You probably think of Blake Lively and immediately see the blonde waves, the Met Gala gowns, or maybe her poking fun at Ryan Reynolds on Instagram. But go back to Blake Lively 2004, and the vibe was totally different. She wasn't an "It Girl." She was just a lanky, soccer-playing teenager at Burbank High School who was actually kind of annoyed by the idea of acting.
Honestly, the story of how she ended up on a movie set that year is mostly thanks to her brother, Eric, being a bit of a pest. He saw something in her that she didn't see—or just didn't want to see yet.
The Brother Who "Tricked" Her
In early 2004, Blake was a junior in high school. She was busy. She was class president, a cheerleader, and performed in the show choir. Acting? That was the "family business," and she wanted no part of it. Her parents taught acting classes, and her siblings were already in the industry. She wanted to go to Stanford.
👉 See also: Jimmy Carter Death Cause: What Really Happened with the 39th President
Then Eric started making calls.
He told agents about his sister. He basically set up auditions without her permission. "I was really busy at school," she once recalled. Eventually, just to get him off her back, she agreed to go to a few. One of those was for a little movie based on a popular book called The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants.
She didn't have an agent. She didn't even have a headshot. At the audition, she just walked in, handed them a piece of paper with her name on it, and walked out. They thought she was joking. They thought it was a "bit."
It wasn't. She just didn't care that much. And ironically, that "I don't care" energy was exactly what they wanted for the character of Bridget Vreeland.
Filming the Summer of 2004
While the movie hit theaters in 2005, the magic of Blake Lively 2004 happened behind the scenes during production. She spent that summer filming in Mexico and Greece. Imagine being 16 or 17, having never really worked a "real" job, and suddenly you're flown across the world to play a star soccer player.
She actually had to learn how to play soccer for the role. She's joked before that she was mostly just tall and "clumsy," used as a "beast" to barrel through other kids so the actually talented players could get the ball.
The bond you see on screen with America Ferrera, Alexis Bledel, and Amber Tamblyn? That started right there in 2004. They weren't just coworkers; they became a legitimate support system. In an industry that usually tries to pit young women against each other, they did the opposite.
🔗 Read more: Prince William: Why the Brother of Prince Harry is Moving in a Totally Different Direction
The Mean Girls Near-Miss
Here’s a detail that feels like a glitch in the multiverse: Blake Lively almost played Karen Smith in Mean Girls.
The movie came out in April 2004, but the casting happened right before. She was a finalist for the role that eventually went to Amanda Seyfried. The producers reportedly loved her, but they felt Amanda had more of that "spacey" vibe they needed. Can you imagine Blake Lively doing the "I have a fifth sense" bit? It’s hard to picture now, but 2004 was the year she almost became a Plastic.
Life at Burbank High
Even after she booked a lead role in a major Hollywood production, Blake went back to school. She didn't drop out. She didn't get a private tutor and disappear into a trailer.
She returned for her senior year.
She kept her role as class president. She kept doing show choir. There’s something very grounded about that—finishing your AP classes while knowing you have a movie coming out in a few months. Most people would have checked out, but she seemed to want to soak up every bit of a "normal" life before the Gossip Girl whirlwind eventually changed everything three years later.
Why 2004 Matters for the Lively Brand
If you look at how she handles her career now—the DIY styling, the business ventures like Betty Buzz, the very specific way she controls her image—it all traces back to that 2004 independence. She wasn't a "theatre kid" desperate for a break. She was a girl who knew who she was before the cameras started rolling.
Key takeaways from her 2004 era:
- Authenticity wins: Her "non-actor" attitude at the Sisterhood audition is what got her the job.
- Support systems are vital: The friendships she made that year have lasted over two decades.
- Stay grounded: She chose to finish high school traditionally despite having a foot in the door of Hollywood.
If you're looking to capture some of that 2004-era Blake energy, start by leaning into your own natural strengths rather than trying to fit a specific mold. Sometimes, the thing you’re "tricked" into doing turns out to be the thing that defines your life.
To see how much has changed, you can track her filmography starting from that 2005 debut and compare it to her more recent, self-produced projects. It's a masterclass in evolving from a "reluctant" actress into a total industry powerhouse.