So, the dust has finally settled on what was easily the most chaotic postseason in the history of this sport. Honestly, if you told me back in August that we’d see a 12-team field actually work without the universe imploding, I probably would’ve laughed. But here we are. Looking back at the bowl game projections 2024 experts were sweating over, it’s wild to see how much they actually missed.
The transition to the 12-team College Football Playoff (CFP) changed every single variable. It wasn't just about the Top 4 anymore; it was about home-field advantage in December and how the "Group of Five" would hold up against the blue bloods. Spoiler alert: they held up better than the critics expected, even if the scoreboard didn't always show it.
Why the Early Season Projections Floundered
The biggest mistake people made with bowl game projections 2024 was assuming the old power structures would remain rigid. We saw teams like Indiana and Arizona State completely wreck the "preseason darling" narrative. Remember when everyone thought the SEC would grab six spots in the bracket? Yeah, that didn't happen.
Instead, we got a Big Ten that basically flexed its muscles across the entire continent. The committee had a nightmare of a time seeding the 5 through 12 spots because the difference between a one-loss at-large and a two-loss conference runner-up was razor-thin.
✨ Don't miss: When are the Vikings playing? Navigating the 2025-2026 NFL Schedule and Playoff Hunt
- The Bye Week Myth: Everyone thought the top four seeds would be untouchable. But the reality? That time off actually led to some serious "rust vs. Bell" scenarios.
- Home Games Matter: Watching a first-round playoff game at a place like Notre Dame Stadium in late December? That’s a different kind of football. The projections didn't account for the "frozen tundra" factor enough.
The First Round: Where the Math Met the Mud
When the actual matchups dropped, the bowl game projections 2024 finally hit the reality of the 12-team bracket. We saw No. 7 Notre Dame take down No. 10 Indiana in a game that felt more like a heavyweight fight than a track meet. Final score was 27-17, but it felt closer.
Then you had the absolute demolition in Columbus. Ohio State, sitting at No. 8, basically told Tennessee that the "Orange Crush" wasn't ready for prime time yet, winning 42-17. It was a statement. It told the world that the seeding didn't necessarily reflect the actual talent on the field.
The most intriguing game of that opening weekend was definitely SMU at Penn State. A lot of people—mostly "experts" on Twitter—thought SMU would get bullied. And they did, losing 38-10. But the fact that a Group of Five-adjacent program was even in that environment changed the recruitment calculus for the next five years.
💡 You might also like: NCAA Basketball Rankings Complete: Why the AP Poll and NET Don't Always Agree
Quarterfinals and the "New Year's Six" Evolution
Once we moved into the traditional bowl windows, the stakes got weirdly higher. The Fiesta Bowl saw Penn State continue their tear, handling Boise State 31-14. It sort of validated the committee's decision to keep Boise at the No. 3 seed despite the "strength of schedule" haters.
But the Peach Bowl? That was the one. Texas and Arizona State went into double overtime. Imagine the nerves. Texas eventually pulled it out 39-31, but Arizona State proved that the Big 12 wasn't just a "basketball conference" anymore.
- Rose Bowl: Ohio State 41, Oregon 21. A classic Big Ten showdown that lived up to the hype, even if Oregon's defense disappeared in the fourth.
- Sugar Bowl: The upset of the century. Notre Dame 23, Georgia 10. Nobody, and I mean nobody, had Georgia scoring only ten points in a playoff game.
The Non-Playoff Gems You Probably Missed
If you only watched the CFP, you missed the real "sickos" football. The bowl game projections 2024 for the smaller games were actually pretty spot on for entertainment value.
The Detroit Bowl was a literal fever dream. Toledo and Pitt went into six—yes, six—overtimes. Toledo won 48-46. It was the kind of game that makes you question why you stay up until 1:00 AM on a Tuesday, but you're glad you did.
Then there was the Pop-Tarts Bowl. Beyond the meme of the edible mascot, the game was a banger. Iowa State took down Miami 42-41. It was a high-octane reminder that even outside the Top 12, there is a ton of NFL-level talent playing for "meaningless" trophies.
What This Means for Your 2025 Strategy
If you're looking at these results and trying to figure out how to handle your 2025 bets or brackets, here is the cold, hard truth: momentum is a lie, but depth is everything. The teams that succeeded in this new 12-team format were the ones that didn't have to rely on 11 starters. You need a 22-man rotation because the season is now essentially two games longer for the finalists.
💡 You might also like: Mike Smith NHL Goalie: What Most People Get Wrong
- Ignore the Name on the Jersey: The gap between the "Power 4" and the top of the "Group of 5" is closing because of the transfer portal.
- Value the O-Line: In the late-season cold-weather games (South Bend, Columbus, State College), the teams with the 300-pounders who could still move in the fourth quarter won every single time.
- Kicking is the X-Factor: We saw three bowl games decided by missed field goals in the final two minutes. If your team doesn't have a reliable kicker, they aren't a title contender. Period.
Basically, the 2024 bowl season proved that the "projections" are mostly just educated guesses until the first snow falls in the Midwest. The 12-team era is here, it’s messy, and it’s exactly what college football needed to stay relevant.
Keep an eye on the portal entries this spring. That’s where the 2025 "projections" actually begin. If a team is losing its entire defensive secondary to the highest bidder, don't be surprised when they're the ones getting lit up in a first-round home game next December.