You know that feeling when everyone’s waiting for the other shoe to drop? That’s been the vibe around the starting qb for the 49ers for what feels like forever. Except the shoe never really hits the floor. It just keeps hovering.
Honestly, we’re sitting here in early 2026, and the conversation hasn't changed as much as people thought it would. Brock Purdy is still the guy under center. He’s the one Kyle Shanahan trusts with the keys to the most expensive Ferrari in the NFC West. But the context? Man, the context is totally different now. We aren't talking about "Mr. Irrelevant" anymore. We’re talking about a guy who just signed a five-year, $265 million extension.
The $53 Million Question
If you’ve been following the Niners lately, you know that 2025 was a bit of a roller coaster. Purdy threw for over 2,100 yards through the first half of the season, and he even tied legends like Kurt Warner with seven career games of a 140.0+ passer rating. He’s efficient. He’s gritty. But he’s also human.
There’s this weird tension in Santa Clara right now. On one hand, you’ve got Shanahan saying things like, "Brock’s the one who I think will play better," even when the All-Pros around him start aging or getting banged up. On the other hand, the pressure is basically at a boiling point. The 49ers just scraped by the Eagles in the Wild Card round—a 23-19 nail-biter—and Purdy had to gut it out with a stinger in his left shoulder.
It wasn't pretty. He went 18-for-31 with two picks. But he won. That’s the Purdy experience in a nutshell.
What Most People Get Wrong About the 49ers QB Situation
A lot of fans think the starting qb for the 49ers is just a "system player." It’s a lazy take.
Look at the December 14th game against the Titans. Purdy was a magician. 23 of 30, three touchdowns, and a 140.3 rating. He even ripped off a career-long 26-yard run. You don't do that just by "following the script." You do that by having elite processing speed.
The real issue isn't whether Purdy is good. It’s whether the 49ers can survive the "Contract Era."
Back in the day, Purdy was a bargain. Now? His cap hit is jumping to nearly $25 million in 2026 and will eventually soar to over $57 million by 2028. That’s a lot of money that isn't going to the offensive line or a lockdown corner.
The Roster is Getting Thin
We’re seeing the cracks. George Kittle just went down with a season-ending Achilles tear in the Wild Card game. That is a massive blow. Christian McCaffrey is still a beast, but he’s carrying a workload that would break most humans.
📖 Related: Buffalo Bills Game Tomorrow: What Fans Need to Know After the Playoff Heartbreak
When people search for the starting qb for the 49ers, they’re usually looking for stats or injury updates. But the real story is the depth chart.
- Mac Jones is sitting there at QB2.
- Kurtis Rourke is the rookie on the NFI list.
- Adrian Martinez is the practice squad insurance.
If Purdy’s shoulder stinger from the Eagles game turns into something worse, the season changes in a heartbeat. Mac Jones in a Shanahan offense is an interesting "what if," but nobody in the 415 wants to actually see it happen in a Divisional Round game against the Seahawks.
Why 2026 is the True Litmus Test
This season is basically a "prove it" year despite the massive contract. Analysts like Grant Cohn have pointed out that while the deal looks huge, the 49ers actually have some flexibility to move on after 2026 if things go south.
That sounds crazy, right? Cutting a guy you just gave $182 million in guarantees?
But that’s the NFL. If the Niners don't bring home a Lombardi Trophy soon, the seat under Kyle Shanahan starts getting warm, and the quarterback is always the first one to take the heat.
🔗 Read more: Shemar Stewart Draft Profile: Why Every Scout Is Betting On This Monster
Purdy is 26 now. He’s not the kid from Iowa State anymore. He’s a veteran who has to lead a team that is currently missing stars like Brandon Aiyuk (ACL) and Nick Bosa (ACL). It’s a lot of weight to carry.
What You Should Watch For Next
If you’re tracking the starting qb for the 49ers through the rest of this postseason, keep your eyes on these specific things:
- The Shoulder Velocity: Watch the zip on his intermediate throws. If he’s floating balls, that stinger is still bothering him.
- Third Down Conversion Rate: Purdy admitted himself that they’ve been "gritty" but inefficient on third downs lately.
- The Kittle Void: How does he adjust without his favorite safety valve? Look for more targets going to Jauan Jennings and Ricky Pearsall.
The window isn't closed, but it’s definitely heavy. Purdy has the talent to push it open, but he’s going to have to do it with less help than he’s ever had before.
Actionable Insight for Fans: If you're betting or playing daily fantasy, keep a close watch on the Friday injury reports. The 49ers have been notorious for "limited" participants who end up as game-time decisions, especially with Purdy’s shoulder and the rotating door at linebacker.