The white smoke hasn't gone up yet, but the whispers are everywhere. Walk into any Italian café near the Borgo Santo Spirito right now and you’ll hear the name "Dolan" dropped between sips of espresso. It sounds crazy to some. An American? The guy from New York with the booming laugh and the penchant for hot dogs?
Honestly, the idea of a "Pope Timothy" is the ultimate "what if" of modern Catholicism.
We are living through a massive turning point for the Church. With the recent passing of Pope Francis, the College of Cardinals is essentially staring at a blank canvas, and everyone is trying to figure out if they’re going to paint a masterpiece or a mess. If you've spent any time following the Vatican, you know the unwritten rule: "He who enters the conclave a pope, leaves a cardinal." It's a warning against arrogance. But Cardinal Timothy Dolan has always been a different kind of beast in the ecclesiastical world.
Why the "American Factor" Is a Double-Edged Sword
Let’s be real for a second. The biggest hurdle for Dolan isn't his theology—it's his passport.
Historically, the Church avoids picking a pope from a global superpower. It’s a PR nightmare. If you pick an American, suddenly every papal decree looks like it was vetted by the State Department or influenced by Wall Street. The Church tries to stay "universal," and being tied to the red, white, and blue makes that hard.
But here’s the twist.
The Church in Europe is, frankly, struggling. Pews are empty. In the Global South—Africa and Asia—it's exploding, but those regions often lack the administrative "oomph" or the diplomatic reach that a New York heavyweight brings to the table. Some cardinals are looking at the books—the Vatican's finances are a disaster—and they’re thinking, "Maybe we need a manager." Dolan knows how to run a massive, complex machine. He’s done it in Milwaukee and New York for decades.
The Trump Connection and the Political Minefield
You can't talk about Dolan without talking about politics. It’s unavoidable.
Dolan has been seen as "chummy" with Donald Trump in the past, leading prayers at inaugurations and navigating the thorny world of New York's elite. For the more progressive wing of the voting cardinals—the ones Francis hand-picked—this is a massive red flag. They want a "Pope of the Poor," not a "Pope of the Pierre Hotel."
However, don't mistake his affability for a lack of edge.
I’ve watched him pivot from a joke about the Yankees to a searing defense of traditional doctrine in about four seconds flat. He’s a "happy warrior." In a Church that feels increasingly polarized and, let’s be honest, a bit depressed, that personality is infectious. Some electors might decide they’re tired of the somber, academic types. They might just want a guy who can sell the Gospel to a crowd of 50,000 without breaking a sweat.
Could Cardinal Dolan Become Pope? The Math of the Conclave
In the 2025-2026 cycle, the "papabile" (the men likely to be pope) list is crowded. You’ve got:
- Pietro Parolin: The ultimate insider.
- Luis Antonio Tagle: The "Francis of Asia."
- Péter Erdő: The brilliant conservative from Hungary.
Where does Dolan fit? He’s the "compromise."
If the conclave deadlocks between a hardline liberal and a traditionalist, they often look for a "pastoral" candidate. Someone who isn't a scary ideologue. Dolan’s theology is actually quite conservative, but his vibe is moderate. He’s the guy who can sit down with both sides and make them feel heard, even if he doesn't change his mind.
The numbers are tricky. You need a two-thirds majority. With 133 or so electors, you need a massive block of support. The American contingent is strong—10 voters—but they aren't a monolith. Men like Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago or Joseph Tobin of Newark often see the world differently than Dolan does. If he can't even get his own "home team" to vote for him as a block, the rest of the world won't follow.
The Age Factor and "The Successor"
Dolan just turned 75. In the secular world, that’s retirement age. In the Vatican, that’s "prime time."
Interestingly, Pope Leo XIV recently accepted Dolan's resignation as Archbishop of New York, a move that happens automatically when a bishop hits 75. But being "retired" from a diocese doesn't mean you're out of the running for the papacy. In fact, it might make him more attractive. He’s no longer bogged down by the day-to-day drama of New York real estate and school closings. He’s free to be a global figure.
The Verdict: Don't Bet the House, But Don't Look Away
Is it likely? No. Is it possible? Absolutely.
The "Holy Spirit" is the wildcard everyone cites, but the "theopolitics" (as the experts call it) are what really drive the bus. If the cardinals decide the Church needs a communicator who can bridge the gap between the secular West and the growing Global South—and they can get past the "Yankee" stigma—Dolan is the only one who fits the bill.
📖 Related: Pope Francis Death Time and Date: What Really Happened on Easter Monday
Basically, he’s the high-stakes gamble. He’s the candidate who could either revitalize the Church’s public image overnight or alienate half the world by appearing too "American."
If you’re following this, keep an eye on the "General Congregations"—the meetings before the conclave. That’s where the real deals are made. If Dolan starts getting asked to lead the morning reflections or if he's seen huddled with the Italian block, the odds shift.
Next Steps for You:
To get a real sense of the "Dolan style," watch his 2025 Easter Mass or his recent interviews on Fox Business. Pay attention to how he handles the "hot seat" questions—that’s exactly how he’ll have to perform in front of the College of Cardinals if he wants the job. You should also compare his public statements with those of Cardinal Tagle or Cardinal Parolin; the contrast in "energy" tells you everything you need to know about the choice the Church is currently facing.