If you grew up anywhere near the south suburbs of Chicago, you probably have a very specific memory of the Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant Orland Park IL. Maybe it was a high school graduation dinner where 15 of you crammed around a circular table. Or perhaps a birthday where you were forced to stare at a bust of the Pope while eating a meatball the size of a grapefruit.
It was loud. It was tacky. Honestly, it was a lot of fun.
But things have changed. If you’ve driven past the 15350 S. 94th Ave location lately, you might have noticed the parking lot looking a little emptier than it did in 2013. The kitschy, red-sauce empire that once defined "group dining" in Orland Park has hit some major speed bumps. Between corporate bankruptcies and shifting tastes, the story of Buca in Orland Park is basically a microcosm of what’s happening to casual dining across America.
The Orland Park Legend: More Than Just Pasta
Buca di Beppo wasn’t trying to be an authentic trattoria in Florence. It was an exaggerated, neon-soaked fever dream of a 1950s Little Italy basement. That’s literally what the name means—"Joe’s Basement."
For years, the Orland Park spot was the go-to for anyone who didn't want to deal with the pretension of downtown Chicago but wanted more "vibe" than a standard Olive Garden. You walked in and were immediately hit with thousands of framed photos. Some were genuine family snapshots; others were just random Italian-American icons like Sophia Loren or Joe DiMaggio.
The layout was a maze. You had the "Pope Room," the "Kitchen Table" where you could literally watch the line cooks sweat over your rigatoni, and various semi-private nooks that felt like you were dining in a relative's over-decorated living room. It was the perfect shield for a loud family. You couldn't possibly be the most annoying people in the room because the restaurant itself was designed to be louder than you.
The Reality of the Menu (and Those Giant Meatballs)
Let's talk about the food, because people usually fall into two camps here. You either love the "family style" chaos or you find it incredibly overwhelming.
The core of the experience was the Buca Small versus the Buca Large. A "small" was supposed to feed three people. A "large" could arguably feed a small army or one very determined teenager.
- The World Famous Meatballs: These are half-pound beasts. They come topped with marinara and a dollop of ricotta. Are they the best meatballs in Illinois? Probably not. Are they the most memorable? Absolutely.
- Chicken Carbonara: Sliced chicken, prosciutto, peas, and garlic in a heavy Alfredo sauce. It’s a calorie bomb, but it’s the definition of comfort food.
- Spicy Chicken Rigatoni: This is actually one of the more balanced dishes. It’s got a kick from the crushed red pepper and a bit of sweetness from the peas.
The problem, as many locals found out, is that the price tag started to creep up while the "wow" factor stayed the same. When you’re spending $40+ on a single platter of pasta, you start to wonder if you’re paying for the food or the 400 pictures of Frank Sinatra on the walls.
Why the Orland Park Location Hit the News
In August 2024, the parent company of Buca di Beppo filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. This wasn't just a corporate hiccup; it was a survival move. They ended up closing about 20% of their restaurants almost overnight.
Specifically, the Orland Park location was listed in bankruptcy filings as one of the "underperforming" spots that the company sought to reject leases for. While the brand is trying to stage a comeback under new ownership (Main Street Capital Corporation stepped in with a $30 million investment late in 2024), the landscape for the Orland Park site has been shaky.
✨ Don't miss: Why First Day of Fall 2025 Images Are Already Flooding Your Feed
It’s a tough spot to be in. Orland Park is a competitive dining hub. You’ve got everything from high-end steakhouses to local mom-and-pop Italian joints that don't have the "chain" baggage. When a brand like Buca starts to lose its luster, the "tacky-on-purpose" vibe can start to just feel... well, tacky.
What Most People Get Wrong About Buca
A lot of people think Buca di Beppo is an old-school Italian brand. It’s not. It was actually started in a basement in Minneapolis in 1993 by a guy named Phil Roberts. He wasn’t even Italian! He just loved the aesthetic of Italian-American culture.
The Orland Park location followed that blueprint perfectly. It was designed to be "good-natured bad taste." But as the years went on and the company went through various owners (including Planet Hollywood), the quality became hit-or-miss.
You’ve probably seen the mixed reviews online. One person raves about the "best lasagna ever," while the next person complains that their chicken was dry and the service was slow. That's the risk with these massive, high-volume restaurants. When they're "on," they're great for a party. When they're "off," it feels like a very expensive mistake.
Is It Still Worth the Trip?
If you’re planning a big group event—think 10 to 20 people—Buca still has one major advantage: they know how to handle a crowd. Most small Italian restaurants in the suburbs will panic if you show up with a party of 15 without a month's notice. Buca was built for it.
The catering is also still a major part of their business in the Orland Park area. They do "Celebration Packages" that feed groups of 10 or 20, which is a lifesaver for office lunches or graduation parties at home. You get the half pans of Baked Ziti, the salad, and the bread, and it’s usually much cheaper than dining in.
Quick Survival Tips for Buca Orland Park:
- Don't over-order. Seriously. One "Large" pasta and one "Large" salad is usually plenty for 5 people.
- Ask for the Kitchen Table. If you have a group of 6-10, it's the best seat in the house. You get to see the chaos of the kitchen up close.
- Check the status. Given the recent bankruptcy restructuring, always call ahead or check their official site before heading out. Things move fast in the restaurant world these days.
- Try the Apple Gorgonzola salad. It’s arguably the best thing on the menu and provides a much-needed break from the heavy carbs.
The Buca di Beppo in Orland Park represents a specific era of American dining—the era of "bigger is better" and "more is more." Whether it survives the current shift toward smaller, more "authentic" dining remains to be seen. But for now, those giant meatballs are still a piece of local history.
👉 See also: How to Spell Imagery: Why This Seven-Letter Word Trips Up the Best Writers
If you are looking to book a table, your best bet is to use their online reservation system directly on the official Buca website to ensure the location is currently accepting diners. For those planning a large event, skip the standard menu and ask for the "Group Dining" coordinator, as they often have set-price packages that can save you a significant amount compared to ordering à la carte.