The honeymoon is over.
When the Cincinnati Bengals signed TJ Slaton to a two-year, $15.1 million contract back in March 2025, it felt like the savvy, middle-market move that makes Super Bowl rosters tick. They needed a mountain to replace the hole left by DJ Reader. They needed a guy who could eat double teams so B.J. Hill and the edge rushers could actually, you know, do their jobs.
Slaton was that guy. Or he was supposed to be.
✨ Don't miss: Afghanistan National Cricket Team vs Hong Kong National Cricket Team: What Really Happened
Now, standing in early 2026 after a disappointing 6-11 season, the math is getting ugly. Real ugly. Slaton is currently carrying an $8.66 million cap hit for the 2026 season. In the world of NFL roster building, that’s a lot of money for a "run-stuffer" on a team that just finished with one of the worst run defenses in the league.
The Math Behind the Slaton Dilemma
Let’s be real for a second. If you’re paying a defensive tackle nearly $9 million, you want more than a "space eater." You want a disruptor.
According to Over The Cap, Slaton is basically the definition of a "cap casualty" candidate right now. If the Bengals keep him, they swallow that $8.66 million hit. If they cut him? They save roughly **$6.16 million** in cap space while only eating about $2.5 million in dead money.
In a league where every dollar counts—especially with the looming need to figure out long-term extensions for guys like Ja'Marr Chase—$6 million is a fortune. It’s the difference between signing a starting-caliber veteran safety or hoping a third-round rookie doesn’t get burned on every deep post.
Was He Actually Bad?
It depends on who you ask. If you live and die by the box score, Slaton looks like a ghost. He finished 2025 with around 35 tackles and a handful of sacks. For a 340-pound nose tackle, that's... fine?
But the advanced metrics tell a weirder story. His PFF run-defense grade hovered in the low 40s for much of the year. That's not just "not great"—it’s essentially replacement-level. When you watch the tape from the late-season losses to the Steelers or the Ravens, you see why. There were too many snaps where Slaton was getting moved off the ball or failing to anchor the middle.
Honestly, the Bengals' defense was a mess from top to bottom last year, so it's probably unfair to pin it all on one guy. But when you’re the sixth-highest cap hit on the team, you’re the first one people look at when things go south.
The Draft Factor: Why 2026 Changes Everything
The biggest threat to TJ Slaton’s locker at Paycor Stadium isn’t just his contract. It’s the 2026 NFL Draft class.
The Bengals are sitting at the No. 10 overall pick. Every major mock draft from Sports Illustrated to Pro Football Focus is screaming the same thing: Cincinnati needs interior defensive line help.
Names like Peter Woods from Clemson or Kayden McDonald from Ohio State are being linked to the Bengals constantly. These aren't just "big guys." They are athletes. Woods, specifically, is a 315-pound freak who can play the 0-tech but also rush from the 3-tech spot.
Why a Rookie Makes Slaton Expendable:
- Cost: A rookie at No. 10 is expensive, but you get four or five years of cost control.
- Upside: Slaton is 28. He is who he is. A guy like Woods or McDonald represents a future "anchor."
- Scheme Fit: The Bengals' defense struggled with lateral quickness. Slaton is a straight-ahead power guy, and the league is moving toward twitchier interiors.
The Case for Keeping Him
Wait. Before everyone gets out the moving boxes, there is a counter-argument.
The Bengals have a history of being... well, patient. Some call it loyal; others call it stubborn. Mike Brown and the front office don't usually like "wasted" money. If they cut Slaton, they are admitting the $15 million investment was a mistake after just one year.
Also, who else is there? Kris Jenkins Jr. and McKinnley Jackson are still developing. B.J. Hill is a veteran leader, but he needs a partner. If you cut Slaton and don't land a Day 1 starter in the draft, your defensive interior becomes a revolving door of practice squad players and veterans on league-minimum deals.
He did have some bright spots. Early in the 2025 season, specifically that September win where the defense actually looked competent, Slaton was dominant. He was "stacking and shedding" exactly like the coaches wanted. The problem was consistency. You can't be a $9 million player only three weeks out of the year.
What Happens Next?
This isn't a simple "yes or no" situation. It’s a game of chicken between Slaton’s agent and the Bengals' front office.
The most likely scenario? A contract restructure or a pay cut. If Slaton is willing to drop that $8.66 million cap hit down to something like $5 million by converting salary to incentives, he probably stays. He knows the system, and the coaches like his locker room presence.
But if he insists on the full bag? Don't be surprised if he's a June 1st cut.
👉 See also: Cam Newton Height: Why His Massive Size Changed the NFL Forever
The Bengals are at a crossroads. They’ve missed the playoffs three years in a row. The "championship window" that Joe Burrow opened is starting to feel like it's sticking. They can't afford to pay for "potential" or "size" anymore. They need production.
Actionable Takeaways for the Offseason:
- Watch the Draft Board: If the Bengals take a DT at No. 10 or in the early second round, Slaton's days are likely numbered.
- The March 1st Deadline: Keep an eye on roster bonus dates. Many NFL contracts have triggers in early March that force a team's hand.
- Free Agency Triage: If Cincinnati goes heavy on defensive line in free agency (think a second-tier vet like a revitalized Quinton Jefferson type), they are clearing space for Slaton's exit.
Slaton is a massive human being who theoretically fits a massive need. But in the 2026 NFL, being "big" isn't enough to justify a top-10 cap hit on a losing team.