Honestly, if you were watching TV back in 2016, you remember the shift. It wasn’t just a new show; it felt like a glitch in the matrix. When Donald Glover’s Atlanta first dropped on FX, people didn’t know whether to laugh or go sit in a dark room and think about their lives. The industry, however, knew exactly what to do: they started handing out trophies like they were going out of style. But looking back now, the story of Atlanta TV series awards is actually kind of weird. It's a mix of record-breaking "firsts" and some pretty confusing snubs that still don't make sense today.
The show basically redefined what a "comedy" could look like. You had episodes that felt like indie horror movies—looking at you, Teddy Perkins—and others that were straight-up social experiments. Because it refused to sit still in one genre, the awards circuit had to bend over backward to keep up.
The Night History Got Made
Most people point to the 2017 Primetime Emmys as the "big" moment. And yeah, it was massive. Donald Glover didn't just win; he kicked the door down. He took home the Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series, but the real shocker for the "old guard" was his win for Outstanding Directing for a Comedy Series.
Why?
Because he was the first Black person to ever win that specific directing award. Ever.
📖 Related: Why Actors From Star Wars Often Struggle With the Fame That Comes After
It’s wild to think it took until 2017 for that to happen, but that's the reality of the industry. The episode that clinched it was "B.A.N.," that surrealist masterpiece that parodied a fictional talk show on the "Black American Network," complete with fake commercials for things like Dodge Chargers and "Coconut Crunch-Os." It was bold, it was risky, and it proved that the Television Academy was finally willing to reward something that wasn't a traditional three-camera sitcom.
Why the Golden Globes Fell in Love First
Before the Emmys even got their act together, the Golden Globes were already obsessed. In early 2017, the show won Best Television Series – Musical or Comedy. Glover also bagged Best Actor.
It’s sorta funny how the Globes usually get a bad rap for being "eccentric," but they saw the vision early. They recognized that Atlanta wasn't just about a guy trying to manage his cousin's rap career. It was about the "vibe" of the city, the weight of being broke, and the weird, magical realism of the American South.
The Heavy Hitters in the Trophy Room:
- Two Peabody Awards: One for Season 1 and another for Season 4. These are the "prestige" ones that focus on storytelling that actually matters.
- Writers Guild of America (WGA): They won for both Best Comedy Series and Best New Series right out of the gate.
- AFI Awards: The American Film Institute consistently ranked it as one of the top 10 TV programs of the year.
The Supporting Cast: The Great Nomination Robbery?
Here is where things get a bit frustrating. While Donald Glover was the face of the Atlanta TV series awards run, the rest of the cast was doing some of the heaviest lifting on television.
Brian Tyree Henry (Alfred "Paper Boi" Miles) is a powerhouse. He eventually got an Emmy nomination for Supporting Actor in 2018, but he never actually took the trophy home for this role. Same for Zazie Beetz (Van), who grabbed a nomination in 2018.
LaKeith Stanfield? Somehow, he never even got an Emmy nomination for playing Darius. Not one. If you’ve seen the "Teddy Perkins" episode or "Free African 2," you know how insane that is. Darius was the soul of the show, yet the major awards bodies seemed to have a blind spot for his specific brand of weirdness.
Then there’s Hiro Murai. If Atlanta has a specific "look," it’s because of him. He’s the guy who directed "Teddy Perkins" and "New Jazz." He’s been nominated multiple times for Directing, but he often got overshadowed in the win column. It’s one of those things where the show was so consistently good that people started taking its brilliance for granted.
🔗 Read more: The Rookie Season 1 Episode 14: Why Plain Clothes Day Is the Show's Real Turning Point
The Surrealism vs. The Stats
By the time Season 3 and Season 4 rolled around, the "awards darling" status started to fade a bit, even though the quality was arguably higher and more experimental than ever. Season 3 took the crew to Europe, and while the cinematography was stunning—Christian Sprenger won an Emmy for it in 2022—the main categories started to overlook them.
Was it because the show became "too weird"? Maybe.
In Season 4, they returned to the roots of the city, and it felt like a victory lap. The Peabody win for the final season felt like a "lifetime achievement" nod, acknowledging that Atlanta changed the landscape of TV forever. It paved the way for shows like The Bear (which Hiro Murai also produces) and Reservation Dogs to exist.
What Really Happened With the "Teddy Perkins" Snub?
Let’s talk about the 2018 Emmys for a second. "Teddy Perkins" is widely considered one of the greatest episodes of television ever made. It had everyone talking. Donald Glover showed up to the ceremony as Teddy Perkins (allegedly, it’s still a bit of a legend).
The episode was nominated for everything: Writing, Directing, Editing, Cinematography. But it lost the major categories to The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. Don't get me wrong, Maisel was great, but "Teddy Perkins" was a cultural event. That was the moment many fans realized that the Atlanta TV series awards trajectory wasn't going to be a simple "win everything" story. It was going to be a "cult classic that the establishment respects but doesn't always fully embrace" story.
Actionable Takeaways for TV Fans and Creators
If you're looking at the legacy of this show, don't just count the trophies. The impact is deeper than the shelf space in Donald Glover's house.
- Look at the "Firsts": Use Atlanta as a case study for how to break barriers. Glover’s directing win changed the internal "rules" of what a Black creator could achieve in the comedy category.
- Cinematography Matters: If you’re a creator, study Christian Sprenger’s work on this show. His Emmy wins for "Three Slaps" and "Alfred's World" show that even in a "comedy," the visual language can be as heavy as a prestige drama.
- The Peabody is the Real Prize: If you want to know which shows will actually be remembered in 20 years, look at the Peabody winners. Atlanta winning twice tells you more about its cultural relevance than any red carpet interview ever could.
- Revisit the Snubs: Go back and watch Brian Tyree Henry in "Woods" (Season 2, Episode 8). The fact that he didn't win an Emmy for that 30-minute masterclass in grief and survival is a crime. Watch it to understand nuance in acting.
The show ended in 2022, but its ghost is everywhere in modern television. It proved that you can be "unapologetically Black," surreal, and confusing, and the world will still find a way to give you your flowers—even if they miss a few of the best performers along the way.
✨ Don't miss: Nelly Little House on the Prairie: Why We Still Love to Hate the Ultimate TV Mean Girl
To truly understand the show's impact, you have to look past the Primetime Emmy count and see how it shifted the expectations for every creator who came after. It wasn't just about winning; it was about changing the game so the old rules didn't apply anymore.