Developing the Leader Within You: Why Most People Get John Maxwell’s Advice Wrong

Developing the Leader Within You: Why Most People Get John Maxwell’s Advice Wrong

Leadership isn't about the corner office. Honestly, it’s not even about the fancy title or the parking spot with your name on it. If you’ve ever sat through a meeting where the "boss" barked orders and everyone rolled their eyes the second they left the room, you’ve seen the gap between authority and actual leadership. This is exactly what John Maxwell hit on decades ago, and it’s why Developing the Leader Within You remains a staple on desks from Fortune 500 CEOs to small-town nonprofit directors.

Maxwell’s core argument is pretty simple, yet it trips people up constantly. He says leadership is influence. That’s it. Nothing more, nothing less.

If you think you're leading but nobody is following, you're just taking a walk. It sounds harsh, but it’s the reality of the business world in 2026. You can’t force people to buy into a vision anymore; you have to earn the right to lead them.

The Influence Trap and the 5 Levels

Most people start at Level 1: Position. This is the entry-level of leadership where people follow you because they have to. They need the paycheck. They don't want to get fired. But if you stay here, you're basically a glorified babysitter. Maxwell pushes for a climb up what he calls the 5 Levels of Leadership, and it’s a journey that most people quit halfway through.

  1. Position (Rights): People follow because they have to.
  2. Permission (Relationships): People follow because they want to. You’ve actually grabbed a coffee with them and listened to their problems.
  3. Production (Results): People follow because of what you’ve done for the organization. You’ve got "runs on the board."
  4. People Development (Reproduction): People follow because of what you’ve done for them. You made them better.
  5. Pinnacle (Respect): People follow because of who you are and what you represent. This is the "legacy" phase.

Most "successful" managers get stuck at Level 3. They hit their KPIs, the revenue is up, and they think they've arrived. But level 3 leaders are often exhausted because they’re carrying the whole team on their backs. To hit Level 4, you have to stop doing the work yourself and start obsessing over how to make other people as good as you are. It’s a massive ego shift that many aren't willing to make.

✨ Don't miss: USD to LBP Exchange Rate: Why the Stability is Deceiving

Prioritizing Like a Real Leader

We’ve all heard of the 80/20 principle, or the Pareto Principle. In Developing the Leader Within You, Maxwell applies this to leadership in a way that’s kinda brutal for the perfectionists out there. He argues that 20% of your priorities will give you 80% of your production.

If you have a list of ten things to do, two of them matter more than the other eight combined.

The problem? Most of us spend our day "clearing the deck" with the easy, low-value tasks so we can feel productive. A real leader ignores the small stuff to focus on the high-impact stuff. This usually means saying "no" to good opportunities so you can say "yes" to the best ones.

The PLAN AHEAD Method

When it comes to making changes—something every leader has to do—Maxwell suggests a framework he calls PLAN AHEAD. It’s not just corporate jargon; it’s a roadmap for not blowing up your team’s morale:

  • Predetermine the change.
  • Lay out steps.
  • Adjust priorities.
  • Notify your team.
  • Allow time for acceptance.
  • Head into action.
  • Expect problems.
  • Always point to successes.
  • Daily review of progress.

Most leaders skip the "Notify" and "Allow time for acceptance" parts. They just jump straight to "Head into action" and then wonder why the team is frustrated. You’ve gotta give people the "why" before the "what."

👉 See also: How many nickels in a cent: Why the Math Doesn't Actually Work

The Integrity Gap

Integrity is a word that gets thrown around so much it’s almost lost its meaning. But in the 2.0 version of the book, Maxwell doubles down on it. He says integrity isn't just about not lying; it's about your words matching your actions.

If you tell your team to work hard but you’re golfing every Friday afternoon, you’ve lost the "Permission" level of leadership. You’re back at Level 1.

Trust is like change in your pocket. Every time you do what you say you’ll do, you add a few coins. Every time you flake or take credit for someone else's work, you spend it. Eventually, if you keep spending, you go bankrupt. Once a leader is bankrupt on trust, no amount of "vision casting" or "strategic planning" is going to save the culture.

👉 See also: 12400 Wilshire Boulevard: Why This West LA Address Is More Than Just Another Office Tower

Solving Problems vs. Avoiding Them

A weird thing happens when people get into leadership: they start resenting problems. They feel like a "good" leader shouldn't have so many fires to put out. Maxwell flips this. He says the quickest way to gain leadership is by solving problems.

Problems are basically an invitation to lead.

If everything was running perfectly, they wouldn't need you. The best leaders don't just fix the immediate issue; they look for the "problem under the problem." They fix the system so the fire doesn't start again next week. It’s the difference between being a firefighter and being an architect.

How to Actually Apply This Today

Reading a book is easy. Changing your behavior is the hard part. If you want to actually start developing the leader within you, you can't just highlight sentences in a paperback. You have to move.

Start by identifying your "Top 20%" people. Maxwell suggests spending 80% of your time with the top 20% of your producers. It sounds counterintuitive—shouldn’t you help the struggling people? Sorta. But if you spend all your time trying to fix the bottom performers, you’re ignoring the people who are actually driving the mission. Invest in your best, and they’ll help you lift the rest.

Actionable Next Steps:

  • Audit your calendar: Look at last week. What percentage of your time was spent on "Level 3" production versus "Level 4" people development? If the answer is 0% on development, you’re a manager, not a leader yet.
  • The "One-on-One" Shift: In your next one-on-one meeting, don't ask about the status of a project. Ask, "What’s the biggest hurdle in your way right now, and how can I help you clear it?"
  • Identify your Level: Pick three people you lead. Ask yourself what level you are with each of them. You might be a Level 3 with one person because you’ve worked together for years, but a Level 1 with the new hire. You have to earn your way up with every single individual.

Leadership is a choice. It’s a daily grind of choosing service over ego and discipline over convenience. Maxwell’s framework isn't a magic wand, but it’s a pretty solid compass for anyone tired of just "taking a walk" and ready to actually start leading.