Before she was headlining festivals in neon-green butterfly wings or teaching the world how to spell "H-O-T-T-O-G-O" with their arms, she was just Kayleigh Rose Amstutz. If you’d walked the halls of Willard High School in Missouri back in 2013, you might have seen her. Honestly, she wasn't the "Midwest Princess" then—at least not the version we see on stage now. She was a track runner. A choir kid. A girl who secretly downloaded Pandora in the school bathroom because her conservative upbringing didn't exactly encourage listening to Drake or Rihanna.
The story of Chappell Roan high school years isn't some polished Disney Channel origin story. It’s actually kinda messy. It’s the story of a girl who felt "disconnected and emotional" while living in a town of 3,000 people where church was a three-times-a-week commitment. Understanding those four years in Willard is basically the key to understanding why her music feels like such a massive, glittery explosion of freedom today.
The Track Star Nobody Expected
People usually assume pop stars spent their teen years practicing autographs, but Kayleigh was busy hitting the pavement. Most fans don't realize she was a legit athlete. She competed in the 5K for cross country and the 800-meter run for the Willard Tigers.
She wasn't just showing up for the participation trophy, either. In September 2012, during her freshman year, she placed 12th at the Neosho Border War with a time of 23:54.00. By her sophomore year, she chopped that down significantly, hitting a personal record of 20:06.96 at sectionals. She even ran the 4x800 relay.
But here’s the thing: she didn't love it. She later told Nardwuar in an interview that she thought she’d go to college for running, but she "not anymore"’d that dream pretty quickly. You can almost see the shift in her trajectory during those years—from the disciplined, quiet track runner to the artist who wanted to scream.
📖 Related: Most Recent Disney Animated Movies: Why Quality Is Finally Back on the Menu
That Career-Defining Talent Show
If there's one "movie moment" from the Chappell Roan high school era, it’s the 8th-grade talent show. This is where the Kayleigh-to-Chappell pipeline really started. She sat down at a piano and sang "The Christmas Song."
She won.
That win wasn't just a confidence boost; it was the catalyst. Her mom, Kara, saw the potential and encouraged her to start performing around town and at local spots in Springfield. Shortly after, at age 14 or 15, the YouTube uploads started. She was doing covers in her bedroom, looking like any other Missouri teen, but the voice was already there. It was raw, powerful, and way too big for a small-town living room.
The Double Life of Kayleigh Rose
Living in Willard meant navigating a very specific set of social rules. Her family was well-known—her mom was the local vet and her uncle, Darin Chappell, eventually became a Republican member of the Missouri House of Representatives.
- Church: Three times a week.
- Summer: Christian youth camps.
- The Conflict: Feeling "different" and "bad" for being gay in a fundamentalist environment.
She’s been very open about how she used to sneak out. She wanted to be a "good person," but the urge to escape was basically vibrating under her skin. That tension is all over her debut album. When you hear the lyrics to "Casual" or "Pink Pony Club," you're hearing the direct result of a teenager who felt like she had to hide her true self while walking the halls of a conservative Missouri high school.
Why She Graduated a Year Early
By the time she was a junior, the "normal" high school experience was already over. Atlantic Records had seen her YouTube videos—specifically her original song "Die Young"—and they wanted her. Imagine being 17, still living in Willard, and suddenly you're flying to New York and LA for meetings.
She made a choice that most kids wouldn't: she ditched her senior year. To focus on music full-time, she took online classes through Brigham Young University (BYU) to earn the remaining credits she needed.
📖 Related: One Direction Last Performance: What Really Happened on That Emotional Night
Because of this, she missed out on the classic milestones. No prom. No walking across the stage with her class. She’s called the beginning of her career "messy" because it forced her to grow up at warp speed while her peers were still worrying about SATs and Friday night football games. She traded her graduation cap for a record deal, and while it paid off, she’s admitted it felt like she missed a chunk of her childhood.
The Interlochen Turning Point
While Willard was her home, another "school" played a massive role in her development: Interlochen Center for the Arts. She attended their summer camp for songwriters as a teenager.
This was the first time she was surrounded by "art kids" instead of "track kids" or "church kids." It was at Interlochen where she wrote her first real original songs. If Willard was where she learned to survive, Interlochen was where she learned to create. It gave her the technical foundation to back up that massive natural voice.
What Most People Get Wrong About Her "Rise"
There’s this myth that Chappell Roan is an overnight success. It’s actually the opposite. After she signed that deal in high school and released her School Nights EP in 2017, things stalled. She got dropped by her label in 2020.
She actually had to move back to Missouri for a while. She worked a drive-through job in her hometown, the very place she’d tried so hard to "escape" during high school. That period of being back in the Midwest, feeling like a failure, is what eventually fueled the "Midwest Princess" persona. She realized she didn't have to choose between her Missouri roots and her queer identity—she could mash them together into something theatrical and campy.
Navigating the Legacy of Willard High
Today, Willard High School is basically a landmark for fans. You can even find marching band arrangements of "HOT TO GO!" because the local culture has finally caught up to her.
But for Kayleigh, the memories are complicated. She’s talked about the "creepy" and "invasive" side of fame, and how people from her past sometimes try to claim her success. Her relationship with her hometown is evolving, just like her relationship with religion. She’s no longer the girl running 5Ks in the Ozarks, but you can still hear the "yodel" in her voice—a technique she worked on for years—that feels distinctly Missouri.
Your Next Steps to Deepen the Lore
If you want to truly understand the world that built Chappell Roan, you should listen to her early work under the name Kayleigh Rose on YouTube. It’s a trip to see her without the wigs and the white face paint.
💡 You might also like: Stream Ramona and Beezus: Where to Watch the 2010 Classic Right Now
Also, look up the lyrics to "School Nights." It’s the title track of her first EP, and it perfectly captures that specific, lonely ache of being a teenager waiting for your real life to start. For Kayleigh, that real life started the second she stepped off the track at Willard and onto a plane to Los Angeles.
Check out the local Springfield, Missouri news archives from 2013-2015 if you want to see the original "local girl makes good" stories. It puts into perspective just how far she’s come from winning a middle school talent show with a Christmas song.