You’ve probably been there. You toss a few foil-wrapped Russets onto the grates next to your steaks, figuring they’ll be done whenever the meat is. An hour later, you peel back the aluminum to find a potato that is either rock-hard in the center or, somehow worse, a gray, mushy mess that tastes more like wet metal than dinner. It's frustrating. Honestly, the humble baked potato on a grill is one of those side dishes that seems foolproof until you actually try to execute it perfectly under the localized heat of a charcoal or gas flame.
Most backyard cooks treat the grill like a standard kitchen oven. Big mistake. An oven provides stable, omnidirectional heat; a grill is a chaotic environment of convection currents and intense infrared radiation. If you want that pillowy, cloud-like interior and a skin that actually tastes like something, you have to stop treating the potato as an afterthought.
🔗 Read more: Greenworks 80 Volt Battery: What Most People Get Wrong
The Foil Myth and Why Your Spuds Are Sad
Let’s talk about the silver elephant in the room. Foil. We’ve been conditioned to think that wrapping a potato in aluminum foil is the only way to grill it. It isn't. In fact, wrapping your potato in foil basically turns the grill into a steamer. You aren't "baking" the potato at that point; you're boiling it in its own internal moisture. This leads to a skin that is wet and papery rather than crisp and salty.
If you’re looking for that classic steakhouse texture, the foil has to go. Or, at the very least, it needs to be relegated to the very end of the process. When you cook a baked potato on a grill without a wrapper, the dry heat pulls moisture out of the skin, concentrating the sugars and creating a slight crunch. It’s a chemical transformation called the Maillard reaction, and it doesn't happen in a steam pocket.
Of course, there is a trade-off. Without foil, the skin can char if you place it directly over the burners. You’ve got to use indirect heat. This means lighting one side of the grill and placing the potatoes on the "cold" side. It takes longer. It requires patience. But the result is a potato that actually tastes like the outdoors instead of a cafeteria tray.
Choosing the Right Spud (Size Matters)
Don't grab the waxy red potatoes or those cute little Yukon Golds for this. You need starch. Specifically, you need the Russet Burbank or the Norkotah. These varieties are high in amylose starch, which is what gives you that fluffy, granular texture when the internal temperature hits the sweet spot.
🔗 Read more: Why Williams Sonoma University Town Center Is Still the Best Place to Touch a $400 Toaster
I’ve seen people try to grill "new potatoes" this way, and it’s just a disappointment. They stay dense. They don't absorb butter. They're just... there.
Go for the medium-sized ones. The massive, "pounder" potatoes you see at some wholesale clubs are impressive, but they take forever to cook on a grill. By the time the middle is soft, the outside is usually a charcoal brick. Aim for something around 8 to 10 ounces. They’re easier to manage and they cook at a predictable rate, usually finishing in about 45 to 60 minutes if your grill is hovering around 400 degrees.
The Prep Work Nobody Does
Before that potato even touches a grate, you need to do two things. First, prick it. Use a fork. Hit it about six or eight times. This isn't just an old wives' tale; it’s about steam pressure. A potato is mostly water. As that water heats up, it turns to steam. If that steam has nowhere to go, it stays trapped in the starch cells, making the interior gummy. Worse, in rare cases, the pressure can actually cause the potato to split or pop, which is a mess nobody wants to clean off their flavorizer bars.
Second, the oil. Don't use butter yet. Butter has milk solids that burn at grill temperatures. Use a high-smoke-point oil like avocado oil or even just basic vegetable oil. Coat the skin thoroughly. Then—and this is the part people skip—generously coat it in kosher salt. Not table salt. Kosher salt has larger grains that won't just dissolve and disappear; they’ll create a seasoned crust that makes the skin the best part of the meal.
Temperature Control: The 210-Degree Rule
Professional chefs like J. Kenji López-Alt have pointed out that the "perfect" baked potato happens when the internal temperature reaches between 205°F and 212°F. At this temperature, the starch granules have fully hydrated and burst, creating that light, airy texture.
If you pull a baked potato on a grill at 185°F, it might feel "soft" to a squeeze, but it will be "leathery" to the bite.
Use a digital meat thermometer. Seriously. Stick it right into the center of the largest potato. If it reads 210°F, it’s done. If it’s 190°F, give it another ten minutes. This is the difference between a "fine" potato and one that people actually talk about the next day.
Indirect vs. Direct Heat
- Indirect Heat: This is your best friend. Set your gas grill to medium-high on one side and leave the other burners off. Place the potatoes on the unlit side. Close the lid. This creates an oven-like environment with the added benefit of smoky air.
- The "Hybrid" Method: Some folks like to start the potatoes in the microwave for 5 minutes to jumpstart the internal cooking, then finish them on the grill for 20 minutes to get the skin crisp. It's a bit of a cheat, but honestly, it works if you’re in a rush.
- Charcoal Setup: If you’re using charcoal, bank your coals to one side. Put the potatoes on the opposite side of the grate. If you want a bit of extra flavor, toss a small chunk of hickory or applewood onto the coals. A smoked baked potato is a revelation.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Don't crowd the grill. Airflow is everything. If you pack twelve potatoes onto a small grill, you’re creating a heat shield that prevents the top of the potatoes from cooking. Space them out.
Stop peeking. Every time you lift the grill lid to check on your baked potato on a grill, you’re dropping the ambient temperature by 50 degrees or more. It takes minutes for that heat to recover. If you’re using a gas grill with a built-in thermometer, trust the dial. Only open the lid when it’s time to flip them (usually halfway through) or to check the final internal temp.
And please, for the love of all things holy, don't put the toppings on while it's still on the grill. I've seen people try to melt cheese or add sour cream while the potato is sitting over the flame. All you're doing is making a mess and curdling your dairy. Wait until it’s on the plate.
The Finish: The "Slam" Technique
Once you pull that potato off the grill, don't just slice it open with a knife. Slicing with a knife compresses the starch and can lead to a heavy, wet texture.
Instead, try the "Slam" or the "Squeeze." Take the potato (use a towel, it’s hot!), and drop it onto the counter from about six inches up. Or, use your hands to squeeze the ends toward the center until the skin cracks. This breaks up the internal starch structure and lets the steam escape instantly, resulting in a much fluffier interior. Only then should you add your fats—butter, bacon grease, or heavy cream.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Edinburgh Zoo Penguin Cam is Still the Internet’s Favorite Distraction
Actionable Steps for Your Next Cookout
- Skip the foil unless you absolutely prefer a soft, steamed skin.
- Scrub and dry the potatoes completely before oiling; moisture on the surface prevents crisping.
- Season aggressively with kosher salt and a high-heat oil.
- Aim for 400°F on the grill's ambient thermometer.
- Use indirect heat to avoid burning the bottom of the spud.
- Verify with a thermometer—look for that 210°F internal mark.
- Rest for 5 minutes before cracking it open to let the internal steam stabilize.
Grilling a potato isn't just about heat; it's about managing moisture. When you move away from the "wrap and forget" method and start treating the potato with the same respect you give a ribeye, the results are genuinely transformative. You get a side dish that isn't just a vessel for sour cream, but a highlight of the meal itself.