If you drive up Route 12 through the winding, tree-choked hills of Windsor County, you'll eventually hit a patch of road where the trees pull back to reveal Silver Lake. It’s stunning. Right there, sitting squarely across from the water, is the Barnard General Store. It looks like exactly what you’d imagine a Vermont store to be—white clapboard, a wide porch, and a sense of permanence that feels older than the state itself.
But here’s the thing. It almost vanished.
Most people see the postcard-perfect exterior and assume it’s been running smoothly since 1832. It hasn't. In 2012, the store actually shut its doors. For a town like Barnard, which basically has a population hovering around 900 people, losing the general store wasn't just losing a place to buy milk. It was like losing the town's heartbeat. When the lights went dark and the "Closed" sign went up, the community didn't just move on to the nearest supermarket in Woodstock or Bethel. They fought for it.
The Day the Barnard General Store Nearly Vanished
It was a shock. Honestly, when the previous owners had to close due to financial struggles, the silence in the center of town was deafening. You’ve got to understand that in rural Vermont, the general store is the post office, the grocery store, the local diner, and the town square all rolled into one. Without it, you’re just a collection of houses in the woods.
The locals did something kind of incredible. They formed the Barnard Community Trust. They didn't wait for a corporate savior or a wealthy out-of-stater to come in and turn it into a high-end boutique. They raised over $500,000. That’s a massive amount of money for a tiny village. They bought the building to ensure that no matter who ran the business, the physical structure would always belong to the town.
This is why the Barnard General Store in Barnard Vermont feels different when you walk in today. You aren't just a customer; you're standing in a building held up by the collective will of its neighbors. Eventually, Joe and Maria Steakas took over the operations, bringing back the deli, the ice cream counter, and that specific smell of woodsmoke and fresh coffee that defines the experience.
Why the Location Matters More Than You Think
Silver Lake is right there. Literally steps away. In the summer, the store is the unofficial headquarters for the Silver Lake State Park. You see kids running across the street with dripping ice cream cones and people grabbing sandwiches before heading out on a kayak. It’s idyllic.
But it’s the winter that proves the store’s worth. When the snow is four feet deep and the wind is howling off the lake, that wood-burning stove inside is the warmest place in the county. It’s where you find out whose tractor is stuck or who needs help clearing their roof.
What You’re Actually Getting at the Counter
Don't expect a polished, corporate experience. This is a floorboards-creak-under-your-boots kind of place. The inventory is a wild mix. You might see a $15 bottle of maple syrup sitting next to a generic can of beans, alongside locally crafted pottery and high-end cheeses.
The deli is the real star.
- The Sandwiches: They don't skimp. Whether it's a classic turkey club or something more "Vermonty" with sharp cheddar and apples, it's hefty.
- The Baked Goods: Maria’s influence is all over the pastry case. If the cookies are fresh, buy three. You’ll regret only getting one.
- The Coffee: It’s hot, it’s strong, and it’s usually being poured while a local farmer discusses the weather with a tourist who looks slightly lost.
The "locals' table" is a real thing. It’s usually tucked toward the back or near the front window. If you sit there, be prepared to listen more than you talk. You’ll hear about the town meeting, the state of the roads, and who caught what out of the lake. It’s a living history lesson.
👉 See also: Snow in New York: Why the City's Winter is Changing Faster Than You Think
The Survival of the General Store Model
Is it expensive? Sometimes. You’re paying for the convenience of not driving twenty miles, but you’re also paying for the survival of a dying American institution.
General stores across New England are dropping like flies. High property taxes and the lure of big-box retailers in West Lebanon make it hard to keep the lights on. The Barnard General Store survives because it evolved. It’s a hybrid. It serves the "Old Vermont"—the loggers and the generational farmers—and the "New Vermont"—the summer residents and the leaf-peepers who want organic sourdough and artisanal chocolate.
Keeping that balance is a tightrope walk. If it becomes too fancy, the locals feel pushed out. If it stays too gritty, it can’t pay the bills. The Steakas family seems to have found that "just right" middle ground where everyone feels welcome.
Planning a Visit: Realities and Tips
If you’re planning to drive up, keep a few things in mind. Cell service in Barnard is... let's call it "optimistic." You might have a bar; you probably won't. Download your maps before you leave Woodstock.
Parking can be a nightmare in July. The lot is small, and with the lake traffic, it gets chaotic. Just be patient. Pull in, grab your food, and walk across to the lake to eat. There’s a small beach area at the state park, but even just sitting on the stone wall across from the store is a top-tier experience.
- Check the hours. They aren't open 24/7. This isn't a 7-Eleven. They usually close by 6:00 PM or 7:00 PM depending on the season.
- Bring a cooler. You’re going to want to buy local meat or dairy to take home, and if you’re driving back to a hotel or an Airbnb, you’ll want it to stay cold.
- Respect the porch. It’s a place for lingering, but don't block the door.
The Deep History Under the Floorboards
The store was founded in 1832. Think about that for a second. When this place opened, Andrew Jackson was president. It has survived the Civil War, the Great Depression, and the 1927 flood that devastated much of the state.
It’s built on a foundation of Vermont fieldstone. If you look at the old photos hanging on the walls—and you definitely should spend ten minutes looking at them—you’ll see that the facade hasn't changed much. The cars in the photos change from Model Ts to Subarus, but the porch remains the same.
Actionable Steps for Your Trip
To get the most out of a visit to the Barnard General Store, avoid the peak lunch rush between 12:00 PM and 1:30 PM if you can. Arriving around 10:30 AM allows you to grab the freshest baked goods while the kitchen is still quiet enough to handle custom sandwich orders quickly.
Once you have your haul, take the two-minute drive up North Road to see the rolling pastures that make this part of Vermont famous. If you're visiting in the autumn, the view from the store's front porch toward the hills across Silver Lake offers some of the best color density in the state without the massive crowds of Stowe or Burlington.
📖 Related: Dams on the Catawba River: Why This Massive Water Machine Actually Works
Support the local economy by looking for the "Made in Vermont" tags on the shelves. Buying a jar of honey or a hand-knit hat from a local artisan directly contributes to the fund that keeps the building maintained by the Community Trust. Your purchase is quite literally a vote for the store to exist for another century.
Don't just pass through. Stop. Sit. Listen to the creak of the door. The Barnard General Store in Barnard Vermont isn't just a place to shop; it’s a lesson in what happens when a community refuses to let its soul be sold off. It’s proof that sometimes, the old ways of doing things are actually the only ways that work.