Don't Carry It All: The Psychology of Mental Load and Why We Keep Breaking Down

Don't Carry It All: The Psychology of Mental Load and Why We Keep Breaking Down

You’re standing in the kitchen. It’s 6:14 PM. The fridge is humming that annoying low-frequency buzz that usually doesn’t bother you, but today it feels like a physical weight against your eardrums. You have a deadline tomorrow, the dog needs a vet appointment for that weird bump on his leg, and you just realized you forgot to buy milk. Again. It isn't just about the milk. It’s about the fact that you are the only one in the house who knew the milk was gone. That is the essence of why you need to learn how to don't carry it all before the structural integrity of your mental health starts to give way.

We talk a lot about "burnout" like it’s a badge of honor or a temporary glitch in the system. It’s not. It’s usually the result of a long-term, invisible accumulation of tasks, worries, and emotional labor that we’ve convinced ourselves is just "part of life." But when we look at the actual data on cognitive load and physiological stress, the picture gets a lot grimmer.

The Science of Why You Can't Just "Push Through"

Your brain isn't a hard drive with infinite space. It’s more like a workbench. If you keep piling tools and projects on that workbench without finishing anything or clearing the space, eventually, you can't even see the wood anymore. You lose the ability to work.

Neuropsychologists often point to the concept of Cognitive Load Theory. Originally developed by John Sweller in the 1980s, it basically says our working memory has a limited capacity. When we try to process too much information at once—like remembering a grocery list while navigating traffic and planning a work presentation—the system glitches. We become irritable. We make "stupid" mistakes. We forget our keys. It’s not a character flaw; it’s a hardware limitation.

The Invisible Weight of Emotional Labor

Sociologist Arlie Hochschild coined the term "emotional labor" back in 1983, but it’s evolved. Today, we often use it to describe the "managerial" work of running a life. It’s the "worrying" part.

  • Who is keeping track of when the oil needs changing?
  • Who remembers that your mother-in-law is allergic to shellfish before you book the restaurant?
  • Who knows where the spare lightbulbs are kept?

When you don't carry it all, you aren't just saying "I won't do the dishes." You’re saying, "I am no longer the sole proprietor of the household's operational database." There is a massive difference between doing a task and owning the responsibility for making sure that task happens. Most people are exhausted because they are owning 100% of the responsibility even if they are only doing 50% of the physical work.

Breaking the "Hero" Complex

We have this weird obsession with being the person who can "do it all." We post about our "hustle." We brag about how little sleep we got. It’s honestly kind of toxic.

I remember talking to a high-level executive who was on the verge of a literal heart attack. He told me he felt like if he let go of even one small project, the whole company would fold. That’s the "Hero Complex" in action. It’s a form of narcissism, really—thinking you’re so indispensable that the world stops spinning without your specific input.

Actually, the most effective leaders and the happiest parents are usually the ones who are the best at "letting things be mediocre" for a while. If the laundry stays in the dryer for three days, does the world end? No. If you order pizza because you’re too tired to cook the organic kale you bought, are you a failure? Nope. You’re just a human who understands that your energy is a finite resource.

📖 Related: Understanding the Power and Control Wheel: Why Emotional Abuse is More Than Just Words

The Biological Cost of Hyper-Vigilance

When you are constantly "carrying it all," your body stays in a state of low-grade sympathetic nervous system activation. This is your "fight or flight" mode. Usually, this should only kick in when you’re being chased by a bear or avoiding a car accident. But if you’re constantly scanning your environment for things that need to be done, your cortisol levels stay elevated.

High cortisol is bad news. It messes with your sleep, it causes systemic inflammation, and it literally shrinks the prefrontal cortex—the part of your brain responsible for executive function and emotional regulation. So, the more you try to carry, the less capable your brain becomes of carrying it. It’s a self-defeating cycle.

Real-World Strategies to Lighten the Load

So, how do you actually stop? How do you implement a "don't carry it all" policy without your life falling apart? It requires a mix of boundary setting and radical honesty.

1. The "Fair Play" Method

Eve Rodsky wrote a fantastic book called Fair Play that uses a card-deck system to divide household labor. The genius of her system isn't just about who does what; it’s about CPE: Conception, Planning, and Execution. If you ask your partner to "help with dinner," you are still doing the Conception (deciding what to eat) and the Planning (checking if you have ingredients). They are only doing the Execution. This doesn't actually lower your mental load. To truly stop carrying it all, you have to hand over the entire "card." If they own dinner, they own the planning, the shopping, the cooking, and the cleanup. You stay out of it. Even if they make cereal three nights in a row.

2. The Power of "Selective Neglect"

This is a term used in some psychological circles to describe the intentional choice to let certain things fail. You have to decide what matters and what doesn't.

Maybe the lawn doesn't get mowed this week. Maybe you don't respond to that non-urgent email until Monday. By choosing what to neglect, you reclaim control over your attention. You’re no longer a victim of your to-do list; you’re the curator of your life.

Why We Struggle to Let Go

Honestly, the hardest part of trying to don't carry it all isn't the logistics. It’s the guilt.

Society—and often our own families—expects us to be "on" all the time. Women, in particular, are socialized to be the nurturers and the organizers. If a house is messy or a kid misses a birthday party, the judgment usually falls on the mother, regardless of who was actually "responsible."

We have to get comfortable with being "judged." We have to realize that other people’s expectations are not our obligations. If someone thinks you’re "lazy" because you’ve prioritized your peace over a perfectly curated life, that’s a "them" problem, not a "you" problem.

The "Deadly" Perfectionism

Perfectionism is just anxiety in a fancy suit. It’s the fear that if we aren't perfect, we aren't worthy of love or respect. When we try to carry every single burden, we are often trying to prove our worth.

But here’s the truth: nobody is going to give you a trophy at the end of your life for having the cleanest baseboards or the most organized spreadsheets. They’re going to remember if you were present, if you were kind, and if you actually enjoyed your time on this planet. You can't be present if your mind is a 24/7 construction site of worries.

The Role of Technology: Help or Hindrance?

We thought apps and smart devices would make things easier. Instead, they just gave us more things to track. Now we have notifications for everything. Our "load" is now digital.

To truly don't carry it all, you might need to do a digital audit. Delete the apps that make you feel like you aren't doing enough. Turn off the notifications that interrupt your flow. Technology should be a tool that serves you, not a leash that keeps you tethered to your responsibilities every second of the day.

Actionable Steps to Shed the Weight

Don't try to change everything at once. That just adds more to your load. Start small.

  • The 24-Hour Rule: When someone asks you to do something, don't say yes immediately. Say, "Let me check my schedule and get back to you tomorrow." This gives you space to decide if you actually have the capacity.
  • Audit Your "Shoulds": Write down everything you feel you "should" do today. Now, look at that list and ask, "Who says?" If the answer is "society" or "my inner critic," cross it off.
  • Delegate the Outcome, Not the Task: When you hand something off, don't give instructions. Give the goal. "I need the kids fed and in bed by 8 PM" is better than a 10-step list of how to make chicken nuggets. Let the other person figure it out.
  • Schedule "Nothing" Time: Literally put a block on your calendar for doing absolutely nothing. No chores, no scrolling, no "productive" hobbies. Just sitting. It recalibrates your nervous system.

The goal isn't to become a person who does nothing. The goal is to become a person who chooses what to carry based on their own values, rather than carrying everything out of habit or fear.

When you stop carrying it all, you finally have the hands free to hold the things that actually matter. You might find that once you put down the heavy, useless stuff, you actually have more energy for the work that fulfills you and the people you love. It’s a terrifying shift, but it’s the only way to survive a world that is constantly asking for more than we have to give.

Start by putting down one thing today. Just one. See what happens. Most of the time, the world keeps spinning, and you finally get to catch your breath.

Immediate Next Steps:

  1. Identify your "Heavy Lift": Pinpoint the one recurring task that causes the most mental friction (e.g., meal planning, managing the shared calendar).
  2. The Hand-Off: Formally transfer this task to someone else or automate it completely. If you transfer it, you must also transfer the right to do it "wrong" without correcting them.
  3. Digital Declutter: Turn off all non-human notifications on your phone for 48 hours. If it's not a person trying to reach you, it doesn't need your immediate attention.
  4. Practice the "No": Say "no" to one social or professional invitation this week that you would normally say "yes" to out of guilt. Observe the lack of catastrophe that follows.