Did Larry Caputo Remarry? What Really Happened After the Long Island Medium Split

Did Larry Caputo Remarry? What Really Happened After the Long Island Medium Split

Life moves fast. One minute you’re a staple on one of the biggest reality shows in America, and the next, you’re living a totally different life on the opposite coast. That’s the reality for Larry Caputo. For years, we watched him as the supportive, often hilarious husband of Theresa Caputo on Long Island Medium. They were the rock of the show. 28 years is a long time. People don't just forget a couple like that overnight.

Naturally, when the divorce was finalized in 2018, the rumor mill went into overdrive. Everyone wanted to know: did Larry Caputo remarry?

Honestly, it’s a question that pops up every time a fan catches a rerun of the old show. You see them on screen, look at their chemistry, and wonder how it all fell apart. But more than that, people want to know if he found that "happily ever after" again.

The Breakup That Shocked Fans

The split wasn't some sudden, explosive scandal. It was slow. It was painful. Theresa and Larry announced their separation in December 2017, and honestly, you could see the cracks in the final seasons of the show. Larry moved to Santa Monica, California, while Theresa stayed in New York.

Distance doesn't always make the heart grow fonder. Sometimes, it just makes the distance permanent.

By the time 2018 rolled around, the divorce was official. Larry was 61 at the time, facing a brand-new world. He told TMZ back then that he had "moved on" and met "someone special." That one sentence launched a thousand tabloid articles.

The Connie Stauddy Era

For a while, it looked like Larry might be headed back to the altar. He was linked to a woman named Connie Stauddy from Alabama. They reportedly met because she reached out for a reading from Theresa—talk about a strange way to meet your future boyfriend's ex-wife.

Larry didn't hide it. He posted a photo of a blonde woman on Instagram with the caption "Love my baby boo!"

People went nuts. The comments were a mess. Some fans were happy for him, while others—the ones who couldn't let go of the "Theresa and Larry" dream—were pretty harsh. They pointed out she looked a bit like Theresa. They told him he should go back to his wife. Larry, never one to take things lying down, actually clapped back at some of those comments.

But then? Silence.

The "baby boo" posts disappeared. The photos were deleted.

Did Larry Caputo Remarry? The Current Reality

Let's get to the point. As of 2026, Larry Caputo has not remarried. There has been no wedding. No secret ceremony in Lake Como (though his son, Larry Jr., did have a gorgeous wedding there in 2023). Larry has remained legally single since his divorce from Theresa was finalized.

While he has certainly dated, he hasn't taken that leap back into matrimony. He seems to have traded the high-stress life of a reality TV star for a much quieter existence. If you follow him on social media these days, you’re more likely to see him at the gym, riding his Harley-Davidson, or promoting his wine brand, Lorenzo Caputo.

He's living the California dream.

It’s actually interesting to see the contrast between Larry and Theresa’s post-divorce lives. Theresa has been very public about having a long-term boyfriend, though she keeps his face off camera. Larry, on the other hand, went from being semi-public about his dating life to being almost entirely private.

Maybe the "baby boo" backlash taught him a lesson about keeping his private life, well, private.

Why the Rumors Won't Die

Why do people keep asking if he remarried? It’s mostly because of the confusion between Larry Sr. and Larry Jr.

📖 Related: Inside Jay Z House: The $200 Million Malibu Fortress and the Bel-Air Estate Defined by Excess

In June 2023, Larry Jr. married his longtime girlfriend, Leah Munch. It was a massive event. People magazine covered it. Theresa was there, looking ecstatic. Because "Larry Caputo" was in all the wedding headlines, a lot of casual fans thought it was the father getting hitched.

It wasn't.

Larry Sr. was there, of course. He’s still very much a part of his children’s lives. But he was there as the father of the groom, not the groom himself.

What is Larry Doing Now?

He’s 69 now.

He looks good. Really good. He’s clearly spent the last few years hitting the weights and focusing on his health. He’s also lean into his Italian roots with his wine business. It’s a far cry from the days of sitting on a couch in Long Island while his wife talked to spirits in the kitchen.

There's a certain peace in his updates lately. He seems settled. He isn't chasing the cameras anymore.

Does he regret the divorce? He’s never said that. In fact, he’s spoken about how the lack of communication and time together just wore them down. It happens. Even after three decades.

Insights for Fans

If you're looking for a definitive answer, here it is: Larry Caputo is single (or at least unmarried) and living a low-key life in California.

If you want to keep up with what he's actually doing, don't look at the tabloid headers. Look at his own updates. He’s focused on:

  • Fitness: The man is in better shape than most guys half his age.
  • Family: He’s a proud dad to Victoria and Larry Jr. and a grandfather to Victoria's daughter, Michelina.
  • Business: Growing his wine label and enjoying the West Coast lifestyle.

Larry’s story is a reminder that there is absolutely life after a long-term marriage ends. It doesn't have to mean jumping into another marriage right away. Sometimes, it just means finding out who you are when the cameras aren't rolling and your partner isn't the center of the room.

To stay truly updated on the Caputo family, your best bet is to follow the kids on social media. They are the bridge between Larry and Theresa’s worlds now, and they often share the most authentic glimpses of where Larry Sr. is at in his journey.