If you’ve been following the AFC East lately, you know the vibe. It’s basically been a recurring nightmare for folks in South Florida. Looking back at bills vs dolphins 2024, it wasn't just about the scores on the board; it was about a massive power shift that felt permanent, then suddenly, incredibly tense.
Buffalo has owned this matchup for what feels like a decade. Honestly, Josh Allen treats Hard Rock Stadium like his personal vacation home. But 2024 gave us two completely different flavors of this rivalry. We saw a Week 2 blowout that left Miami fans questioning everything, followed by a Week 9 thriller that literally came down to the final seconds and a record-breaking leg.
The Week 2 Meltdown in Miami
September 12, 2024. Thursday Night Football. The lights were bright, the humidity was thick, and the Dolphins looked ready to finally slay the dragon.
It didn't happen.
Instead, James Cook decided to have the game of his life. He scored three touchdowns in the first half alone. Three! He was darting through holes that the Bills' offensive line opened up like garage doors. He finished with 78 yards on the ground and another score through the air. Buffalo took a 24-10 lead into the half and never looked back.
But the score—a definitive 31-10 Bills win—wasn't the story everyone was talking about the next morning.
The Moment Everything Changed for Tua
The air sucked right out of the stadium in the third quarter. Tua Tagovailoa scrambled, lowered his head, and collided with Damar Hamlin. It was one of those hits where you just know. Tua went down with his third documented concussion, and for a while, the football world stopped caring about the AFC East standings. It was about the human being.
Miami's offense, which is usually this high-flying track meet, just evaporated. Skylar Thompson came in, but the Bills' defense, led by Ja'Marcus Ingram’s two interceptions (one of which he took back for a pick-six), was just too much.
Bills vs Dolphins 2024: The Orchard Park Rematch
By the time Week 9 rolled around on November 3, the vibes had shifted. Tua was back. The Dolphins were desperate. Buffalo was sitting pretty at 6-2, looking to put a stranglehold on the division.
This game was different. It wasn't a track meet; it was a heavyweight slugfest.
The Dolphins actually looked like the better team for long stretches. Tyreek Hill was involved, De'Von Achane was slashing through the secondary, and the Miami defense was actually making Josh Allen sweat. Allen didn't have his usual "Superman" game. He threw for 235 yards and three touchdowns, but he also threw a pick and struggled to find a rhythm early on.
Tyler Bass and the Kick Heard ‘Round Western New York
The game was tied 27-27. There were only seconds left. Buffalo was stalled around the Miami 43-yard line. Most coaches would've punted or tried a Hail Mary. Sean McDermott sent out Tyler Bass.
Now, you've gotta understand the context here. Bass had been struggling. He’d missed extra points and short field goals earlier in the season. The fans were restless. But he stepped up and nailed a 61-yard field goal.
It was a franchise record.
The ball cleared the uprights with room to spare. Highmark Stadium absolutely exploded. That single kick basically ended the Dolphins' hopes of winning the AFC East in 2024. It was the kind of moment that defines a season.
Why the Bills Keep Winning This Matchup
People love to talk about the "Josh Allen vs. Tua" debate, but it’s kinda deeper than that. Since Sean McDermott took over, he’s gone 14-2 against Miami. That’s not just a trend; it’s a psychological edge.
💡 You might also like: When is NFL Super Bowl 2025? What You Need to Know About the Big Game
- Defensive Schemes: Buffalo’s defensive coordinator always seems to have a plan for Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle. They play "top-down" coverage that forces Miami to be patient. Miami isn't good at being patient.
- Physicality: In both 2024 games, the Bills' offensive line bullied the Dolphins' front. When you can run for 100+ yards at will, the pass rush loses its teeth.
- The "Allen" Factor: Even when Josh Allen has an "off" day, he makes two or three plays that no other human can make. Whether it’s a 15-yard scramble on 3rd and 12 or a shovel pass to a backup tight end like Quintin Morris, he finds a way.
What This Means for the Future
The bills vs dolphins 2024 series proved that while the gap might be closing in terms of talent, the "clutch" gap is still wide. Miami had every chance to win that game in November. They didn't.
If the Dolphins want to flip the script, they have to figure out how to win in the cold and how to stop James Cook from becoming Thurman Thomas every time he sees a teal jersey. For Buffalo, 2024 was a reminder that they are still the kings of the North, even when they aren't playing their best football.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts:
- Watch the Trenches: In future matchups, ignore the wide receivers. Watch the Bills' guards against the Dolphins' interior defensive line. That is where these games are decided.
- Monitor the Kicking Game: Tyler Bass's 61-yarder changed his career trajectory. Confidence is everything for a kicker, and Buffalo's special teams are now a weapon, not a liability.
- Tua's Health vs. Mobility: Notice how Tua played differently in the second matchup? He was quicker to get rid of the ball. This helps him stay safe but limits those big, explosive plays Miami craves.
- The James Cook Evolution: Cook is no longer just a "change of pace" back. He is the engine of the Bills' offense. Expect him to be the focal point of every game plan against Miami moving forward.
The 2024 season solidified the Bills' dominance, but the razor-thin margin in the second game suggests that the Dolphins aren't going away. They're just one 61-yard kick away from changing the narrative.
Next Steps:
To get the full picture of the 2024 AFC East race, you should compare these Bills-Dolphins stats with the Bills' performance against the Jets later that season to see how Buffalo handled different defensive looks. You might also want to look into the updated NFL concussion protocols that were heavily discussed following the Week 2 incident.