57 years old and still faster than guys half his age.
He stayed busy. He popped up in the 1989 movie Tap alongside Gregory Hines and Sammy Davis Jr., which was like a "passing of the torch" moment for the industry. He toured with Tommy Tune in My One and Only. He even did a guest spot on Diagnosis Murder with Dick Van Dyke.
✨ Don't miss: Why The Last of Us Season 1 Episode 1 Still Hits So Hard
Duncan lived to be 97, passing away in early 2023. Until the very end, he was a mentor. He wasn't just "that guy from the old show." He was a bridge between the Vaudeville era and the modern tap revival.
How to Appreciate This History Today
If you want to actually understand why people were so obsessed with the tap dancer on Lawrence Welk, don't just read about it.
- Watch the "Challenge" Dances: Look for clips of Arthur Duncan and Jack Imel going toe-to-toe. It shows the technical difference between "show tap" and "rhythm tap."
- The Betty White Connection: Check out the 2017 episode of Little Big Shots: Forever Young. Seeing a 90-something Arthur Duncan reunite with Betty White is probably the most wholesome thing on the internet.
- Listen to the Floor: In the old Welk episodes, the floor was specially mic'd for Duncan. Listen to the syncopation. He wasn't just hitting the beats; he was playing the floor like a drum set.
Arthur Duncan proved that you could be a trailblazer without being loud about it. He broke barriers with his feet and kept a forgotten art form breathing when nobody else cared. That’s why, even decades after the show went into reruns, he’s still the gold standard for television dance.
To get the full experience of Duncan's legacy, your next step should be to look up his 1971 "Route 66" performance on the show. It’s widely considered one of his most technically perfect routines and perfectly captures his ability to blend storytelling with rapid-fire percussion. This will give you a firsthand look at the precision and joy he brought to the screen for eighteen years.