You’re sitting at the Seder table. The Haggadah is open, the wine is poured, and then comes the moment everyone—especially the kids—dreads just a little bit. It’s time for the bitter herbs of Passover. You take a piece of matzah, glob on some of that sinus-clearing white horseradish, and take a bite. Your eyes water. Your throat burns. It’s intense. Honestly, it’s meant to be.
Most people call it Maror. It’s one of the most visceral parts of the Seder, a physical jolt designed to stop you from just reading a book and start making you feel history. But there is a massive amount of confusion about what actually counts as a bitter herb, why we use certain plants over others, and how a leafy green vegetable like romaine lettuce ended up in the same category as a root that feels like a chemical explosion in your nose.
📖 Related: Where Should We Begin: Why Esther Perel’s Card Game is the Anti-Small Talk Remedy You Need
The Botany of Bitterness
The Torah is pretty specific but also kind of vague. It says to eat the Paschal lamb with matzah and merorim—plural for bitter things. It doesn't give a grocery list.
Maimonides, the heavy-hitting 12th-century scholar and physician, actually tried to narrow this down. In his Mishneh Torah, he notes that there are five specific species that fulfill the requirement. The Mishnah (Pesachim 2:6) lists them as Chazeret, Ulshin, Tamcha, Charchavina, and Maror.
Now, here is where it gets tricky. Translating ancient Hebrew plant names into modern English or Latin is a mess.
Take Chazeret. Most scholars agree this is romaine lettuce. You might think, "Wait, romaine isn't bitter." And you'd be right, mostly. But if you let romaine grow past its prime, the stalk becomes woody and the sap turns into a milky, bitter liquid. The rabbis loved this as a metaphor. The Egyptian enslavement started "sweet" or soft—think of Joseph being a hero in Egypt—and ended up bitter and hard.
Then there’s Tamcha. In many Ashkenazi households, this is synonymous with horseradish. But many botanists, including the late Professor Yehuda Feliks who was a legend in the world of Biblical botany, argued that Tamcha was likely a type of horehound or even wild chicory. Horseradish didn't even really show up in the Jewish culinary scene until it moved into colder European climates where green herbs wouldn't grow in early spring.
Why Horseradish Became the King of Maror
If you live in a place like New York, London, or Warsaw, finding fresh, bitter lettuce in the middle of a cold spring wasn't always a thing. You used what you had stored in the cellar.
Enter the horseradish root.
It’s hardy. It’s cheap. It’s definitely "bitter" in a loose sense of the word, though scientifically it’s more of a pungent heat than a true bitter taste like kale or coffee. There’s a funny bit of halachic (Jewish law) debate here. Technically, the herb should be eaten raw. If you grate it and let it sit out, it loses its kick. If you cook it, it’s useless for the mitzvah.
Some people get really intense about the grating process. They’ll tell you that if you don't cry while prepping the bitter herbs of Passover, you’re doing it wrong. That’s probably more folklore than law, but it adds to the atmosphere.
The Romaine Lettuce Controversy
There is a legitimate health and religious safety issue that often pops up with the "best" bitter herb: romaine lettuce.
Because romaine is the preferred choice in the Mishnah, many people want to use it. However, the leaves are notorious for harboring tiny bugs. In Jewish law, eating a bug is a major no-no. This has led to a whole industry of "triple-washed" or greenhouse-grown bug-free lettuce.
Some families skip the leaves entirely and just eat the crunchy stalks. Others stick to the horseradish just to avoid the bug headache. If you're going the lettuce route, you've gotta be meticulous. It's one of those weird moments where biology and ancient ritual collide in a kitchen sink full of cold water and vinegar.
Beyond the Taste: The Neurobiology of the Seder
There's a reason we don't just talk about being slaves; we eat the experience.
Neuroscience tells us that bitter tastes are processed differently by the brain. Bitterness is often a warning signal for poison. When you hit your tongue with Maror, your body's "threat" system flares up for a second. It wakes you up.
🔗 Read more: Why Pioneer Woman Potato Soup is the Only Comfort Food Recipe You Actually Need
- It creates a "flashbulb memory."
- The sharp flavor cuts through the heaviness of the meal.
- It forces a physical reaction (tears, coughing) that mirrors grief.
The bitter herbs of Passover function as a sensory anchor. You aren't just a spectator; your body is reacting to the story. It’s "edible history," as some educators like to call it.
Chazeret vs. Maror: Using Two Herbs
If you look at a traditional Seder plate, there are actually two spots for herbs. One is labeled Maror, and the other is Chazeret.
Why two?
Basically, we eat bitter herbs twice. First, by themselves (after dipping in charoset), and second, as part of the "Hillel Sandwich" (Korech). Hillel, a famous sage from the Second Temple period, believed you had to eat the lamb, the matzah, and the herbs all in one bite. Since we don't have the Temple sacrifice anymore, we do a "remembrance" of his sandwich.
Often, people use the grated horseradish for the first "hit" and the romaine lettuce for the sandwich. It’s a way to cover your bases and make sure you’ve ticked off at least two of those ancient species mentioned in the Mishnah.
How to Handle the Heat: Practical Tips
If you're hosting and you want to do this right without sending your Great Aunt to the emergency room, there’s some nuance to the prep.
Don't buy the jarred stuff.
The vinegar in bottled horseradish "cooks" the herb, which some authorities say makes it invalid for the ritual. Buy the raw root. It looks like a dirty parsnip. Peel it, grate it fresh on the day of the Seder, and keep it covered so the volatile oils don't evaporate.
The Charoset Buffer
We dip the Maror into Charoset (that sweet apple/nut/wine paste). Don't leave it in there too long. The sweetness is supposed to be a "remedy" for the bitterness, but if you soak it, you lose the point of the bitter herb entirely. You want a coating, not a marinade.
The "Size of an Olive" Rule
To technically fulfill the commandment, you need to eat a k’zayit. This is a volume roughly the size of a large olive. Doing that with pure, fresh-grated horseradish is a feat of strength. Most people mix a tiny bit of horseradish with a larger piece of romaine lettuce to make that volume manageable.
What If You Can't Find the "Real" Stuff?
History is full of Jews using whatever they could find. In some parts of Italy, people used wild artichokes. In other regions, they used endives or escarole. The common thread is the "milky sap" and the bitter finish.
💡 You might also like: Esco Marietta Restaurant and Tapas: Why This Spot Is Actually Worth the Hype
If you're stuck, the principle is simple: it needs to be a vegetable, it needs to be bitter, and it shouldn't be something so obscure that nobody recognizes it as food.
Honestly, the bitter herbs of Passover remind us that life isn't all wine and reclining. There’s a jagged edge to the human experience. We eat the bitterness to acknowledge that it existed, but we do it while sitting at a table of free people. That's the real power of the ritual.
Actionable Steps for Your Seder
To make the most of this tradition, start by sourcing a fresh horseradish root at least two days in advance, as they can sometimes be hard to find at the last minute. When prepping the romaine, check the inner heart leaves for the most "bitter" punch, as these are often closer to the ancient variety intended by the text. Finally, try explaining the "sweet-to-bitter" growth of the lettuce to your guests; it's a much more engaging story than just complaining about the heat of the root.
To ensure the herbs remain potent for the ceremony, keep them tightly sealed in a glass jar in the refrigerator immediately after grating. If you find the raw horseradish too overpowering to consume in the required amount, utilize the "Hillel Sandwich" method by wrapping the root in a large romaine leaf, which provides a cooling moisture that makes the experience significantly more tolerable for most palates.