If you’ve ever stood on the Needles Highway and looked out over the Black Hills, you know that feeling of total, rugged stillness. It’s quiet. But honestly, that silence is a bit of a lie. The landscape of Custer State Park is constantly moving, shifting, and—more often than we’d like—burning.
Fire is a weird thing in South Dakota. We hate it because it threatens the buffalo herds and the historic lodges, but the forest actually craves it. Without the occasional Custer State Park fire, the ponderosa pines get too crowded. They choke each other out. Then, when a spark finally hits, the whole place goes up like a matchbox because there’s too much fuel.
It’s a cycle. A scary, expensive, necessary cycle.
The Legion Lake Fire: A Massive Wake-up Call
Most people who visit the park today see the rolling hills and the "Begging Burros" and don't realize how close this place came to looking like a moonscape back in December 2017. The Legion Lake Fire wasn't just a little brush fire. It was a monster.
It started because of a downed power line near Legion Lake. High winds—we're talking 50 to 60 mph gusts—ripped through the canyons and pushed the flames faster than anyone could keep up with. Within days, it had scorched over 54,000 acres. That’s more than half the park. Think about that for a second. Half of one of the most beautiful places in the country, just... gone in a week.
I remember talking to locals who were terrified for the State Game Lodge. That building has hosted presidents like Coolidge and Eisenhower. It’s a piece of American history. Firefighters had to literally wrap parts of the park’s infrastructure in foil-like protective blankets. It worked, mostly. But the scar tissue on the land is still there if you know where to look.
The fire jumped Highway 16A. It jumped Wildlife Loop Road. It even pushed outside the park boundaries into private land and towards the town of Fairburn. It was the third-largest wildfire in the recorded history of the Black Hills, and it changed how the South Dakota Department of Game, Fish and Parks (GFP) handles forest management.
💡 You might also like: Wyndham Garden Austin: Why Travelers Keep Booking This South IH-35 Landmark
Why the Black Hills Are a Powder Keg
You’ve got to understand the biology here. Ponderosa pines are the kings of the park. They have this thick, corky bark that is actually designed to survive low-intensity ground fires. In a perfect world, a fire would just creep along the grass, clear out the dead needles and baby trees, and leave the big ones standing.
But we’ve spent a hundred years stopping every single fire the second it starts.
What happens then? The forest gets "thick." Instead of 40 trees per acre, you have 400. This creates what experts call "ladder fuels." A fire starts in the grass, climbs the low branches, and hits the canopy. Once a fire becomes a "crown fire," it’s basically game over until the weather changes.
The 1988 Galena Fire was another big one. It burned about 16,000 acres. Then you had the Mt. Coolidge Fire. It feels like every decade, the park tries to reset itself. The 2017 event was just the most aggressive version of that "reset" button we've seen in modern times.
The Buffalo and the Burn
Everyone asks about the bison. "What happens to the herd during a Custer State Park fire?"
It’s actually incredible to watch. Bison aren’t stupid. They’ve lived with fire for thousands of years. During the Legion Lake Fire, the herd of about 1,300 animals mostly moved toward the large, open grasslands in the southern part of the park. They found the "black"—areas that had already burned—and just stood there. Fire can't burn the same spot twice.
The real magic happens the year after a fire.
Fire releases nitrogen back into the soil. The ash acts like a super-charged fertilizer. By the following spring, the burned areas in Custer State Park were covered in the most vibrant, nutrient-dense green grass you’ve ever seen. The bison loved it. They actually prefer grazing in recent burn scars because the forage is better for them.
So, while the charred trees look ugly to us, to a bison, a fire is basically a dinner bell for a better buffet next season.
How the Park Manages the Threat Now
They don't just wait for lightning anymore. Or downed power lines.
Prescribed burns are the main tool now. If you visit in the "shoulder seasons"—usually late fall or early spring—you might see smoke. Don't panic. It's likely a controlled burn. The park staff works with the South Dakota Wildland Fire division to intentionally set small, cool fires.
They target specific areas:
- Around the Blue Bell Lodge and other structures.
- Near the park entrances to create fuel breaks.
- In the backcountry to thin out the "dog-hair" pine thickets.
It’s a delicate dance. You need the right humidity. You need the right wind direction (nobody wants to smoke out the tourists in Rapid City). If it's too dry, it’s too dangerous. If it’s too wet, the wood won't take a flame.
🔗 Read more: Why Monte Rei Golf & Country Club Portugal is Still the King of the Algarve
There's also the pine beetle issue. A few years back, these tiny beetles killed millions of trees across the Black Hills. Dead trees are just standing fuel. The park has been aggressive about logging and thinning these dead stands to make sure the next Custer State Park fire doesn't have an easy path to the treetops.
What You’ll See on the Ground Today
If you’re driving the Wildlife Loop today, look at the ridges. You’ll see "ghost forests"—stands of silver, barkless trees standing like skeletons. Those are the leftovers from 2017.
But look down.
You’ll see wild rosebushes, chokecherries, and young aspens. These species love sunlight. When the thick pine canopy burned away, it finally let the sun hit the forest floor for the first time in 80 years. This has actually improved the habitat for elk and deer. They need that brushy cover and the berries that grow there.
It’s a different kind of beauty. It’s not the pristine, postcard forest people expect, but it’s more "alive" in a biological sense.
Practical Tips for Your Visit
Fire season in the Black Hills usually peaks in July and August, but as we saw with the Legion Lake Fire in December, it can happen anytime there's no snow on the ground.
If you're planning a trip, keep these things in mind:
- Check the Fire Danger Rating: There are signs at every park entrance. If it says "Extreme," they mean it. Don't even think about a campfire.
- Respect the Closures: If a trail is closed due to fire activity or "mop-up" operations, stay off it. Burned roots can create "ash pits"—underground pockets of hot coals that can swallow a leg.
- Drones are a No-Go: If there is an active fire, flying a drone can ground firefighting aircraft. It’s a massive fine and incredibly dangerous.
- Watch for Falling Trees: In older burn areas, "snags" (dead standing trees) fall over constantly, especially when it’s windy. Don't camp or park right under a stand of charred pines.
The reality of Custer State Park is that fire is part of its DNA. You can't have the park without the flames. We just have to get better at living with them.
Next time you see a charred stump or a blackened hillside, don't just see a disaster. See a forest that’s catching its breath. See a park that is regenerating.
Actionable Steps for Travelers
Before you head out to Custer, do a quick check on the South Dakota Great Lakes region fire reports. If you see active smoke, check the South Dakota Wildland Fire dashboard. It’ll tell you exactly where the activity is so you can pivot your hiking plans to the northern or southern ends of the park accordingly.
Also, if you're staying in the park, make sure you have the "SD GFP" app downloaded. It's the fastest way to get emergency alerts if a fast-moving fire starts while you're out on the trails. Stick to the paved roads if visibility drops, and always give the fire crews plenty of space to move their heavy tankers—they have a tough enough job as it is.