Stats lie. You know it, and I know it. If you just look at the raw box scores from the 2025 season, you’d think North Texas was the second coming of the 2019 LSU Tigers. They averaged 45.1 points per game, which is objectively insane. But does that make them the "best" offense in the country?
Honestly, it depends on what you value. Are we talking about the most efficient unit? The one with the highest ceiling? Or just the team that bullies bad defenses on Tuesday nights in the Sun Belt? When people argue about college football offensive rankings, they usually forget that context is everything. Scoring 50 against a middle-of-the-road G5 school isn't the same as dropping 40 on a Kirby Smart defense.
The Top Tier: Who Actually Moved the Needle in 2025?
If we’re being real, Indiana was the story of the year. Coach Curt Cignetti didn't just win; he broke the scoreboard. The Hoosiers finished second in scoring at 42.6 points per game, and they didn't do it with smoke and mirrors. They did it with Fernando Mendoza, the PFF Heisman winner, who looked like a surgeon out there.
Mendoza’s connection with Jeremiah Smith (the Ohio State transfer/phenom who basically broke the sport) was unfair. Smith is probably the best player in the country regardless of position. You've seen the highlights—the one-handed grabs, the 40-yard sprints where he makes elite corners look like they’re running in sand.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Auburn 2013 football schedule was the wildest ride in SEC history
Then you have Utah. Most people think of Utah as a "ground and pound" team. That changed. They finished 4th in total offense averaging 482.9 yards per game. They still had that physical identity, leading the way with a rushing attack that put up 266.3 yards per game, but they became balanced. It wasn't just about moving the chains anymore; it was about explosive plays.
The Real Numbers (No Fluff)
| Team | PPG | Total YPG | The "X" Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| North Texas | 45.1 | 511.0 | Drew Mestemaker (4,379 passing yards) |
| Indiana | 42.6 | 461.0 | Fernando Mendoza (72.8% completion) |
| Notre Dame | 42.0 | 458.5 | Jeremiyah Love (Elite RB production) |
| Utah | 41.3 | 482.9 | Physicality-first rushing attack |
| South Florida | 40.5 | 488.7 | Byrum Brown's dual-threat insanity |
Why "Total Yards" is a Trap
People love to cite total yardage as the gold standard for college football offensive rankings. It’s a mistake. Look at Ole Miss. They were 2nd in total offense (489.7 YPG) but 10th in scoring. Why? Because they struggled in the red zone compared to teams like Oklahoma, who led the nation with a 97.1% red zone score rate.
If you can’t punch it in when the field shrinks, all those yards are just empty calories.
Vanderbilt is another wild example. Under Diego Pavia, they became a nightmare to prepare for. They weren't just "good for Vandy." They were 8th in the country in scoring (38.5 PPG). Pavia’s ability to extend plays and find Eli Stowers (a First Team All-American TE) meant they could sustain 12-play drives that sucked the soul out of opposing defenses.
The SEC and Big Ten Power Shift
The 2025 season saw a massive shift in how the "Big Two" conferences approached offense. In the SEC, Tennessee and USC (yes, the travel schedule was brutal) stayed near the top of the passing rankings. The Vols averaged 292.8 passing yards, keeping Josh Heupel’s system relevant even as the league got more defensive.
But the Big Ten? That’s where the real evolution happened.
- Ohio State reloaded with Julian Sayin at QB.
- Oregon found a groove with Dante Moore.
- Penn State... well, Penn State was a mess.
James Franklin is gone. He’s at Virginia Tech now. Penn State entered the year with massive hype—EA Sports even gave them a 91 offensive rating—but they fell apart. They ended up in the Pinstripe Bowl. That’s the danger of preseason rankings; they don't account for the "human element" of a locker room losing its way.
What to Watch for in 2026
The coaching carousel has already turned the 2026 outlook upside down. Michigan just made the biggest splash by stealing Jason Beck from Utah to be their OC. If you liked Utah’s 2025 offense, you’re going to see a version of that in Ann Arbor, likely with Bryce Underwood at the helm.
Florida also made a massive move, grabbing Buster Faulkner from Georgia Tech. Faulkner’s unit at Tech was efficient and creative, averaging 6.98 yards per play. Putting that mind together with DJ Lagway in Gainesville? That's going to be a problem for the SEC.
Actionable Takeaways for the 2026 Season
If you're looking at offensive rankings to figure out who to bet on or who to watch next year, stop looking at "Total Yards." Instead, focus on these three things:
- Third Down Conversion Rate: Indiana led the country at 57.9%. If you can stay on the field, you eventually score.
- Returning Production at QB/OC: Oregon and Ohio State are both replacing major play-callers (Will Stein and Brian Hartline moved on). There will be growing pains.
- Red Zone Efficiency: Watch Oklahoma and Washington. They don't waste trips inside the 20.
The 2025 season proved that the gap between the "Blue Bloods" and the rest of the country is closing, thanks to the portal. When a team like North Texas can lead the nation in scoring, it means the talent is spread out. You can't just look at the logo on the helmet anymore. You have to look at the scheme and the signal-caller.
The most important thing to remember is that rankings are a snapshot, not a crystal ball. A team can be #1 in September and unranked by November if their offensive line depth gets tested. Keep an eye on the trenches in 2026; that's where these "high-flying" offenses actually win or lose.