You’ve probably seen the $10 cartons at the grocery store. They’re pretty, they’ve got nice fonts, and they promise "artisan" quality. But honestly? Most of that stuff is just salty water with a hint of poultry. If you want the real deal—the kind of liquid gold that actually gels in the fridge and makes your joints feel human again—you have to do it yourself. Chicken bone broth homemade isn't just a trend; it’s basically the oldest culinary "hack" in existence. It’s the difference between a soup that tastes okay and a meal that feels like a hug for your soul.
People overcomplicate this. They think they need a degree in biochemistry or a $500 copper pot. You don't. You just need some patience, a few scraps, and the willingness to let your stove do the heavy lifting while you binge-watch a show.
The Gelatin Test and Why Most People Fail It
Let's talk about the wobble. If your broth doesn't turn into a meat-flavored Jell-O when it gets cold, you didn't make bone broth. You made stock. There’s a difference. Stock is for flavor; broth—specifically the long-simmered kind—is about extracting collagen.
According to Dr. Cate Shanahan, author of Deep Nutrition, the connective tissue in bones contains glycosaminoglycans. That’s a fancy word for stuff that helps your skin, hair, and gut lining. To get that out, you need heat and time. If you just boil a carcass for an hour, you're leaving the best parts behind.
Why does it fail to gel? Usually, it's too much water. People fill a giant pot to the brim with one chicken carcass. That’s a mistake. You want just enough water to cover the bones by about an inch. Think concentrated. Think thick.
The Foot Factor
Want a secret? Use feet.
Chicken feet are packed with collagen. I know, they look like something out of a horror movie. But if you can get past the visual, throwing three or four cleaned chicken feet into your chicken bone broth homemade batch will guarantee that gelatinous texture. If you can’t find feet, wings are the next best thing. They have a high skin-to-bone ratio, which is where the magic happens.
📖 Related: Mothering Sunday: Why Mother’s Day in the UK is Not What You Think
Stop Throwing Your Money in the Trash
We live in a world where we’re taught to toss the "trash." The onion skins? Trash. The carrot tops? Trash. The carcass from that Sunday rotisserie chicken? Trash.
Stop.
Get a gallon-sized freezer bag. Every time you cook, throw the vegetable scraps in there. The ends of the leeks, the slightly wilted celery, the parsley stems. When the bag is full, it's broth day. This isn't just being cheap; it’s being smart. The skins of onions actually add a deep, golden amber color to the broth that you can’t get from the flesh alone.
Roast or No Roast?
Some people say you have to roast the bones first. Others say it doesn't matter.
If you're using a leftover carcass from a roasted chicken, you’ve already done the work. The Maillard reaction has happened. But if you’re using raw backs or necks, roasting them at 400°F for twenty minutes adds a smoky, savory depth. It's the difference between a light, blonde broth and a rich, dark one. Both are good. The blonde one is better for risotto; the dark one is better for sipping out of a mug on a rainy Tuesday.
The Science of the Simmer
Don't boil it.
I’ll say it again: do not boil your broth.
When you boil bones aggressively, you emulsify the fats and impurities into the liquid. You’ll end up with a cloudy, greasy mess that tastes slightly bitter. You want a "smile." That’s what old-school chefs call it—when one or two bubbles pop to the surface every few seconds.
- Low and slow: 12 to 24 hours is the sweet spot.
- The Vinegar Myth: You’ll hear people say you must add apple cider vinegar to pull the minerals out of the bones. While the acid does help break down tissue, a study published in Food & Nutrition Research suggests the mineral increase is actually pretty negligible. Add it if you like the brightness, but don't think it's turning your soup into a multivitamin.
- The Scum: In the first hour, gray foam will rise to the top. Skim it off. It’s just denatured protein. It won't kill you, but it makes the broth taste "off."
Equipment: Slow Cooker vs. Instant Pot vs. Stockpot
Honestly, use what you have.
The Stockpot is the classic. It’s great because you can make huge batches. The downside? You have to keep an eye on it. You can't really go to sleep with a gas burner running.
The Slow Cooker is the hero of the "set it and forget it" crowd. You can let that thing ride for 24 hours. The temperature stays consistent, and it’s generally the safest way to get a deep extraction without worrying about your house burning down.
The Instant Pot is the controversial one. You can make broth in two hours. Does it taste good? Yes. Is it as deep and nuanced as the 24-hour version? Not quite. But if you’re in a rush, a pressure cooker is a godsend. Just make sure you do a natural pressure release. If you vent it manually, the sudden drop in pressure causes the liquid to boil violently inside, which—you guessed it—makes the broth cloudy.
Flavor Profiles That Actually Work
Don't just throw everything in the pot. If you add broccoli or cabbage, your broth will smell like sulfur. It’s gross. Stick to the classics: onion, carrot, celery.
- For an Asian twist: Add a thumb of ginger, three cloves of garlic, and a few star anise.
- For a classic French vibe: Thyme, bay leaf, and peppercorns.
- The Salt Rule: Never salt your broth at the beginning. As the liquid reduces, the salt concentrates. If you salt it at the start, you’ll end up with a brine that’s undrinkable. Salt at the very end.
Storing Your Liquid Gold
Once you've strained out the solids (which, by the way, are now tasteless mush—compost them), you need to cool the broth fast. Don't put a piping hot gallon of liquid in your fridge. You'll raise the internal temp of the fridge and spoil your milk.
Ice bath the pot in the sink.
Once it’s cool, you’ve got about five days in the fridge. If you aren't going to use it by then, freeze it. Silicone muffin molds are perfect for this. Freeze them into pucks, then toss the pucks into a freezer bag. Now you have pre-portioned 1/2 cup servings of chicken bone broth homemade whenever you need to deglaze a pan or make a quick sauce.
The Reality of "Healing" Claims
Let’s be real for a second. There is a lot of hype out there. People claim bone broth cures everything from depression to baldness. It doesn't.
👉 See also: Exactly How Many Cups Are in 15 Quarts (and Why Your Measurement Might Be Off)
What it is is an incredibly bioavailable source of amino acids like glycine and proline. Glycine is essential for the body’s production of glutathione, which is a major antioxidant. It’s also very easy on the digestive system. When you're sick, your body spends a lot of energy fighting pathogens. Digesting a heavy steak takes energy. Broth gives you the nutrients without the metabolic tax.
It’s "food as medicine" in its simplest form. Nothing more, nothing less.
Troubleshooting Common Broth Disasters
If your broth tastes like bitter water, you probably used too many herbs or let them simmer for too long. Rosemary and sage can get overpowering fast. Keep the herbs for the last hour of cooking.
If it’s greasy, you didn't trim the skin or you didn't skim the fat. Pro tip: let the broth sit in the fridge overnight. The fat will solidify into a hard white disc on top. You can just pop it off with a spoon. Don't throw that fat (schmaltz) away, though. Use it to roast potatoes. It’s incredible.
If it didn't gel, don't panic. It still tastes good. Next time, use less water or more bones. It's a learning curve. Every chicken is different. A pasture-raised bird that actually walked around will have much denser bones and more collagen than a factory-farmed bird that never moved. Quality in, quality out.
Actionable Steps for Your First Batch
Ready to stop reading and start simmering?
- Save your carcass: Next time you have chicken, put the bones in a bag in the freezer.
- Gather the aromatics: One onion (halved, skin on), two carrots, two stalks of celery.
- The Pot: Put bones and veggies in a slow cooker. Add water until just covered.
- The Wait: Turn it on low. Go to bed.
- The Finish: In the morning, strain it through a fine-mesh sieve.
- The Chill: Cool it in an ice bath, then refrigerate.
- The Use: Sip a mug of it with a pinch of sea salt and a squeeze of lemon.
You’ll realize within one sip why the boxed stuff is a waste of money. There’s a certain richness, a "mouthfeel" that you just can't manufacture in a factory. It’s the ultimate kitchen basic. Once you master the art of chicken bone broth homemade, your cooking—and maybe your gut—will never be the same.
Go find some bones. Start the pot. Your future self, the one with the clear skin and the happy stomach, will thank you.