You’re exhausted. The baby has been crying for three hours, the laundry is a mountain, and you just need ten minutes to drink a coffee that isn't lukewarm. It’s tempting. That glowing rectangle in the living room feels like a lifeline. But choosing a baby’s first tv show isn’t as simple as just hitting play on whatever is trending on YouTube.
Honestly, the "wrong" show can actually make your life harder.
Most of us grew up with cartoons that moved at a million miles an hour. We turned out fine, right? Well, science has changed. Recent research, including a 2025 study from the A*STAR Institute for Human Development and Potential, found that high screen exposure before age two can actually lead to "accelerated brain maturation." That sounds like a good thing, but it’s not. It basically means the brain specializes in visual processing too early, which can lead to slower decision-making and higher anxiety by the time they're teenagers.
So, yeah. The stakes are a bit higher than just finding something to keep them quiet.
Why Speed Kills (Developmentally Speaking)
Think about Cocomelon. It’s the elephant in the room. Kids are obsessed with it. Why? Because the "scene cuts" happen every one to three seconds. It’s like a shot of dopamine to a tiny, developing brain. When you turn it off, the real world—where things don't change colors and explode every two seconds—feels incredibly boring. That’s why the "Cocomelon tantrum" is a real thing.
Basically, you want the opposite of that.
You want "low-stimulation" content. Experts like Dr. Choulet often point to shows that mimic the actual pace of a toddler’s life. If a character is walking across a room, you should see them actually walk. No jump cuts. No flashing strobe lights.
The Heavy Hitters: Ms. Rachel vs. Bluey
If you’ve spent five minutes on a parenting forum, you’ve heard of Ms. Rachel. Her Songs for Littles is basically the gold standard for baby’s first tv show right now.
👉 See also: The Queen Size Loft Bed Adult Owners Actually Love
Why does it work?
It’s not just the overalls. Rachel Accurso is a trained educator who uses techniques like "parentese"—that high-pitched, slow way of talking that babies actually tune into. She leaves gaps. She says, "Can you say... mama?" and then she actually waits. That silence is crucial. It gives the baby’s brain time to process the request and try to respond.
Then there’s Bluey.
Kinda controversial for the under-two crowd. While Bluey is arguably the best-written show on television (for adults and kids alike), it’s often too fast for an infant. The nuance, the sarcasm, and the complex family dynamics are great for a four-year-old. For a ten-month-old? It’s just moving shapes. If you’re going to put on Bluey, do it because you want to watch it while the baby plays with some blocks on the floor.
Real Options for a Low-Stim Start
If you're looking for something that won't fry their circuits, here are the shows that actually respect a baby's developmental timeline:
- Puffin Rock: This is the "zen" show. It’s narrated by Chris O’Dowd, and the color palette is all muted greens and blues. It follows Oona and her little brother Baba. It’s slow. It’s kind. It’s perfect.
- Trash Truck: Don't let the name fool you. It's incredibly gentle. It’s about a boy named Hank and a literal trash truck, but the stories are grounded in imagination and quiet discovery.
- Old School Sesame Street: Believe it or not, the 1970s version of Sesame Street is often better than the modern one for infants. The segments were longer. The pacing was slower. You can find these on various streaming archives.
- Guess How Much I Love You: Based on the classic book, this show is practically a lullaby in visual form.
The "Video Deficit" Problem
Here is the hard truth: babies under 18 months don't really "learn" from screens. Researchers call this the video deficit.
A baby can watch a video of someone stacking blocks a hundred times and still not know how to do it. But if you sit with them and stack two blocks once? They’ve got it. They need the 3D world. They need the smell of the plastic, the weight of the block, and the "good job!" from your actual face.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) still holds pretty firm: no screens before 18 months, except for video chatting. FaceTiming Grandma is different because it's interactive. It’s a "back-and-forth" social exchange.
How to Do Screen Time Without the Guilt
Let's be real. Sometimes you have to use the TV. If you're sick, or you're solo parenting and need a shower, the TV is a tool. The key is how you use it.
Don't use it as a "pacifier" for tantrums. If you give a kid a screen because they're screaming, you're teaching them that screaming gets them the high-dopamine toy. Use it for "planned" breaks.
Co-view whenever possible. This is the secret sauce. If you’re sitting there saying, "Oh look, the puffin found a snack! Is he hungry?" you are turning a passive experience into a social one. You are bridging the gap between the 2D screen and their 3D reality.
Check the "Theta/Beta" ratio. A study published in JAMA Pediatrics showed that babies with high screen time had stronger "theta waves"—which are associated with a less-alert, daydreamy state—and weaker "beta waves," which we use for focus. If your baby looks "tranced out" or "zombified" while watching, the show is too stimulating. They should be looking away, pointing, or reacting, not staring with a slack jaw.
The Transition Plan
When the show ends, the transition is usually the hardest part. You're taking them from a world of easy entertainment back to a world where they have to work for their fun.
👉 See also: New Year's Makeup Looks Most People Actually Get Wrong
Try the "Two-Minute Warning," even if they can't talk yet.
"One more song, then we turn the TV off and go play with your red ball."
Then, actually do it. Turn the TV off. Don't leave it on in the background. Background TV (even if no one is watching) has been linked to lower language scores because it reduces the number of words parents say to their children.
Actionable Steps for Today
If you're ready to introduce a baby’s first tv show, or you’re trying to fix a screen-time habit that’s gone off the rails, start here:
- Audit the speed: Watch a show for five minutes. Count how many times the camera angle changes. If it’s more than 10 times a minute, it’s probably too fast for an infant.
- The "Rachel" Test: Try one 10-minute segment of a language-focused show like Ms. Rachel. Sit with your baby. If they try to mimic her sounds, it’s a win. If they just stare blankly, turn it off and try again in a month.
- Physical first: Always try 15 minutes of "floor time" before turning on the TV. Often, a baby is just bored or needs a change of scenery. A quick trip to the porch or a bowl of water with some spoons can often buy you the same ten minutes a TV show would.
- Audio-only: Consider a Yoto player or just playing music. You get the "distraction" benefit without the brain-altering visual stimulation.
Screen time isn't "poison," but it is a powerful tool. Use it like a spice, not the main course.