If you’ve spent any time on TikTok or X lately, you know Dave Portnoy’s love life is basically a spectator sport. It’s a whole thing. One day he’s reviewing a pepperoni slice in a random parking lot, and the next, the internet is melting down because a girl was spotted sitting behind him at a Celtics game. People want to know the deal. Honestly, keeping up with the "El Pres" dating timeline is a full-time job at this point.
So, let's just get to it. Dave Portnoy's girlfriend is Camryn D’Aloia. For a guy who literally built an empire out of being loud and public, he’s been surprisingly low-key about this one. Or at least, as low-key as you can be when you’re Dave Portnoy. They didn't have some big, flashy "Instagram Official" moment with a professional photoshoot. Instead, the confirmation came out in a classic, rambling Dave story about nearly dying at sea. You can't make this stuff up.
The Nantucket Boat Mishap That Changed Everything
Basically, the relationship was "confirmed" because of a dead boat battery. In the summer of 2024, Dave was out off the coast of Nantucket when his boat lost power. He was drifting. He was panicking. He’s admitted he was basically useless in the situation.
Enter "Cam."
During an episode of the Drop A Pin podcast in April 2025, Portnoy finally let the cat out of the bag. He recounted how he told "Cam, a girl I'm dating," that she had to jump off the boat and swim to shore to get help before they drifted too far out. She actually did it. She dove into the water, swam to land, and called the harbor master.
If that isn't a "ride or die" introduction, I don't know what is. Dave joked that while he was losing his mind, she was the one taking action. It was a rare moment where he didn't just refer to a "rumored" flame but explicitly used the word girlfriend—well, "girl I’m dating," which in Portnoy-speak is as close to a formal announcement as we usually get.
Who Exactly is Camryn D’Aloia?
Camryn isn’t some mega-famous influencer with ten million followers, which is probably why people are so curious. She’s kind of a mystery.
- Age Gap: There’s no point in ignoring it because everyone talks about it. Camryn is 26. Dave is 48. That 22-year gap has definitely kept the comment sections busy.
- The Massachusetts Connection: She’s a local girl, which fits Dave’s whole New England brand. She graduated from Framingham State University in 2021.
- Day Job: According to her LinkedIn (before she likely realized she needed to tighten up her privacy settings), she worked as a community management associate for Nutrafol.
- Private Life: Unlike some of Dave’s exes, she keeps her Instagram private. She’s not out here chasing the "Barstool Girl" spotlight, which seems to be a change of pace for Portnoy.
The two were first spotted together way back in April 2024. They were at a Celtics vs. Heat game—sitting courtside, obviously. The TV cameras caught them chatting, and TikTok detectives immediately went to work. Dave actually called that moment "unfortunate" at the time on the BFFs podcast because he was only a few months out of his breakup with Silvana Mojica and wasn't ready for the "new girlfriend" headlines yet.
Why This Isn't Just Another Silvana Situation
If you followed the Silvana Mojica era, you know it was intense. They were together for three years. They were everywhere. When they broke up in late 2023, it was messy. Silvana posted videos of herself crying; Dave went on BFFs to explain that he just couldn't give her what she deserved (meaning marriage and kids).
He’s been very open about the fact that he’s "old as sh**" and doesn't want to "steal the youth" of the women he dates. He knows he's in a different stage of life.
With Camryn, things feel... quieter? They’ve been seen at Patriots games sitting with Robert Kraft and at Indiana Fever games to watch Caitlin Clark. She’s there, but she’s not the main character of his social media feed. It feels more like a real-life relationship and less like a content collaboration.
The Reality of Being Dave Portnoy's Girlfriend
It isn't all courtside seats and Nantucket sunsets. Being with Dave means dealing with a very specific kind of fame.
First, there’s the "First Lady" ghost. Long-time Stoolies still hold a candle for Dave’s ex-wife, Renee Satterthwaite. They separated in 2017 but—fun fact—they are still technically married. A judge actually denied their divorce petition in 2023 because the settlement wasn't "equitable" enough for Renee, despite her not even wanting more money. Dave still speaks incredibly highly of her, which can't be the easiest thing for a new girlfriend to navigate.
Then there’s the dog. Miss Peaches. Let’s be real: the most important woman in Dave Portnoy’s life is a rescue pit bull. Camryn has been seen in the background of videos featuring the dog, and if you want to win Dave's heart, you clearly have to win over the hound.
💡 You might also like: Blue ivy name meaning: The real reason Beyoncé and Jay-Z chose it
What Most People Get Wrong About the Pair
People love to jump to conclusions. They see a 48-year-old millionaire with a 26-year-old and assume they know exactly what the dynamic is. But if you look at the timeline, they’ve been together—or at least "hanging out"—for nearly two years now. In the world of celebrity flings, that's practically a lifetime.
Is he going to marry her? Probably not. Dave has been pretty cynical about the institution of marriage lately. He’s told his audience repeatedly that he likes his life exactly how it is. He has his pizza, his gambling, his dog, and a girlfriend who is willing to jump off a boat to save him.
Honestly, it seems like Camryn is content with that. She isn't launching a podcast. She isn't selling a lifestyle brand off the back of his fame. She’s just... dating the guy.
The E-E-A-T Perspective: Is This Permanent?
Experts in celebrity branding often point out that Portnoy’s "relatability" is his biggest asset. Dating someone who keeps a low profile actually helps his brand more than dating a fellow high-profile influencer. It keeps the focus on him and Barstool.
However, we have to acknowledge the limitations of what we know. Because Camryn is so private, we only see what Dave allows us to see through the Barstool lens. There are no "insider sources" from her camp leaking stories to Page Six. It’s a closed loop.
What we do know is that she’s been a staple at his side through some of the biggest Barstool moments of the last year, including the massive growth of the "Miss Peaches" brand and the constant chaos of the Unnamed Show.
What to Look Out For Next
If you’re trying to track the status of Dave and Camryn, stop looking at his Instagram and start looking at the background of Barstool’s sports coverage.
- Courtside Sightings: The Celtics are their "thing." If Dave is at a home game and she’s not there, that’s when the rumors will actually have some legs.
- The "Miss Peaches" Factor: Keep an eye on the rescue dog's TikTok. If Camryn starts appearing more frequently in the "family" content, it means she’s truly part of the inner circle.
- The 2026 Book Tour: Dave is set to release his book, Cancel Me if You Can, in June 2026. If Camryn is by his side during the press run, you can bet the relationship is as serious as it gets.
Basically, if you want to know if they're still together, just check if there's a blonde girl in a vintage Patriots hat sitting next to a guy eating a slice of cheese pizza. If there is, it’s probably Camryn.
✨ Don't miss: Emma Stone Boyfriend: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Relationship History
To stay updated on the latest shifts in the Barstool world, you should keep an eye on the BFFs podcast clips, as that's usually where Dave lets his guard down about his personal life when Brianna Chickenfry or Josh Richards press him on it.