You ever walk into a bar and feel like the walls are actually breathing? Not in a creepy, haunted house kind of way, but like there’s so much history packed into the floorboards that the building has its own pulse. That is exactly what happens when you step off the steep, San Francisco-style streets of Mt. Adams and into Crowley's Highland House Cafe.
It is 2026, and Cincinnati is full of sleek rooftops and "concept" bars where the drinks cost more than your first car. But Crowley’s? Crowley’s is still just Crowley’s.
The 1937 Vibe That Refuses to Die
Most people in Cincy just call it Crowley’s Irish Pub. If you want to get technical—which nobody there really does unless they’re on their third Guinness—the full name is Crowley's Highland House Cafe. It was founded in 1937 by a guy named William “Specs” Crowley.
📖 Related: Finding the Right Rachel Starr Hair Salon: What You Actually Need to Know
Specs was a former banker who lost his job during the Great Depression. Talk about a career pivot. He bought the place for three months' back rent and eight cents in back taxes. Eight cents. Today, you can't even get a refill on a soda for that, but back then, it was enough to start a legacy that has stayed in the same family for nearly 90 years.
Why Everyone Talks About the Guinness
Honestly, the Guinness here is a whole thing. People get really snobby about "the pour," but at Crowley’s, it’s basically a religion.
✨ Don't miss: Weak and Mildly Acidic: Why the pH Scale Is Messier Than You Think
- There is no "Bishop's Collar" (that annoying thick ring of foam).
- The temperature is always spot on.
- The bartenders, like the legendary Rob, actually take the time to do it right.
It’s not just about the beer, though. It’s about the fact that they don’t serve food. Okay, let me rephrase: they have popcorn. Sometimes they have chili cook-offs or pumpkin carving contests where food shows up, but this isn't a place where you're going for a three-course meal. It's a pub. A real one. You come here to talk, to hide from the rain, or to celebrate a Bengals win.
Did you know Zac Taylor actually gave this bar a game ball after a 2023 playoff win? That’s the kind of neighborhood clout we’re talking about. When the Bengals were the "Bungals" for decades, Crowley’s was there. When they finally started winning, the coach recognized the bars that never jumped ship.
The "Highland" Confusion
Sometimes people get this place mixed up with Highland Coffee House over by UC. Totally different vibe. While the coffee house is for late-night studying and feeling intellectual, Crowley's Highland House Cafe is where you go when you’re done with all that. It’s perched on Pavilion Street, and if you’re lucky enough to grab a spot near the window on a snowy day, you’ll see why they call it the "Highland House." You’re literally looking down at the city.
👉 See also: How to Cook a Rotisserie Chicken Without Ruining the Skin
The interior is dark wood, green paint, and enough shamrocks to make a leprechaun dizzy. There are military medals on the walls from Crowley family members and old newspaper clippings that haven't been moved since the moon landing.
What to Actually Expect
If you’re heading there this weekend, don't expect a parking lot. Mount Adams is a nightmare for parking. You’re going to be circling those narrow streets like a hawk.
- The Crowd: It’s a mix. You’ve got the old-timers who have been sitting on the same stools since 1970, and then you’ve got the younger crowd who just discovered that cheap, strong pours are better than $18 craft cocktails.
- The Dogs: It is famously pet-friendly. Don’t be surprised if a golden retriever is the most popular regular at the bar.
- The Bathroom: Look, it’s a historic building. The hot water is on the right. Usually. It’s part of the charm, or at least that’s what we tell the tourists.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
Don't just show up and act like a tourist. If you want to blend in at Crowley's Highland House Cafe, follow the unwritten rules of the hill.
- Check the Trivia: They do weekly trivia nights that get surprisingly competitive. If you aren't there to play, maybe pick a different night, because the room gets packed.
- Bring Cash: They take cards, but it’s a dive bar. Having cash for a quick round of Jamesons makes everyone’s life easier.
- Talk to the Bartender: This isn't a "stare at your phone" kind of place. The bartenders here actually know the history of the neighborhood. Ask about the "midget tossing" rumors from the 60s—it’s a weird bit of local lore that perfectly captures how wild the bar scene used to be.
- Timing Matters: If you want that "escape from the world" feeling, go on a Tuesday afternoon when the sun is hitting the stained-glass family shields. If you want a party, Saturday night is your move, but be prepared to stand.
The best way to experience Crowley's is to forget your itinerary. Walk in, grab a pint, and wait five minutes. Someone will probably start a conversation with you. In a world that feels increasingly digital and fake, Crowley’s is a rare, stubborn piece of reality.