Fantasy football is basically a game of risk management disguised as a hobby for people who like spreadsheets. You spend all summer reading camp reports. You watch preseason games where the third-stringers are playing for their lives. But honestly? The most important thing you’ll do before the clock starts ticking in your draft room is deciding who you aren't going to pick. That’s where the do not draft list comes in. It’s not about hating a player. It’s about value, math, and avoiding the landmines that blow up a season before October even hits.
Most people think a do not draft list is just a collection of players who suck. It's not. It’s usually a list of very talented athletes who are simply being sold at a price that doesn't make sense. If a guy is projected to go in the second round but his offensive line just lost two Pro Bowlers, he’s a trap. If a wide receiver is switching teams and history shows that specific transition usually results in a 20% production dip, he’s a trap. You've got to be cold-blooded about it.
The Psychology of the Do Not Draft List
Drafting is emotional. We remember that one time a player won us a week with a 40-point explosion. We forget the three weeks they gave us four points. A solid do not draft list acts like a shield against your own nostalgia. It forces you to look at the "Average Draft Position" (ADP) and say, "No thanks."
Take the "Dead Zone" running backs. Every year, there’s a group of backs going in rounds three through six. They have names you recognize. They’re starters. But statistically, these guys fail at a much higher rate than wide receivers in the same range. If your do not draft list doesn't include a few of these volume-dependent, low-efficiency backs, you’re probably headed for a mediocre 6-8 season. It’s just how the numbers shake out.
Injury Red Flags and the Age Cliff
You can't predict injuries. Not really. But you can predict risk. Look at the "Age Cliff" for running backs. It’s real. Once a back hits 27 or 28, the cliff isn't a slope; it’s a drop-off into a canyon. If you see an aging vet whose name value is keeping his ADP high, he belongs on the list.
👉 See also: What Time Is the Actual Kickoff for the Super Bowl? (Finally Explained)
Same goes for soft tissue injuries. A hamstring tweak in August is a nightmare. These things linger. They come back in Week 4 when you need a win. If a player is already dealing with a "minor" pull during camp, and he’s your projected RB1, you need to seriously consider putting him on your do not draft list. It’s about building a roster with a high floor. You want guys who are actually on the field.
Spotting the Offensive Environment Traps
Individual talent is only about 40% of the equation in fantasy. The rest? It’s the play-caller, the quarterback, and the big guys upfront. You could be the most talented receiver in the league, but if your quarterback can’t throw a deep ball to save his life, your ceiling is capped.
Bad offensive lines kill fantasy value. Fast. If a team's projected O-line rank is in the bottom five according to analysts like Brandon Thorn, their lead runner is an automatic candidate for the do not draft list. You’re drafting for touchdowns. Touchdowns require getting into the red zone. If the line can’t push, the team doesn't score. It’s simple, but people ignore it because they like the player’s college highlights.
The Rookie Fever Pitfall
Rookies are sexy. Everyone wants the next Justin Jefferson or Breece Hall. But for every superstar rookie, there are five who do nothing for the first ten weeks. If a rookie's ADP starts creeping into the top four rounds, the risk-to-reward ratio gets wonky. You’re paying for their ceiling while ignoring their floor, which is often zero.
A smart do not draft list acknowledges that while a rookie might be "the guy" eventually, the cost to find out is too high. Let someone else take that gamble. You take the boring veteran who is guaranteed 10 targets a game. It’s not flashy. It doesn't win you the "best draft" award in the group chat. But it wins championships.
Context Matters: When to Break Your Own Rules
There is one caveat. Price. A do not draft list is usually price-dependent. If a player you've sworn off falls two full rounds past their ADP, they might become a value. Even the "do not draft" guys have a point where the talent outweighs the risk.
📖 Related: Minnesota Vikings Sam Darnold: Why Everyone Got the 2024 Season So Wrong
But be careful. Sometimes a player falls for a reason. Maybe the local beat writers know something the national guys don't. Maybe that "minor" ankle sprain is actually a high-ankle issue that will require surgery. Don't be the person who thinks they’re smarter than the room just because a big name fell to them in the 7th round. Sometimes the room is right.
How to Build Your Own List This Year
You shouldn't just copy a list from a website. You need to build one that fits your league's scoring. In a PPR (Points Per Reception) league, big-bruiser backs who don't catch passes are huge candidates for the do not draft list. In a Standard league, those same guys are gold.
- Look at the ADP vs. Last Year’s Finish. If a guy finished as WR25 but is being drafted as WR12, ask yourself why. Did his situation improve that much? Usually, the answer is no.
- Check the coaching changes. A new Offensive Coordinator can change everything. If a team moves from a fast-paced, pass-heavy scheme to a "ground and pound" style, their receivers are in trouble.
- Watch the vacated targets. If a team lost a star player, don't just assume the "next man up" will inherit all that production. Sometimes the whole offense just gets worse.
Fantasy football is won by making fewer mistakes than your opponents. Your do not draft list is your map through the minefield. It keeps you disciplined when the "war room" pressure starts to get to you. It reminds you that you’re not drafting players; you’re drafting points. And some players are just too expensive for the points they actually provide.
Implementation Steps for Your Draft
- Audit your rankings: Highlight any player you feel "meh" about who is going in the first four rounds. If you aren't excited to click their name, they are a list candidate.
- Check the Vegas totals: Look at the projected win totals for every NFL team. If a player is on a team projected to win 4 or 5 games, they’ll be playing from behind. That’s bad for RBs, but potentially okay for WRs in garbage time.
- Identify the "injury-prone" tag: Don't get over-reliant on this, but if a guy hasn't played a full season in three years, stop expecting this year to be different.
- Verify the contract status: Players in contract years sometimes over-perform, but players who just got a massive "bag" occasionally see a dip in urgency or are on teams with less cap space to support them.
Building a do not draft list is about being honest with yourself. It’s about realizing that "talent" doesn't always equal "fantasy points." By the time your draft starts, you should have a clear set of names that you will not click, no matter how much the "expert" rankings tell you they are a "steal." That discipline is the difference between a playoff run and looking at mock drafts for next year by mid-November.