If you mention Colin Quinn Weekend Update to a die-hard Saturday Night Live fan, you’re usually met with one of two reactions. They either groan about the "mush-mouthed" delivery and the awkwardness of the post-Norm Macdonald transition, or they light up because they realize he was basically the last of a dying breed: the blue-collar, grumpy philosopher at the desk.
Honestly, the guy had the hardest job in the history of the show.
Think about it. You aren’t just taking over a segment; you’re replacing Norm Macdonald, a man who had turned the desk into a temple of high-concept irony and "don't give a damn" energy. Norm was fired mid-season in 1998 by Don Ohlmeyer, an NBC executive who famously claimed Norm wasn't funny. It was a mess. The fans were furious, the cast was rattled, and Quinn—who was actually close friends with Norm—was the guy who had to sit in the chair just days later.
It was a total "new stepdad" situation.
The Rough Start and the "Anti-Anchor" Vibe
On January 10, 1998, Quinn took the desk for the first time. He didn't pretend it wasn't weird. He basically walked out and acknowledged that the previous guy had been "sh*t-canned" and that he was the uncomfortable fill-in. It was endearing, but it was also the start of a very polarizing two-and-a-half-year run.
Quinn wasn't trying to be a newsman.
While Chevy Chase or Seth Meyers leaned into the "polished anchor" parody, Quinn looked and sounded like a guy who just walked out of a Brooklyn bar after arguing about the Mets. His delivery was choppy. He’d stumble over the teleprompter. He’d get frustrated with the audience when a joke bombed, famously muttering, "Come on people, these are the jokes." ### Why the delivery actually worked (sorta)
- The "Bartender" Energy: He felt like a real person, not a character.
- The Intellectual Undercurrent: Despite the "mush-mouth" reputation, Quinn was—and is—one of the smartest writers in comedy. His takes on the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal weren't just puns; they were cynical, weary observations of human nature.
- The Interaction: He bartered with the crowd. If they didn't laugh, he'd make a face or mock his own writing. He knew he was struggling, and he made that struggle part of the act.
Colin Quinn Weekend Update: The Era of "The New York Times"
Before he even took the desk, Quinn had a recurring segment called "Colin Quinn Explains the New York Times." This was the blueprint. He’d take a complex, high-brow article and "translate" it for the average person with a thick dose of cynicism.
When he became the permanent anchor, he brought that "everyman" skepticism to the whole segment. It was a massive departure from the "fake news" style that came before and after him. He wasn't playing a role; he was just Colin Quinn, the guy who thinks everyone is annoying and the world is falling apart.
He held the seat until May 2000. By the time he left, the show was ready for another pivot, eventually landing on the Tina Fey and Jimmy Fallon pairing that redefined the segment for the 21st century. But Quinn’s tenure remains this fascinating, gritty bridge between the irony of the 90s and the polish of the 2000s.
The Legacy of the "Comic's Comic"
Critics at the time were often brutal. They hated the stuttering. They hated that he didn't "look" like an anchor. But if you look at his post-SNL career—the legendary Tough Crowd with Colin Quinn, his brilliant one-man shows like Long Story Short or The New York Story—you see that the Weekend Update desk was just too small for him.
📖 Related: I Always Feel Like Somebody's Watching Me: The Paranoia, The Pop Star, and The Psychology
He wasn't a sketch player. He was a monologist.
Jerry Seinfeld, Chris Rock, and Tina Fey have all cited him as a "comic’s comic." He was the guy other comedians watched to see how to actually structure a thought. On Update, that meant his jokes often had three layers of subtext that the live audience sometimes missed because they were waiting for a silly face or a catchphrase.
What We Get Wrong About the Quinn Era
Most people remember him as the guy who "wasn't Norm." That’s a mistake. Quinn didn't try to be Norm. He didn't do the long-form "Dead or Alive" bits or the O.J. Simpson obsession. He did something much more observational and, in a way, much more grounded.
He was the last anchor who truly felt like he could be your neighbor.
💡 You might also like: The Mean One 2022: Why This Weird Grinch Horror Movie Actually Worked
Today’s Update anchors are brilliant, but they are very much "performers." Quinn was a guy at a desk with a newspaper. There was a raw, unfiltered quality to his era that Saturday Night Live hasn't really seen since. He brought a "Tough Crowd" mentality to 30 Rockefeller Plaza, even if the room wasn't always ready for it.
Next Steps for SNL Historians
If you want to appreciate what Quinn was actually doing, don't just watch the clips of him stumbling over a word. Go back and watch his final few episodes in the spring of 2000. Pay attention to the writing on the "big" news stories of the day. You'll see a comedian who had finally found a way to marry his "bricklayer" persona with some of the most sophisticated political satire the show has ever produced. Then, watch his 2011 HBO special Long Story Short to see those same Update-style observations expanded into a masterclass on world history.