You’re sitting there with the third overall pick. Christian McCaffrey is gone. Tyreek Hill is gone. Suddenly, CeeDee Lamb is staring you in the face, and your brain does that weird glitch where you remember he’s holding out or dealing with a hamstring tweak you read about on a shady beat writer's Twitter feed at 2:00 AM. You panic. You take a safe floor player who caps your ceiling, and just like that, you’ve basically handed the league trophy to the guy in your office who drinks too much cold brew.
Building do not draft lists isn't about being a hater. It’s about risk mitigation in a game that is essentially gambling disguised as "statistical analysis." If you aren't walking into your draft room with a list of guys you refuse to touch at their current Average Draft Position (ADP), you aren't playing to win. You're playing not to lose. There's a massive difference.
The Psychology of the Do Not Draft List
Why do we even do this? Honestly, it's because the human brain is terrible at evaluating "sunk cost." When you spend a second-round pick on a veteran running back whose yards per carry have dropped three years in a row, you feel obligated to start him. You start him in Week 1. He gives you 4.2 points. You start him in Week 2 because "he’s due." By Week 6, your season is a dumpster fire.
A well-constructed do not draft list acts like a physical barrier against your own stupidity. It’s a pre-commitment strategy. You’re telling your future, panicked self: "No, we are not taking Kyle Pitts in the fourth round again. I don't care how fast he ran his 40-yard dash three years ago."
Experts like Matthew Berry or the guys over at FantasyPros often talk about "fading" players. Fading is polite. A do not draft list is a manifesto. It acknowledges that at a certain price point, a player's path to failure is significantly wider than their path to success. You have to be okay with being wrong, too. If that guy goes off for someone else, let it happen. You’re playing the percentages.
Injury Red Flags and the Age Cliff
Let’s talk about the "Age Cliff." It’s real. It’s brutal. It’s undefeated.
In the NFL, the drop-off for running backs usually starts at age 26, and by 28, the wheels aren't just wobbling—they’re falling off in the middle of the highway. When you see a 29-year-old back with over 1,500 career carries being drafted as a top-12 option, that name needs to be on your do not draft list immediately. Think about Dalvin Cook’s 2023 season. The signs were there: declining efficiency, shoulder issues, and a massive workload history. People who ignored the red flags spent a high draft pick on a guy who ended up being a healthy scratch.
Soft tissue injuries are the silent killers of fantasy seasons. Hamstrings. Calves. Groins. If a wide receiver spends all of August "working on the side" with trainers, his name belongs on the list. These injuries linger. They turn into "decoy" games where your star player sits on the field but never gets a target because he can’t cut at full speed.
Real Talk on Quarterback Value
You see people reaching for elite quarterbacks in the second round. Josh Allen is great. Patrick Mahomes is a legend. But taking them that early is often a fast track to a mediocre roster. The opportunity cost is too high. If you take a QB in the second, you’re passing on a 1,200-yard receiver or a bell-cow back.
The "Late Round QB" strategy has evolved, but the core principle remains: the gap between the QB3 and the QB10 is often smaller than the gap between the RB5 and the RB25. Unless you’re in a Superflex league, most "top tier" QBs should actually be on your personal do not draft lists at their current market price. You're better off hunting for the next breakout—the guy with rushing upside who is going in round 9 or 10.
Coaching Changes and Scheme Fits
Schemes matter way more than people think. You can have the most talented player in the world, but if he’s in a "run-heavy" offense that uses three different tight ends, his fantasy ceiling is nonexistent.
Take a look at coaching hires. When a defensive-minded head coach takes over a team with a high-flying offense, expect a slower pace. Expect more punting. Expect your wide receiver's targets to drop from 10 a game to 6. If the market hasn't adjusted the player's ADP to account for a new, boring offensive coordinator, that's a prime candidate for your do not draft list.
👉 See also: Arsenal vs Man United: Why This Fixture Still Makes the World Stop
Specific examples often involve players moving teams in free agency. It looks shiny on paper. "Oh, he’s the WR1 there now!" Maybe. Or maybe he’s a specialized talent who succeeded because he had a Hall of Fame QB throwing to him, and now he’s catching passes from a rookie behind a Swiss-cheese offensive line. Kenny Golladay’s move to the Giants is the gold standard for this. He went from a high-point specialist in Detroit to a literal zero in New York. If you had him on your list, you saved your season.
How to Build Your Own List Without Being a Victim of Groupthink
Don't just copy a list from a website. That's lazy. And honestly, it doesn't help you understand why you’re avoiding someone.
Start with the "dead zone" running backs. These are guys usually drafted in rounds 3 through 6. They aren't elite, but they have decent roles. History shows these players fail at a much higher rate than wide receivers in the same range. If a running back in the dead zone doesn't catch passes and plays for a bad team, he’s an auto-include for the do not draft list.
Next, look at vacated targets. If a team loses its star receiver, everyone assumes the remaining guys will just soak up that production. Sometimes they do. More often, the offense just gets worse. Don't draft the "default" WR1 on a bad team just because someone has to catch the ball. Sometimes, nobody catches the ball.
The Variance of "Touchdown Dependency"
Jamaal Williams in 2022 is a perfect case study. He had 17 touchdowns. Seventeen! Everyone knew he wouldn’t do that again. Yet, his ADP in 2023 stayed high because people chase last year's stats. If a player’s entire fantasy value relies on him falling into the end zone twice a game, and he doesn't get the yardage to back it up, he’s a massive trap. Put him on the list. Regression is a monster, and it's coming for those touchdowns.
Actionable Steps for Draft Day
First, identify five players in the first four rounds whose ADP feels "wrong" based on the factors we've discussed—age, injury history, or coaching changes. Write them down. Put them in bold.
When your draft starts, do not deviate. If the draft room is "letting a player fall" to you, ask yourself why. Usually, the room is right. If a guy you have on your do not draft list is still there two rounds past his ADP, it can be tempting to "take the value." Don't do it. A bad player at a "good value" is still a bad player taking up a roster spot on your bench.
Instead of chasing those names, focus on high-upside rookies or players in high-scoring offenses who have a clear path to increased volume. Fantasy football is won by identifying the players who will be better this year than they were last year, not by drafting the guys who were great two seasons ago and are now hanging on by a thread.
Review your list one last time before the clock starts. Be firm. Be ruthless. If you’ve decided that Saquon Barkley’s injury history or a specific quarterback’s lack of rushing yards makes them a "no-go," stick to it. The most successful fantasy players aren't the ones who make the "best" picks; they're the ones who avoid the landmines that blow up everyone else's season by Week 4.
Stop drafting based on name recognition. Start drafting based on projected opportunity and health. Your 2026 trophy depends on the names you don't call out on draft night.