Honestly, the fact that we even got a sequel to a 1988 cult classic in 2024 is a minor miracle. Usually, these things feel like tired cash grabs. But Beetlejuice 2 Michael Keaton proved that some characters just don't age, even if the actor underneath the greasepaint is now in his 70s.
Keaton didn't just show up for a paycheck. He actually was the character again.
The Chaos Returns to Winter River
When the first trailer for Beetlejuice Beetlejuice dropped, people were nervous. Could Michael Keaton still pull off that manic, scratchy-voiced energy? The answer turned out to be a resounding yes. Keaton has often said that the bio-exorcist is his favorite role because there are basically no rules. You can do anything.
The plot picks up decades later. Lydia Deetz, played by a returning Winona Ryder, is now a "ghost house" talk show host. She's got a daughter, Astrid (Jenna Ortega), who thinks her mom is a total fraud. It's a classic family dynamic, just with more dead people. When a family tragedy brings them back to the old house in Winter River, things go south fast.
🔗 Read more: Cape May: Why The Blacklist Season 3 Episode 19 Changed Everything
Keaton’s Betelgeuse is still stuck in the Afterlife waiting room, still trying to find a way out, and still completely obsessed with Lydia.
Why the Performance Felt Different (In a Good Way)
Keaton is older. He’s 73. In the 1988 original, he was a ball of pure, rubber-faced kinetic energy. In the sequel, he’s still fast, but there’s a seasoned sharpness to his comedy. He didn't want the character to be "evolved" or "sensitive" for modern audiences. He pushed for the Juice to remain a sleazebag.
He’s still a villain. Sorta.
The movie relies heavily on practical effects, which Keaton insisted on. No one wanted a CGI Beetlejuice. They used puppets. They used real slime. They used actors in heavy prosthetics. This allowed Keaton to actually interact with the world instead of staring at a green tennis ball on a stick. It makes a huge difference in the final product.
What Most People Get Wrong About His Screen Time
There’s a common misconception that Keaton is the "main character" of these movies. He isn't. In the original, he only had about 17 minutes of screen time. In Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, he has more to do, but it's still very much Lydia's story.
Keaton understands this. He knows that the "Ghost with the Most" works best in short, explosive bursts. If he’s on screen for the whole two hours, the joke gets old. You need that build-up. You need to wait for him to be summoned so that when he finally appears, it feels like a riot.
The New Blood vs. The Old Guard
- Jenna Ortega: She fits the Burton aesthetic perfectly. Her chemistry with Ryder feels authentic.
- Catherine O’Hara: Delia Deetz is still an insufferable artist, and O’Hara is still a comedic genius.
- Willem Dafoe: He plays a dead actor who becomes a detective in the afterlife. It’s as weird as it sounds.
- Monica Bellucci: She plays Betelgeuse’s soul-sucking ex-wife. She’s basically a silent-movie villain stitched together with staples.
The Box Office Reality
The movie was a massive hit. It pulled in over $450 million worldwide. For a $100 million budget, that’s a huge win for Warner Bros. It proved that "legacy sequels" can actually work if the original director and stars are actually invested in the material. Tim Burton looked like he was having fun again, which hasn't always been the case with his recent Disney projects.
Is Beetlejuice 3 Actually Happening?
Rumors are flying. The ending of the second film definitely leaves the door open. However, Tim Burton has been a bit cagey about it. He told the press that it took 35 years to get this one right, so he might be over 100 years old by the time a third one happens.
But money talks.
Warner Bros. has reportedly discussed a third installment. Keaton has joked, "Why stop at three?" He seems to love the character enough to keep going as long as the makeup can hide the wrinkles. If it happens, it’ll likely focus on the "Baby Beetlejuice" teased in the sequel’s dream sequences.
Honestly? Just enjoy what we got.
If you want to dive deeper into the world of Beetlejuice 2 Michael Keaton, your best bet is to re-watch the original and then catch the sequel on Max. Look for the small details in the background of the Afterlife—the "Shrinkers" (the guys with the tiny heads) are all practical puppets, and each one has a slightly different personality. It’s that kind of craftsmanship that makes these movies stand out in an era of bland digital effects.
Go back and look at the "Soul Train" sequence in the sequel. It’s a perfect example of how Keaton and Burton still have that weird, funky spark.
Actionable Next Steps
- Watch the practical effects featurettes: Most streaming platforms have behind-the-scenes clips showing how they built the puppets. It’ll make you appreciate Keaton’s performance even more.
- Compare the dialogue: Pay attention to how many of Keaton's lines are clearly improvised compared to the first film. He’s a master of the "fast-talk" style.
- Keep an eye on official WB announcements: While Burton is hesitant, the studio is definitely looking at the numbers. Any news on a third film will likely break around Halloween 2026.