Honestly, it’s hard to imagine anyone else but Benedict Cumberbatch playing Alan Turing. He has this specific way of vibrating on screen—a mix of high-frequency intelligence and brittle social anxiety. When Benedict Cumberbatch in The Imitation Game first hit theaters in 2014, it didn't just win an Oscar for its screenplay; it basically redefined how we view the "tortured genius" trope.
But there is a massive gap between the movie and the man.
If you’ve seen the film, you probably remember Turing as a borderline-autistic, socially abrasive man who couldn't understand a joke if it hit him in the face. This version of Alan Turing is iconic. It’s also largely a work of fiction. While Cumberbatch’s performance is nothing short of masterly, the script took some serious liberties with the actual history of Bletchley Park and the man who broke the Enigma code.
The Teeth, the Stutter, and the Tears
Cumberbatch is known for being a bit of a "method" obsessive, though he’d probably use a less pretentious word for it. For this role, he didn’t just memorize lines. He went deep.
👉 See also: Milton H. Greene Photographer: What Most People Get Wrong
He actually wore a set of prosthetic dentures that were an exact replica of Alan Turing's 60-year-old teeth. Why? Because he felt the dental structure changed the way Turing would have formed words. It gave him that specific, slightly hesitant speech pattern. He also spent time with Turing’s surviving nieces. They told him he was "convivial" and treated them like adults, which is a far cry from the cold, detached version we see on screen.
One of the most striking things about his preparation was the emotional toll. During the final days of filming—specifically the scenes depicting Turing’s "chemical castration" and mental decline—Cumberbatch reportedly couldn't stop crying. He told Screen Daily that it wasn't just "acting" at that point; he was grieving for a man who saved millions of lives but was destroyed by the very country he protected.
- The Run: Turing was a marathon-level runner. Cumberbatch took up distance running to get that lean, "gaunt" look.
- The Machine: The code-breaking machine in the movie is called "Christopher," named after Turing’s first love. In reality, it was called the "Bombe."
- The Relation: Weirdly enough, according to Ancestry.com, Benedict Cumberbatch and Alan Turing are actually 17th cousins. Talk about destiny.
Why the "Sherlock" Comparison is Lazy
Critics love to say that Benedict Cumberbatch in The Imitation Game is just "Sherlock in a 1940s suit." They’re wrong.
Sherlock is a predator. He’s arrogant, he enjoys being the smartest person in the room, and he uses his intellect as a weapon. Turing, as Cumberbatch plays him, is a prey animal. His social awkwardness isn't a power move; it’s a barrier. There’s a profound vulnerability in his Turing that Sherlock never shows. When Turing tries to tell a joke to his coworkers by offering them apples, it’s painful to watch because he’s trying so hard to belong.
The real Alan Turing was actually quite well-liked. His colleagues at Bletchley Park described him as having a keen sense of humor and being "easily approachable." The movie turned him into a misunderstood loner because, well, that’s what Hollywood thinks a genius looks like.
👉 See also: The Death of Daryl Walking Dead Rumors: Why Norman Reedus Isn't Going Anywhere
The Conflict That Never Happened
One of the biggest "lies" in the movie is the relationship between Turing and Commander Denniston (played by Charles Dance). In the film, they are constantly at each other's throats. Denniston tries to fire him; Turing writes to Churchill to get more funding.
In real life? Denniston was one of the people who recruited Turing and actually respected him immensely. There was no dramatic "security guards dragging him out" scene.
Actionable Insights: How to See the Real Turing
If you loved the movie but want to separate the actor from the actual history, here are a few steps you should take:
👉 See also: Why You Still Listen to Get Low by Lil Jon and the East Side Boyz Two Decades Later
- Read the Source Material: Pick up Alan Turing: The Enigma by Andrew Hodges. It’s the biography the movie was based on, and it’s far more nuanced about his sexuality and his work.
- Visit Bletchley Park: It’s a real place in Buckinghamshire, UK. You can see the actual machines (which don't have as many glowing red wires as the movie version) and stand in the huts where the world was saved.
- Watch "Breaking the Code": If you want to compare performances, find the 1996 TV movie starring Derek Jacobi. It's a very different, perhaps more historically "accurate" vibe than the Hollywood blockbuster.
The legacy of Benedict Cumberbatch in The Imitation Game isn't just about whether every date and name was correct. It’s about the fact that most people didn’t even know who Alan Turing was before this movie came out. Cumberbatch didn't just give a performance; he gave a face to a ghost. He took a man who had been chemically castrated and erased from history books and made him a household name. That, regardless of the historical "tweaks," is a massive achievement.
Next time you watch it, look past the "Sherlock" tropes. Notice the way he fumbles with his buttons or the way his eyes dart when someone asks him a personal question. That’s the real work. That’s how you turn a math genius into a human being.
Next Step: To get a better sense of the actual hardware, you should look up the differences between the "Bombe" machine used at Bletchley and the "Christopher" prop designed for the film. The movie version was made to look like "veins" were pumping blood through the machine to symbolize Turing’s attachment to his lost friend.