Week 9. It’s usually when the "pretenders" finally get shown the door. If you were watching on October 25, 2025, you saw exactly that, but with a side of absolute chaos that basically nuked half of our preseason playoff brackets. This wasn't just another Saturday. It was the day the SEC hierarchy got put in a blender and the Big Ten’s "new look" officially became the "only look" that matters for the top of the polls.
Honestly, if you told me back in August that Indiana would be sitting at No. 2 in the country while LSU was firing Brian Kelly after a Week 9 blowout, I would’ve told you to go grab some water. But here we are.
The Death Valley Disaster and the A&M Statement
Texas A&M went into Baton Rouge as the last unbeaten team in the SEC, and they didn’t just win; they exerted a kind of physical dominance that felt illegal. Marcel Reed is the real deal. People kept waiting for the freshman to blink in the loudest stadium in the country, but he just kept hitting different receivers—nine of them, to be exact.
LSU looked lost. Garrett Nussmeier was under fire all night, and the Tigers' inability to run the ball finally hit a breaking point. A 49-25 final score in Death Valley isn't just a loss; it's a program-altering catastrophe. The fallout was immediate, with reports swirling about the end of the Brian Kelly era before the fans even reached their cars. For the Aggies, it was the "we’ve arrived" moment under Mike Elko that fans have been desperate for since the Jimbo Fisher days.
📖 Related: Airport Stadium 12 Photos: Why This Visual History Matters for Sports Fans
College Football Week 9 Games With Top-25 Teams: The Upset Alert Was Real
If you weren't watching the Vanderbilt-Missouri game, you missed a masterclass in "ugly" football that actually mattered. Vanderbilt is no longer a "feel-good story" or a "lucky underdog." They are a gritty, defensive-minded nightmare. They beat Missouri 17-10 in a game that felt like it was played in a phone booth.
Missouri’s playoff hopes basically evaporated in Nashville. Quarterback Beau Pribula went out with an ankle injury, and the Tigers' offense just couldn't find a rhythm against a Vandy defense that is suddenly one of the toughest units in the SEC.
Meanwhile, up in Norman, Oklahoma found out that Ole Miss doesn't care about "historical blue blood" status. The Rebels walked into a hostile environment and took a 34-26 win. It wasn't the typical Ole Miss track meet, either. They had to grind. Lane Kiffin’s squad showed they can win when the tempo slows down, which is a scary thought for whoever has to play them in November.
Why Indiana and Ohio State are Floating
The Big Ten is currently a two-horse race, and one of those horses is wearing cream and crimson. Indiana is 8-0. Read that again. They dismantled UCLA 38-13, and it wasn't even as close as the score looks. Curt Cignetti has turned a basketball school into a football machine that doesn't commit penalties and doesn't turn the ball over.
Ohio State is... well, they’re Ohio State. They shut out Wisconsin 34-0 in Madison. Julian Sayin is playing like a senior despite his youth, and the Buckeyes' defense held the Badgers to under 150 total yards. They are the unanimous No. 1 for a reason.
The Quiet Collapse of the Big 12 Middle
We have to talk about Arizona State and Texas Tech. A week ago, Arizona State was the darling of the conference after knocking off the Red Raiders. Then, they hosted Houston in Week 9 and totally laid an egg. Houston won 24-16, effectively ending the Sun Devils' dark-horse title run.
Texas Tech, on the other hand, handled their business. They blanked Oklahoma State 42-0. It’s a weird year in the Big 12 where BYU looks like a playoff lock at 8-0 after beating Iowa State 41-27, and everyone else is just fighting for a bowl spot.
Stat Leaders and Eye-Popping Numbers
Sometimes the box scores don't tell the whole story, but this week, they were shouting:
- Jeremiyah Love (Notre Dame): 228 rushing yards against USC. In the rain. That’s grown-man football.
- Haynes King (Georgia Tech): 304 passing yards and 91 rushing yards. He is single-handedly keeping the Yellow Jackets in the ACC race.
- Marcel Reed (Texas A&M): Zero turnovers in the most hostile environment in sports.
What This Means for the CFP Bracket
The first official CFP rankings are coming soon, and the landscape is much tighter than anyone expected. Alabama survived a scare against South Carolina (29-22), which keeps them in the hunt, but they have zero margin for error now.
Texas is another weird one. They needed overtime to beat Mississippi State 45-38. Arch Manning threw for over 300 yards, but he also looked human for the first time, making some freshman mistakes that almost cost them the game. If Texas plays like that against a top-10 team, they’re going to get smoked.
🔗 Read more: NY Jets vs Browns: What Really Happened in Their Wild 2025 Matchup
The Current Playoff Bubble:
- Notre Dame: Sitting at 5-2 but with a win over USC, they’re the ultimate wild card.
- BYU: Undefeated and ignored. That’s going to change very quickly.
- Vanderbilt: If they win two more, the committee has a massive headache on its hands.
Actionable Insights for the Rest of the Season
If you’re looking at these college football week 9 games with top-25 teams to figure out your betting strategy or your travel plans for November, keep these things in mind:
- Trust the Indiana Hype: Their schedule is backloaded, but they are technically sound. Don't bet against them until they hit the Ohio State game.
- Watch the Injury Reports: Missouri and Texas are dealing with banged-up QBs. In a 12-team playoff era, one bad week with a backup can end a season.
- The SEC is a Circle of Death: Aside from Texas A&M, every team in that conference looks vulnerable. Parity is at an all-time high.
- Home Field is Shrinking: We saw major road wins from Ole Miss, Texas A&M, and BYU this week. The "hostile environment" advantage isn't what it used to be.
Keep an eye on the mid-week injury updates for Arch Manning and Behren Morton. Those two names will decide the fate of the Big 12 and the SEC's playoff representation as we move into the final month of the regular season.
💡 You might also like: Super Bowl XIII: Why the 1979 Rematch Still Defines NFL Greatness
The best move right now is to look at the remaining schedules for the "unbeatens." Indiana and BYU have the clearest paths, while the SEC teams are about to cannibalize each other. Buckle up, because November is going to be a bloodbath.