It is the question that starts a thousand internet arguments. You see it on Reddit, in political debates, and definitely in the comments section of any travel vlog featuring San Juan. Do Puerto Ricans pay US taxes? Most people want a simple yes or no. The truth? It is a messy, "it depends" kind of situation that involves a hundred years of legal gymnastics.
Puerto Rico is a territory, not a state. Because of that weird middle-ground status, the tax rules are different from what you’d find in Florida or Ohio. People often assume residents of the island are getting a totally free ride from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). They aren't. Not even close. But they also don't pay exactly what someone in New York pays.
Let's get into the weeds.
📖 Related: How to File an Extension for Your Taxes: What Most People Get Wrong
The Reality of Federal Income Tax on the Island
Basically, if you live in Puerto Rico full-time, you usually don't have to pay federal income tax on money you earn inside Puerto Rico. This comes from Section 933 of the Internal Revenue Code. It’s a huge carve-out. If you own a bakery in Ponce and all your customers are local, the IRS generally doesn't see a dime of that profit.
But wait.
If that same bakery owner has a side hustle selling items on Etsy to people in Chicago, or if they own stocks in a US company that pay dividends, that money is "US-source income." The IRS wants its cut of that. So, many people on the island end up filing two different tax returns: one for the Puerto Rico Department of the Treasury (known as Hacienda) and one for the IRS.
It gets even more granular. Federal employees working on the island—think TSA agents, FBI officers, or postal workers—pay full federal income taxes on their salaries just like anyone in DC would. Members of the US military stationed there? They pay too. It is a patchwork system where your neighbor might be paying the IRS while you aren't, purely based on who signs your paycheck.
Do Puerto Ricans Pay US Taxes? Yes, Through Payroll and Beyond
Even if a resident doesn't owe a cent in federal income tax, they are still paying into the system. This is the part people miss.
Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA) are mandatory in Puerto Rico. Every time a worker gets a paycheck, those federal deductions are taken out. In fact, Puerto Ricans contribute billions of dollars annually to the US Treasury through these payroll taxes. In 2021, the IRS collected over $4.5 billion from the island. That is more than some actual states, like Wyoming or Vermont, contribute in certain years.
Then you have the indirect stuff.
Import/export duties.
Commodity taxes.
Estate and gift taxes in certain scenarios.
The "no taxation without representation" slogan gets tossed around a lot because, while Puerto Ricans pay into Social Security and Medicare, they don't receive the same level of benefits as residents of the 50 states. Programs like Supplemental Security Income (SSI) aren't fully available there, a reality recently upheld by the US Supreme Court in United States v. Vaello Madero. It’s a lopsided deal that creates a lot of local resentment.
The Hacienda Factor
Don't think for a second that Puerto Ricans are living in a tax-free paradise just because the IRS stays away from their local wages. The local tax department, Hacienda, is notoriously aggressive.
Puerto Rico has its own internal revenue code. For many middle-class families, the local income tax rates are actually higher than what they would pay in federal taxes if Puerto Rico were a state. The cost of living is high, and the local tax burden is significant. When you add the 11.5% sales and use tax (IVU)—which is the highest of any US jurisdiction—the "tax break" starts to look like a myth for the average person.
The Act 60 Magnet: Why Everyone is Moving There
You’ve probably heard of crypto bros or hedge fund managers moving to San Juan. They aren't doing it for the mofongo, though the food is great. They are doing it for Act 60 (formerly Act 20 and Act 22).
This is a local law designed to lure wealthy investors to the island. If you become a bona fide resident, you can get a 0% tax rate on capital gains, dividends, and interest. For someone sitting on millions in Bitcoin or tech stocks, that is a life-changing amount of money.
📖 Related: The 161 Maiden Lane New York Mess: Why That Tilting Skyscraper Is Still Just Sitting There
But there are strings attached. You have to:
- Spend at least 183 days a year on the island.
- Buy a home within two years.
- Donate $10,000 annually to local nonprofits.
- File an annual report that costs $5,000.
This has created a massive divide. Locals see wealthy newcomers paying 0% on their investments while the locals themselves are paying high income taxes and dealing with a crumbling power grid. It’s a point of extreme friction. The IRS has also started cracking down, auditing hundreds of Act 60 beneficiaries to make sure they aren't just "faking" their residency while actually living in Miami.
Corporate Taxes and the "Ghost" Economy
For decades, Puerto Rico was a manufacturing hub because of something called Section 936. It allowed US corporations to send profits from PR branches back to the states tax-free. When Congress phased that out in the late 90s and early 2000s, the island's economy went into a tailspin that it still hasn't fully recovered from.
Today, large multi-national corporations still operate there, but the tax structures are a maze of "Controlled Foreign Corporations" (CFCs). These companies pay a local excise tax that accounts for a huge chunk of the Puerto Rican government's budget. It is a delicate balance. If the US changes federal tax law too drastically, these companies might pack up and move to Ireland or Singapore, leaving the island's economy in ruins.
Why the "Common Knowledge" is Usually Wrong
The internet loves a simple narrative. You'll hear people say, "Puerto Rico is a welfare state that doesn't pay taxes."
That's just factually incorrect.
Beyond the billions in payroll taxes, the island acts as a captive market for US goods. Because of the Jones Act, every single thing brought to the island on a ship must be on a vessel that is US-built, US-owned, and US-crewed. This makes milk, cars, and construction materials way more expensive than they are on the mainland. In a way, Puerto Ricans pay a "hidden tax" on every single item they buy, which directly supports the US shipping industry.
What Happens if Puerto Rico Becomes a State?
This is the multi-billion dollar question. If statehood ever happens, the tax landscape flips overnight.
- Individuals: Most residents would suddenly owe federal income tax. However, because income levels on the island are lower than the US average, many would actually get money back through the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Child Tax Credit (CTC).
- The Government: The island would gain access to billions more in federal funding for Medicaid and infrastructure.
- Investors: Act 60 would essentially die. You can't have a 0% federal capital gains rate in a US state.
It is a trade-off. Some argue the influx of federal support would outweigh the new tax burden. Others fear that taxing local businesses would crush an already fragile private sector.
How to Navigate This if You’re Moving
If you’re looking at Puerto Rico for the tax benefits, don't just wing it. The IRS is currently using AI and data matching to find people claiming PR residency while still keeping their primary ties to the mainland.
Bona fide residency is a high bar. You have to prove your "tax home" is in Puerto Rico. This means your family is there, your cars are registered there, you vote there, and you don't have a "closer connection" to the US mainland. If you keep your house in New Jersey and spend 5 months a year there, the IRS will likely argue you aren't a resident of PR, and they will come for back taxes, interest, and penalties.
Actionable Steps for Tax Compliance
If you are earning income related to Puerto Rico, or considering a move, here is how you stay out of trouble:
- Determine Income Source: Identify exactly where your money is coming from. If it’s a US-based remote job, you likely still owe the IRS unless your employer has a local Puerto Rican entity.
- Track Your Days: If you are aiming for Act 60 benefits, use a tracking app. The "183-day rule" is the bare minimum, but the "Closer Connection" test is what usually trips people up in audits.
- Hire a Dual-Specialist: Don't just hire a CPA in New York or a CPA in San Juan. You need someone who understands the interplay between the US Internal Revenue Code and the Puerto Rico Internal Revenue Code.
- File Form 8898: If you move to or from Puerto Rico and have a certain level of income, you are required to notify the IRS. Failing to do this is an automatic red flag.
- Check Social Security Credits: If you work in PR, ensure your FICA contributions are being reported correctly. These credits are what determine your future retirement benefits, and errors are harder to fix the longer you wait.
The bottom line is that Puerto Ricans do pay US taxes, just not all of them, and not in the way most people think. It’s a specialized corner of the tax code that reflects a complicated political relationship. Whether you're a local worker or a high-net-worth investor, the rules are strict, the paperwork is heavy, and the "tax-free" label is mostly a misunderstanding of a much more complex reality.
Next Steps for Research
Check the latest IRS Publication 1321, which specifically outlines the "Special Tax Rules for Bona Fide Residents of Puerto Rico." It provides the current thresholds for filing requirements and clarifies the distinction between possession-source income and US-source income. For those looking into local incentives, the Department of Economic Development and Commerce (DDEC) maintains the official portal for Act 60 applications and compliance mandates.
Ensure you review the "presence test" requirements under 26 CFR § 1.937-1 to understand how the IRS calculates days spent in the territory, especially during travel days or medical emergencies. Tax laws in this jurisdiction are subject to frequent shifts based on both local legislative changes and federal court rulings regarding the Territorial Clause of the US Constitution.
The most important thing is realizing that "tax-exempt" does not mean "file-exempt." Even if you owe zero, the reporting requirements for Puerto Rican residents are often more burdensome than those for residents of the 50 states. Keep meticulous records of all income sources and physical location to avoid the growing number of residency audits conducted by the Large Business and International (LB&I) division of the IRS.