You’ve seen the memes and maybe heard the jokes about hillbillies shooting at each other over a pig. But when the cast of the Hatfields and McCoys hit the screen in 2012, it wasn’t some low-budget caricature. It was a massive, gritty, and surprisingly deep look at two men who basically broke their own lives to win a fight that didn't even matter in the end.
Honestly, it’s one of those rare times where the actors actually made you forget you were watching a "History Channel project." Before Yellowstone made Kevin Costner the king of the modern Western, this miniseries proved he still had that grit. But it wasn't just him. The ensemble was stacked with people who went on to become huge names, and some legends who gave their final great performances.
📖 Related: Upcoming Halle Berry Movies: What’s Actually Happening in 2026
The Titans: Costner and Paxton
The whole thing hangs on the chemistry—or rather, the simmering, mutual hatred—between Kevin Costner and Bill Paxton. Costner played William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield. He played him with this weary, dangerous stillness. You got the sense that Anse just wanted to be left alone to run his timber business, but he was also a man who wouldn't take a single inch of disrespect.
Then you had Bill Paxton as Randall McCoy. Man, Paxton was incredible here. He played Randall as a man literally vibrating with religious trauma and bitterness. While Anse was the prosperous "winner" of the post-war era, Randall was the guy who felt the world (and the Hatfields) had stolen everything from him.
"It’s biblical in its nature," Paxton once said about the story. He saw Randall as a victim of PTSD before that was even a term.
Watching them was like watching two trains about to collide for six hours. Costner ended up taking home the Emmy for Lead Actor, and honestly, it’s hard to argue with that. He brought a weight to the role that made the feud feel like a Greek tragedy instead of just a backyard brawl.
The Supporting Cast of the Hatfields and McCoys You Totally Forgot Were There
If you go back and watch it now, you’re gonna see a lot of "Wait, is that...?" moments. The depth of the cast of the Hatfields and McCoys is actually wild.
Take Boyd Holbrook, for example. Long before he was the villain in Logan or the DEA lead in Narcos, he was William "Cap" Hatfield. He played Anse’s son with this terrifying, blank-eyed loyalty. Cap was the guy who usually pulled the trigger when things got ugly. Holbrook, who is actually from Kentucky, brought a realness to the role that you can't just fake with an accent coach.
✨ Don't miss: Boruto Two Blue Vortex Chapter 16 Explained: Why Everything Just Changed for the Shinobi World
Then there’s Noel Fisher as Cotton Top Mounts. If you know him as Mickey from Shameless, his performance here will wreck you. He played the mentally disabled cousin who became the ultimate scapegoat for the entire feud. The scene where he’s facing the gallows? Genuinely heartbreaking.
The Women of the Feud
We have to talk about Mare Winningham and Jena Malone.
- Mare Winningham played Sally McCoy, Randall’s wife. She had the hardest job in the show—playing a woman watching her children die one by one. She was nominated for an Emmy for a reason; her descent into grief-induced madness is the darkest part of the whole series.
- Jena Malone played Nancy McCoy. She was the firebrand. Nancy was the one who realized she could use her beauty and her wits to manipulate the Hatfields from the inside. She played it with this sharp, jagged edge that made her one of the most interesting characters on screen.
Tom Berenger and the Warlords
You can't mention the cast of the Hatfields and McCoys without talking about Tom Berenger. He looked almost unrecognizable as Jim Vance, the "Uncle Jim" who basically started the shooting. He was the Hatfield family’s personal demon. Berenger won a Supporting Actor Emmy for this, and it was well-deserved. He played Vance as a guy who didn't just accept the violence—he enjoyed it.
On the other side, you had Powers Boothe as Judge Wall Hatfield. Boothe was always the king of playing authoritative men with a hint of menace, and here he was the "legal" arm of the Hatfield clan. It was a perfect contrast to the McCoy’s lawyer, Perry Cline (played by Ronan Vibert), who was more of a slimy, city-slicker type trying to use the law to steal land.
Why This Cast Worked So Well
Usually, when people talk about "historical" dramas, they expect something stiff. This wasn't that. The director, Kevin Reynolds, had worked with Costner before (on Robin Hood and Waterworld), so they had a shorthand.
The production actually filmed in Romania, not West Virginia or Kentucky. Sounds weird, right? But the Carpathian Mountains ended up looking more like the 1880s Appalachia than modern-day Appalachia does. It gave the actors this isolated, rugged environment to play in.
Reality vs. The Script
While the show is famous for its accuracy, the cast had to navigate some "Hollywood-ized" bits. For example:
🔗 Read more: Why the Harry Styles Newspaper Still Matters to Fans
- The Romance: The Johnse Hatfield (Matt Barr) and Roseanna McCoy (Lindsay Pulsipher) plotline felt like Romeo and Juliet, but in reality, it was much messier and less "pretty."
- Bad Frank Phillips: Andrew Howard played the McCoy's hired gun, Frank Phillips. In the show, he’s a total psychopath. In real life... well, he was pretty much a psychopath, so that part was spot on.
What to Do Next if You Liked the Show
If you’ve already binged the series and you’re obsessed with the cast of the Hatfields and McCoys, there are a few things you should check out to get the "real" story.
First, look up the actual photos of Devil Anse and Randall. The resemblance between the real Anse and Costner is actually pretty striking once you see the beard. Second, if you want to see where these actors went next, watch Yellowstone (obviously) for more Costner, or track down Big Love to see Bill Paxton in his prime.
Finally, if you're ever in the Tug Valley area of Kentucky or West Virginia, you can actually visit the gravesites. Seeing the names of the characters from the show on real headstones makes the performances of this cast hit a lot harder. It wasn't just a TV show for the people who lived it; it was a decades-long disaster that nearly started a war between two states.