Black Friday Explained: What it Actually Means and Why the Story Changed

Black Friday Explained: What it Actually Means and Why the Story Changed

You've seen the videos. Crowds sprinting through sliding glass doors, people tugging at the last discounted 4K TV like their lives depend on it, and the inevitable surge of "doorbuster" emails hitting your inbox at 3:00 AM. It’s a chaotic American tradition that has somehow infected the entire globe. But if you stop and think about it, the phrase itself is kinda weird. Most "Black" days in history—like Black Monday or Black Tuesday—refer to horrific stock market crashes or national tragedies. So, why do we use it for the biggest shopping spree of the year?

What what does mean of black friday actually refers to depends entirely on who you ask and which decade you're standing in.

💡 You might also like: The Dream Hotel: Why Daniel Glass’s Noir Mystery Still Sticks With You

It isn't just one thing. It's a mix of police jargon, accounting myths, and a very clever PR pivot that saved the retail industry's reputation. Honestly, the real story is much grittier than the "saving money" narrative we get fed today.


The Philadelphian Origins: It Wasn't a Celebration

Forget the idea that Black Friday started as a happy holiday. It didn't. In the 1950s and 60s, the Philadelphia Police Department used the term "Black Friday" to describe the absolute nightmare they faced on the day after Thanksgiving.

It was a mess.

The city would get flooded with suburban shoppers and tourists arriving early for the Army-Navy football game held that Saturday. Police officers were forced to work grueling 12-hour shifts. They couldn't take the day off. The streets were choked with traffic, sidewalks were packed, and shoplifting was rampant because the crowds were too big to monitor. For the cops, it was a "black" day because it was exhausting and dangerous.

Local retailers hated the name. They tried to change it to "Big Friday" to make it sound more inviting and less like a funeral, but the nickname stuck. You can’t really force a nickname, and "Big Friday" just felt corporate and fake. People liked the edge of Black Friday.

The Accounting Myth: Getting Out of the Red

By the 1980s, the term was spreading across the country. Retailers realized they couldn't stop people from calling it Black Friday, so they did what businesses do best: they rebranded the origin story.

This is where the "In the Black" theory comes from.

The story goes that most retailers operated at a financial loss—referred to as being "in the red"—for the majority of the year. Thanksgiving supposedly marked the turning point. On the day after, the massive surge in sales would finally push their books into the profit column, or "into the black." It sounds logical. It makes sense if you’ve ever looked at a ledger. But according to the Oxford English Dictionary and researchers like Bonnie Taylor-Blake of the American Dialect Society, this was largely a retrospective explanation. It was a way to take a negative term coined by frustrated police and turn it into a success story for capitalism.

It worked.

Nowadays, most people genuinely believe the accounting version is the true one. It’s a cleaner, happier story than "the police were overworked and the city was a zoo."


Why It Still Matters (Even When Deals Are Everywhere)

You’ve probably noticed that Black Friday isn’t just a Friday anymore. We have "Black November," "Early Access Deals," and "Cyber Monday." So, does the day even mean anything in 2026?

Actually, it does.

Psychologically, Black Friday acts as a social anchor. Even if the discounts are the same as they were three weeks ago, the collective energy of the event creates a "scarcity mindset." Dr. Robert Cialdini, a famous expert on influence, often talks about social proof and scarcity. When you see everyone else hunting for a deal, your brain tells you that the deal must be valuable.

  • The Loss Leader Strategy: Stores like Walmart or Target often sell "doorbusters" at a loss. They lose money on that one TV just to get you through the door so you’ll buy pajamas, towels, and groceries at full price.
  • The Manufactured Hype: A lot of the clothing sold on Black Friday is actually manufactured specifically for the sale. It might look like the high-end version, but it’s often made with cheaper fabrics or fewer features to hit that "70% off" price point.
  • The FOMO Factor: Fear of missing out is the engine. If you don't buy it Friday, you'll regret it Saturday.

The Dark Side: Safety and Consumption

We can't talk about the meaning of this day without acknowledging the human cost. Websites like Black Friday Death Count have spent years tracking injuries and fatalities associated with the holiday. It’s a grim reality. While retailers have tried to move away from the "midnight madness" openings to protect staff and customers, the pressure to perform remains.

There's also the environmental impact. The massive influx of cheap plastic goods and the carbon footprint of millions of delivery trucks on the road following the weekend is astronomical. For some, Black Friday has come to mean "peak consumerism," leading to the rise of counter-movements like "Buy Nothing Day," which falls on the same date.


Actionable Insights: How to Actually Win

If you’re going to participate in the madness, don’t just wing it. Knowing what Black Friday means gives you the upper hand because you realize it's a game.

👉 See also: Why Small Table Lamps for Kitchen Counters are Finally Replacing Harsh Overheads

1. Use price trackers. Don't trust the "Original Price" listed on the tag. Use tools like CamelCamelCamel (for Amazon) or Honey to see if the price was actually lower in July. Often, retailers hike prices in October just so they can "slash" them in November.

2. Check the model numbers. If a laptop seems too cheap to be true, look at the serial number. It’s often a "derivative model" with a worse screen or a slower processor than the standard version you see in reviews.

3. Stick to a list. The stores are designed to disorient you. The bright signs and loud music are there to bypass your logical brain. If it wasn't on your list before Thanksgiving, you probably don't need it.

4. Wait for the "Open Box" items. A massive percentage of Black Friday purchases are returned by mid-December. If you can wait two weeks, you can often find the same items in the "Open Box" section of stores like Best Buy for even less than the Black Friday price.

Black Friday started as a nightmare for Philadelphia cops and turned into a global economic phenomenon. Whether it’s about "the black ink" or just a cultural habit, it remains the most intense 24 hours in the retail calendar. It's a day of contradictions—extreme savings mixed with extreme spending, and tradition mixed with pure, calculated marketing. Log off the hype, look at the data, and only buy what you actually intended to own before the flashing lights started.