The stock market is a weird place right now. You look at the headlines and everyone is shouting about all-time highs, but if you actually dig into the current PE of S&P 500, the numbers feel... intense.
As of mid-January 2026, the S&P 500 is trading at a trailing price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of approximately 31.37.
Yeah. You read that right.
To put that in perspective, the historical average is usually pegged somewhere between 15 and 20. We aren't just "above average" anymore; we’re basically in the stratosphere. Honestly, it’s the kind of number that makes value investors like Jeremy Grantham probably want to hide under a desk. But before you panic-sell everything in your 401(k), you've got to realize that the "P" and the "E" in this equation are telling two very different stories this year.
Why the Current Multiple Feels So High
Stocks are expensive. There is no way to sugarcoat it. When you’re paying $31 for every $1 of earnings, you’re basically betting that the future is going to be flawless.
The Shiller PE ratio, which is that cyclically adjusted metric Robert Shiller at Yale made famous, is sitting even higher—hovering around 40.92. That’s a level we’ve basically only seen during the peak of the dot-com bubble. It's a "red flag" hidden in plain sight.
🔗 Read more: Liz Wilcox Net Worth: Why the Survivor Star is Richer Than You Think
But here’s the thing.
The market isn't just a collective of irrational gamblers (though there's always a bit of that). The current valuation is being held up by a few massive pillars:
- The AI "Efficiency" Boom: Analysts like those at Goldman Sachs are projecting earnings growth of nearly 12-15% for 2026. They argue that AI isn't just hype anymore; it's actually starting to pad the bottom line for tech giants.
- The Concentration Problem: The "Magnificent Seven" (or whatever we're calling the tech titans this week) carry such a massive weight that they skew the entire index. If you strip out the top 10 stocks, the "average" stock in the S&P 500 actually looks much more reasonably priced.
- Interest Rate Expectations: Even with the Fed keeping a tight grip, there's a general sense that the "worst" of the inflation spikes are behind us.
Forward PE vs. Trailing PE
If you want to feel better about your portfolio, look at the forward PE ratio.
Right now, the forward 12-month PE is sitting closer to 22.3. Why the gap? Because Wall Street is optimistic. They’re banking on the S&P 500 hitting an aggregate Earnings Per Share (EPS) of about $305 to $310 by the end of 2026.
If those earnings actually show up, a PE of 22 feels high but manageable. If they don't? Well, then the "Price" part of the ratio has to drop to make the math work again. That’s where the risk lives.
Historical Context: Where do we stand?
Looking back at the last few decades gives us some much-needed perspective.
- The Dot-Com Peak: Multiples soared over 40. We know how that ended.
- The Financial Crisis: Multiples actually looked "low" right before the crash because earnings were about to vanish.
- The 2021 "Everything Bubble": We saw a similar spike to what we're seeing now, followed by a rough 2022.
Current valuations are higher than the 5-year average (20.0) and the 10-year average (18.7). We are officially in "expensive" territory.
The Yield Gap: Stocks vs. Bonds
One thing people often forget to check is the earnings yield.
Basically, the earnings yield is just the PE ratio flipped upside down. At a PE of 31, your "yield" is only about 3.2%. When 10-year Treasuries are yielding significantly more than that, you have to ask yourself: why take the risk of stocks?
This is the "Equity Risk Premium." Usually, you want to be paid a premium for the stress of owning stocks. Right now, that premium is thin. Paper-thin.
Actionable Steps for Your Portfolio
So, what do you actually do with this information?
📖 Related: Number for Unemployment in Alabama: What Most People Get Wrong
First, don't time the market. High PE ratios can stay high for years. If you exited the market in 2024 because the PE hit 25, you missed a massive rally.
Second, look at the Equal-Weight S&P 500 (RSP). This version of the index gives every company the same weight. It often has a much lower PE than the standard market-cap-weighted index. It’s a great way to see if the "rest" of the market is actually on sale.
Third, rebalance. If your tech stocks have grown so much that they now make up 80% of your account, it’s probably time to trim them and put that money into boring stuff—think Healthcare or Consumer Staples—that isn't trading at 50x earnings.
Finally, keep an eye on quarterly earnings reports. The current PE of S&P 500 is a house of cards that relies entirely on companies meeting their growth targets. If we see a string of misses in the coming months, expect the market to "re-rate" very quickly.
💡 You might also like: Office sex with the boss: Why the fallout is rarely worth the thrill
Focus on the earnings. If the "E" keeps growing, the "P" can stay high. If the "E" stalls, keep your eyes on the exit.