Honestly, the drama between the White House and the Federal Reserve feels like a never-ending prestige TV show at this point. You’ve probably seen the headlines: "Trump Weighs Firing Powell" or "The Fed Chair is Under Investigation." It sounds like a simple question of who's the boss. But if you’re wondering, can Trump fire Jerome Powell, the answer is a messy "maybe, but probably not the way he wants to."
It’s January 2026, and the tension is at a boiling point. We’ve got criminal investigations into building renovations, "wanted posters" at Mar-a-Lago, and a Fed Chair who seems more determined than ever to stay put. This isn't just about interest rates anymore; it’s a full-blown constitutional cage match.
The "For Cause" Roadblock
Basically, the President can’t just wake up, decide Jerome Powell is "too slow" on interest rate cuts, and send him a "You're Fired" tweet. It doesn't work that way. The Federal Reserve Act is pretty clear: members of the Board of Governors can only be removed "for cause."
What does "for cause" actually mean? In the legal world, it’s not about having a different opinion on the economy. It usually requires something like:
- Inefficiency (being remarkably bad at the basic mechanics of the job).
- Neglect of duty (simply not showing up or doing the work).
- Malfeasance (actual corruption or illegal acts).
Policy disagreements? Nope. That doesn’t count. If Trump fired Powell because he didn't like a 0.25% rate hike, the courts would likely jump in faster than you can say "inflation."
🔗 Read more: Converting 30000 Canadian to US: What Most People Get Wrong About Big Transfers
The New Strategy: Investigations and Pretext
Since firing someone for their "vibes" on the economy is a legal dead end, the administration has shifted gears. You might have heard about the $2.5 billion renovation project at the Fed’s headquarters. Trump’s allies, including people like Bill Pulte, have called it a "marble palace" and accused Powell of gross mismanagement.
Now, the Justice Department is actually looking into whether Powell lied to Congress about those costs. This is the "pretext" Powell was talking about in his recent video statement. If the administration can prove malfeasance or criminality related to these renovations, they suddenly have a "for cause" reason that might actually hold up in court.
Can He Just "Demote" Him?
There’s a theory floating around that Trump could try to demote Powell from "Chair" to just a regular "Governor." The thinking is that while the law protects Governors from being fired, the Chairmanship is a four-year appointment that might be more vulnerable.
Legal experts are split on this. Some say the Chair is just a title within the board, and the same protections apply. Others think a President has more leeway to swap out the leader. Either way, it would lead to a massive lawsuit that would likely outlast Powell’s current term as Chair, which officially ends on May 15, 2026.
The Ghost of Humphrey's Executor
We have to talk about a case from 1935 called Humphrey’s Executor v. United States. It’s the "Old Faithful" of administrative law. Back then, FDR tried to fire a commissioner at the FTC just because they didn't see eye-to-eye on the New Deal. The Supreme Court basically said, "Wait a minute, you can't do that."
They ruled that for independent agencies like the Fed or the FTC, the President’s removal power is limited. However, the current Supreme Court has been leaning toward something called the Unitary Executive Theory. This is the idea that the President should have total control over anyone exercising executive power.
We’re seeing this play out right now with the case of Lisa Cook, another Fed governor Trump has tried to oust. If the Supreme Court rules that Trump can fire Cook without cause, then Jerome Powell’s job security evaporates overnight.
👉 See also: Michael Burry Net Worth Explained: Why the Big Short Legend is Richer (and Poorer) Than You Think
What Happens if He Tries Anyway?
If Trump actually issues a firing order tomorrow, here is the likely sequence of events:
- Powell refuses to leave. He’s already hinted at this. He’d argue the firing is unlawful and show up to work anyway.
- The Fed's "Shadow" Leadership. The Federal Open Market Committee (the group that actually sets interest rates) elects its own chair. Even if Trump "fires" Powell from the Board, the committee could theoretically just vote to keep him as their leader.
- Market Chaos. Investors hate uncertainty. The moment the independence of the Fed is questioned, the bond market usually throws a tantrum. We could see interest rates spike—the exact opposite of what the President wants.
- The Senate Standoff. To get a new Chair, Trump needs Senate confirmation. As of early 2026, even some Republican senators like Thom Tillis have expressed skepticism about the legal attacks on Powell.
The 2026 End Game
Here’s the thing: Powell’s term as Chair ends in May 2026 anyway. Most of this fighting is about the few months remaining or about whether he stays on the Board of Governors afterward (his term as a Governor doesn't end until January 2028).
If Powell stays on the board as a regular governor after May, he still gets a vote on interest rates. This would prevent Trump from getting a "clean slate" at the Fed and keep a vocal critic right in the room where it happens.
Actionable Insights for the Months Ahead
If you’re watching this play out, here’s how to interpret the noise:
🔗 Read more: Carvana Chandler Inspection Center: What Really Happens Before Your Car Arrives
- Watch the Courts, not the Tweets: The real battle isn't on social media; it’s in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. Watch the Lisa Cook case—it’s the bellwether for what can happen to Powell.
- Focus on May 15, 2026: This is the natural expiration date. If Trump hasn't fired him by March, he'll likely just wait it out and nominate a successor like Kevin Warsh or Kevin Hassett.
- Monitor the "For Cause" evidence: If the DOJ actually produces a smoking gun regarding the building renovations, the legal math changes. Without it, a firing is just a political gesture that the courts will likely strike down.
The independence of the Federal Reserve is one of those things people don't think about until it's gone. Whether you love Powell’s rate hikes or hate them, the fight over his job is really a fight over who controls the value of the dollar in your pocket.
Keep an eye on the Senate Banking Committee—their willingness to confirm a "loyalist" successor will tell you more about the future of the economy than any White House press release.