You think you know Joe Goldberg. You’ve probably watched Penn Badgley’s lonely-boy-turned-killer face on Netflix for four seasons, and you think the books just follow the same path. Honestly? They don’t. Not even close. If you’re trying to read the Caroline Kepnes You series in order, you’re walking into a much darker, more cynical, and frankly more "incel-adjacent" world than the show ever dared to portray.
The books aren’t just a blueprint for the series; they are a completely different beast. By the time you get to the third book, the TV show has basically gone off on its own tangent, leaving the source material in the dust. And with a new prequel on the horizon for 2026, the timeline is about to get even more tangled for casual readers.
The Definitive Caroline Kepnes You Series in Order
If you want to read them as they were released, it's pretty straightforward. But if you want the chronological story of how Joe became... well, Joe... there's a new twist coming.
1. You (2014)
This is where the obsession begins. Joe Goldberg meets Guinevere Beck at a bookstore in the East Village. If you’ve seen Season 1, the plot beats are familiar, but the vibe is "dirty." Joe’s internal monologue is far more vulgar and aggressive than the "charitable stalker" persona he has on screen. There is no Paco. There is no kid for Joe to save to prove he has a heart. In the book, Joe is just a predator.
📖 Related: John Cena Trainwreck Scene: Why It Changed His Career Forever
2. Hidden Bodies (2016)
Joe moves to Los Angeles. He’s looking for Amy Adam (a character the show turned into a fake name for Candace). He meets Love Quinn. This is where the show and the books start to divorce. In the book, Love is... different. The ending of this novel is a massive shocker that involves a jail cell and a very different fate for the Quinn family than what you saw on Netflix.
3. You Love Me (2021)
Forget the suburbs and the "Love-is-also-a-killer" plotline from Season 3. In the third book, Joe is in the Pacific Northwest. He’s trying to be a "good man" (his words, not mine) for a librarian named Mary Kay DiMarco. She has a daughter named Nomi. It’s a slow-burn obsession that proves Joe can’t actually change, even when he thinks he’s moved on from the carnage of LA.
4. For You and Only You (2023)
Joe goes to Harvard. Sorta. He gets into a prestigious writing fellowship. He meets "Wonder," a fellow writer who doesn't have a college degree just like him. This book is a scathing critique of the literary world. It’s pretentious, it’s mean, and it’s very Joe Goldberg. It has zero connection to the London "Eat the Rich" plot of Season 4.
5. You First (Coming June 2026)
This is the big one people are waiting for. It’s a prequel. It takes us back to 17-year-old Joe working for Mr. Mooney. We finally get to see the origin of the glass cage and his first "love," Vail Gunderson. Technically, if you want the chronological order, you'll start here once it's out.
Why the Order Matters More Than You Think
Most people assume they can jump into You Love Me after watching Season 2. Don’t do that. You will be hopelessly confused. In the books, Joe’s relationship with the Quinns ends in a way that makes his future "freedom" much more precarious. The Netflix show makes Joe a bit of a hero by giving him kids to protect. The books? No way.
The "Paco" Factor
In the show, Joe is humanized by Paco and Ellie. In the books, those kids don't exist. Without them, Joe is significantly more terrifying. You realize that his "love" isn't a misguided romantic impulse; it's a calculated, possessive illness. Reading them in order allows you to track the decay of his sanity without the "nice guy" filter that Penn Badgley provides.
💡 You might also like: Paul Walker and Brother: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes of Furious 7
Key Differences to Keep in Mind
If you're a fan of the show, here's a quick reality check on what changes when you open the novels:
- Candace: In the books, she is very dead. Like, actually dead. She doesn't come back to haunt him in LA.
- The Internal Voice: The prose is written in the second person ("You"). It feels like Joe is whispering directly into your ear, which is significantly more unsettling than a voiceover.
- The Fate of Love Quinn: The show handled her death with a poetic, poisonous dinner. The book... well, let's just say the Quinn family power is used in a much more legalistic and soul-crushing way for Joe.
What to Read After You Finish
Once you've blazed through the four current books, you might feel a Joe-shaped hole in your life. Caroline Kepnes has another book called Providence. It’s not part of the You universe—it’s more of a supernatural thriller—but it carries that same "obsessive love" energy that she’s famous for.
Basically, if you want the full Joe Goldberg experience, you have to commit to the page. The show is a polished, TV-friendly version of a much nastier story.
💡 You might also like: George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire: Why We’re All Still Waiting
Start with the 2014 original, keep your eyes peeled for the You First prequel in 2026, and remember: Joe is not the hero. He’s the guy you should be running from.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check your local library for You Love Me—it’s often the easiest one to find since it diverged so heavily from the show.
- Pre-order You First if you want to be the first to know Joe's actual origin story before the internet spoils it in 2026.
- Read book one even if you've seen the show; the ending is different enough to justify the re-read.