October 1929 didn't just happen. It crashed. Most people think the Great Depression started with one bad afternoon on Wall Street, but that's a bit of a myth. It was actually a rolling disaster. You had Black Thursday on October 24, and then, after a weekend of pure panic and sweating through suits, Black Tuesday hit on October 29. It was messy.
The 1920s were wild. Everyone was buying on margin, which is basically a fancy way of saying they were gambling with money they didn't actually have. Imagine putting down ten bucks to buy a hundred dollars' worth of stock. If the price goes up, you're a genius. If it drops even a little, the broker calls you and demands the cash you don't have. That’s a margin call. By 1929, the whole American economy was basically a giant house of cards built on these calls.
The Day the Panic Started: Black Thursday
It began on October 24.
The opening bell rang, and things immediately felt "off." Prices didn't just dip; they gapped down. By eleven in the morning, the trading floor at the New York Stock Exchange was a literal mosh pit of screaming men. Stocks like Montgomery Ward and RCA were getting hammered. The ticker tape—the machine that printed out stock prices—couldn't keep up. It was running nearly two hours late. Think about that. You're trying to sell a stock, but the price you’re seeing on the screen is what it was worth 120 minutes ago. In a crash, that's an eternity.
Around noon, a group of high-rolling bankers decided to play hero. Thomas Lamont of J.P. Morgan and Richard Whitney, the Vice President of the Exchange, met up. They pooled their money—about $25 million—and started buying. Whitney walked over to the U.S. Steel post and placed a huge order at a price well above the current market. It worked, mostly. The bleeding stopped. The market even recovered some of its losses by the end of the day. People went home thinking the worst was over.
They were wrong.
The weekend was a psychological nightmare. Over those few days, investors had nothing to do but look at their bank accounts and realize they were ruined. Margin calls went out by the thousands. Families sat in their living rooms realizing the "paper wealth" they had bragged about at dinner parties was gone.
Black Tuesday: When the Floor Fell Out
If Thursday was a warning, October 29 was the execution.
This is the day everyone remembers. Black Tuesday was the single most devastating day in the history of the stock market up to that point. The "bankers' pool" from the previous Thursday didn't show up to save the day this time. They couldn't. The volume of selling was just too massive.
Over 16 million shares changed hands. That might not sound like much today when high-frequency algorithms trade billions of shares in a blink, but in 1929, it was a physical impossibility. The machines literally broke. The ticker tape stayed late into the night. Some brokers just stopped answering the phones. They couldn't face the people on the other end who were losing their life savings in real-time.
Why the recovery failed
- The Fed stayed quiet. The Federal Reserve didn't jump in to provide liquidity like they do now. They basically watched it burn.
- Foreign investors bailed. European markets saw the smoke and started pulling their capital out of New York immediately.
- Massive Leverage. Because people only paid 10% for their stocks, a 10% drop meant they lost 100% of their investment.
- Blind Panic. There was no "circuit breaker" back then. No one stopped the trading to let people breathe.
By the time the closing bell rang on Tuesday, the market had lost billions of dollars. And it wasn't just the rich guys in top hats. It was the janitors, the teachers, and the small business owners who had been told that the "New Era" of prosperity would never end.
The Fallout Nobody Saw Coming
A lot of people think the crash ended and the Depression started the next morning. It was slower than that. The market actually had a few "dead cat bounces" where it looked like it might recover in 1930. But the damage to the American psyche was permanent.
📖 Related: Exchange Rate Dollar to Kyat: What Most People Get Wrong
Banks started failing because they had used depositors' money to bet on the market. When you went to the bank to get your savings out, the doors were locked. This led to "bank runs." People stood in lines blocks long just to be told their money didn't exist anymore.
Economists like Milton Friedman later argued that the crash itself didn't have to cause the Great Depression. He blamed the Federal Reserve for letting the money supply shrink. On the other hand, John Maynard Keynes pointed toward a fundamental drop in "aggregate demand." Basically, people were too scared to spend money, so factories closed, so people lost jobs, so they spent even less. It was a death spiral.
What We Learned (and What We Didn't)
After the dust settled, the government finally stepped in. They created the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 1934 to stop the crazy manipulation that led to the crash. They passed the Glass-Steagall Act to keep commercial banks from gambling with your rent money.
But honestly? We still see the same patterns.
The 1987 crash, the 2008 housing bubble, and even the "flash crashes" of the 2020s all share DNA with October 1929. Human greed is a constant. We get confident, we borrow too much, and we panic when the red numbers start flashing. The difference now is that the Fed has a much bigger printing press, and we have "circuit breakers" that shut down the market if things get too ugly too fast.
Actionable Steps for Modern Investors
If you're looking at the history of Black Thursday and Black Tuesday and wondering how to not let that happen to your own portfolio, here’s the reality.
First, check your leverage. If you are trading on margin, you are playing the same game people played in 1929. It’s fine when the market goes up 1% a day, but it’s lethal when it drops 10% in an hour. Limit your use of borrowed money.
Second, diversification isn't just a buzzword. In 1929, the people who had some money in gold, some in land, and some in cash (outside of the failing banks) survived. Those who were 100% in "hot" stocks got wiped out. Ensure your assets aren't all tied to the same "buy" button.
Third, keep an emergency fund. Not in a brokerage account. In a boring, high-yield savings account or even a physical form if you're truly worried about systemic failure. You need "sleep at night" money that isn't affected by what happens on Wall Street.
Finally, ignore the "New Era" talk. Whenever you hear someone say "this time it's different" or "the old rules of economics don't apply anymore," that's your signal to be careful. The technology changes—from ticker tapes to fiber-optic cables—but the way humans react to losing money never does.
Study the charts from 1929. Look at the "sucker rallies" that happened after the initial crash. It took years for the market to actually hit bottom in 1932. Patience is usually the only thing that saves you when the world feels like it's ending.