Everyone has that one friend. The one who spends their entire Sunday night scrolling through doom-and-gloom financial Twitter threads, convinced the world is ending because a random manufacturing index in a country they can't find on a map dropped by half a percent. By 9:30 AM the next morning, they've panicked. They sell. Then, they watch in agony as the market rebounds by Tuesday afternoon. Honestly, it's a classic mistake. If you've ever felt the urge to dump your portfolio the second the opening bell rings after a long weekend, stop. Just stop. There is a very specific reason you should don't sell stocks on monday, and it isn't just a superstition—it’s backed by decades of messy, weird, and often frustrating market data.
The stock market is a giant machine powered by human emotion, and humans are notoriously grumpy on Mondays. Think about it. You’ve had forty-eight hours to stew over every bad headline. The news cycle doesn't sleep just because the New York Stock Exchange does. When bad news breaks on a Saturday, it ferments. It bubbles up. By the time Monday morning rolls around, there is a massive backlog of sell orders waiting to be executed. This creates what academics call the "Weekend Effect" or the "Monday Effect." It’s a phenomenon where returns on Mondays are statistically lower than other days of the week. Basically, if you sell on Monday morning, you are likely selling into a wave of collective pessimism at the worst possible price of the week.
The Brutal Reality of the Weekend Effect
Researchers have been obsessed with this for years. Back in the 1980s, economist Frank French published a famous study in the Journal of Financial Economics showing that daily returns were significantly different on Mondays compared to other days. He looked at S&P 500 data from 1953 to 1977 and found that the average return on Monday was actually negative. Negative! Every other day of the week trended positive. While the market has evolved with high-frequency trading and 24/7 global markets, the psychological core of this remains.
Markets hate uncertainty. Over the weekend, there is no "price discovery" because the exchanges are closed. If a geopolitical crisis kicks off on Sunday, investors can't react in real-time. They wait. They pace. Then, they slam the sell button at 9:31 AM. This creates a liquidity crunch. When everyone is trying to exit through the same narrow door at the same time, the price drops further than it probably should. If you're the one selling, you're the one providing that liquidity at a discount to the "smart money" waiting to buy your fear. It's a bad deal.
Why the First 90 Minutes are a Trap
The "Monday Morning Fade" is a real thing. Traders often see a "fake out" move in the first hour of Monday trading. You might see a small bounce as people cover short positions, followed by a massive slide as the "weekend worriers" dump their shares. If you sell during this window, you are essentially participating in a fire sale.
I remember talking to a veteran floor trader who told me that Mondays are for "amateur hour." He argued that institutional investors—the big pension funds and hedge funds—often wait for the Monday volatility to settle before making their moves. They want to see where the dust lands. If the big players are waiting, why are you rushing? You're playing against a stacked deck.
The volatility on Mondays is often higher than on Wednesdays or Thursdays. High volatility means wider bid-ask spreads. This means you’re losing money on the "friction" of the trade itself. You get a worse fill price. You pay more in the invisible tax of market inefficiency. It adds up. Over a lifetime of investing, selling on the worst-performing day of the week can shave a staggering amount off your total net worth.
Looking at the "Bad News" Bias
Psychologically, we are wired to remember losses more than gains. This is "loss aversion." On a Monday, after a weekend of reading "The 5 Reasons the Economy is About to Crash" articles, your loss aversion is at an all-time high. You aren't thinking about the 10-year horizon. You're thinking about the next ten minutes.
📖 Related: Why 708 Third Avenue NY is the Sleeper Hit of Midtown East Office Space
Many retail investors use Mondays to "clean up" their portfolios. They treat it like a chore, like taking out the trash. But the stock market isn't a kitchen. You shouldn't be cleaning it out just because it's the start of the work week. This "behavioral bias" leads to selling winners too early or panic-selling losers at the absolute bottom.
When the "Don't Sell" Rule Actually Breaks
Now, look, I’m not saying you should never sell on a Monday. That would be dogmatic and, frankly, stupid. If a company you own just announced their CEO was arrested for embezzlement at 8:00 AM on a Monday, yeah, you might want to get out.
But for general portfolio rebalancing? For "I'm worried about the market" sells? Monday is your enemy.
There are also instances where the Monday Effect flips. This is known as a "Reverse Monday Effect." In some high-growth periods, Mondays can actually be bullish if the previous Friday was strong. But these are outliers. The general rule—the one that keeps your shirt on your back—is to let the Monday madness pass.
- Check the volume. If Monday's sell-off is happening on low volume, it’s likely noise. Don't fall for it.
- Wait for Tuesday. History shows that "Turnaround Tuesday" is a very real thing. After the Monday panic subsides, cooler heads prevail, and prices often mean-revert.
- Analyze the "Why." Did the market drop because of a structural change in the economy, or because some guy on news television looked stressed? 90% of the time, it's the latter.
Institutional Games and the Retail Squeeze
Big banks and algorithmic traders know you're nervous on Mondays. They use sophisticated models to hunt for "stop-loss" orders. If they know a bunch of retail investors have set stop-losses just below a key support level, they can push the price down on Monday morning to trigger those sells. Once your shares are automatically sold at a loss, the big guys buy them up and the price bounces back.
It’s predatory. It’s also perfectly legal.
By refusing to sell on Monday, you take that weapon out of their hands. You are choosing to be a "price maker" later in the week rather than a "price taker" during the Monday morning scramble.
What the Data Says About Other Days
If Monday is the worst, what’s the best? Historically, Fridays have often shown a "pre-holiday" or "pre-weekend" optimism, though that has flattened out in recent years. Wednesdays and Thursdays tend to be the "truest" days for price discovery. The mid-week is when the actual economic data has been digested, the initial emotional reactions are gone, and the market is trading on fundamentals rather than "Sunday Night Scares."
Actionable Steps for Your Portfolio
So, what do you actually do with this information? You don't just sit on your hands and hope for the best. You build a system that protects you from your own Monday-morning brain.
First, disable your trade notifications on Sundays. Seriously. Nothing good comes from checking your portfolio balance when the markets are closed and you're already dreading your 9 AM meeting.
Second, implement a "24-Hour Cooling Off Rule." If you feel the urge to sell everything on Monday, tell yourself you have to wait until Tuesday at noon. If the reasons for selling still hold up after 24 hours of calm, then proceed. Most of the time, you'll find the "urgent" need to sell was just a temporary spike in cortisol.
Third, look at the 50-day moving average. If the stock is still trading above its long-term average, a Monday dip is just noise. It’s a blip. It’s a gift to the people who aren't panicking.
Fourth, use "Limit Orders" instead of "Market Orders." If you absolutely must sell on a Monday, do not use a market order. You will get "picked off" by the high-frequency traders. Set a limit price—the minimum you are willing to accept. If the market is crashing too fast to hit your limit, then you shouldn't have been selling into that chaos anyway.
Stop being the liquidity for the pros. The next time you feel that Monday morning itch to dump your holdings, remember that the most successful investors aren't the ones who react the fastest. They’re the ones who can sit still while everyone else is running for the exits. Don't sell stocks on monday just because the headlines are loud. Wait for the silence of Tuesday. Your bank account will thank you.
Your next move: Open your brokerage account right now and check your "Stop-Loss" orders. If they are set too tight, a random Monday morning dip could trigger a sell you didn't actually want. Loosen them up or switch to "Alerts" instead of automatic sells so you stay in control of the trade.