Fantasy football is basically a game of lying to yourself until the numbers prove you wrong. You've probably spent the last three months convinced that your roster is "one piece away," but then you look at the dynasty rankings 2025 superflex landscape and realize your "piece" is actually an aging vet on a team that just drafted his replacement. It’s brutal. Honestly, superflex is the only way to play if you want the "QB is King" reality of the NFL to actually matter in your living room, but it also makes the margin for error razor-thin.
If you aren't valuing the 2025 rookie class correctly right now, you’re already behind. This isn't the 2024 class where we had Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels looking like sure things. The 2025 vibe is different. It’s heavier on the ground, and the wide receiver depth is... interesting, to say the least.
The Quarterback Tier: Where Dreams (and Budgets) Go to Die
In a superflex startup or even just a trade-heavy offseason, the top of the board is dominated by the usual suspects, but the order is shifting. Josh Allen is still the god-tier option for most. He’s been a top-three fantasy QB for five straight seasons. Even with Joe Brady leaning more into the run game in Buffalo, Allen’s rushing floor is a safety net made of pure gold.
💡 You might also like: How Do NFL Schedules Work: The Logic Behind the Chaos
But have you seen what Jayden Daniels did? He averaged 23.7 fantasy points per game in 2024. That’s insane. The Washington Commanders actually went out and got him Deebo Samuel Sr. and Laremy Tunsil to keep him upright. If you’re ranking him anywhere outside your top three QBs in dynasty, you’re playing it too safe. Rushing upside wins championships. Period.
Then there's the Joe Burrow situation. He’s the "best potential value" guy because he doesn't run. People get bored of 4,500 yards and 35 touchdowns through the air if there aren't 600 rushing yards attached to it. Don't be that person. Burrow is locked in with Ja’Marr Chase for the foreseeable future. That connection is a literal cheat code.
The 2025 Rookie Impact: It's the Year of the Running Back
For years, we’ve been told "running backs don't matter." Tell that to the guy who drafts Ashton Jeanty. Honestly, Jeanty is the closest thing we’ve seen to a "can't-miss" back since Bijan Robinson. PFF gave him a 99.9 career rushing grade at Boise State. He’s likely headed to a spot like the Las Vegas Raiders or maybe the Chicago Bears if they decide to really move on from the Swift experiment.
- Ashton Jeanty (RB1): He's the 1.01 in almost every rookie mock right now.
- Cam Ward (QB1): The Miami product is the only 2025 QB likely to go in the first round of superflex rookie drafts. He's got the arm, but the "turnover-worthy plays" will give you gray hairs.
- Omarion Hampton (RB2): Think of him as the hammer. He’s a zone-scheme dream who might end up with Jim Harbaugh in LA. That’s a scary thought for the rest of the AFC West.
- Tetairoa McMillan (WR1): At 6'4", he's the "X" receiver every NFL team wants. If he lands in Carolina with Bryce Young, he’s getting 140 targets day one.
Wide Receiver Values: The Alpha and the Others
We need to talk about Ja'Marr Chase. He won the triple crown in 2024. Receptions, yards, touchdowns—all of it. In a 2025 superflex world, he is the only non-QB worth a top-five pick in a startup. Justin Jefferson is right there, but the "JJ McCarthy or Sam Darnold" question mark at QB puts him a hair behind Chase for me.
Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr. are the two biggest risers from the 2024 class. Nabers is doing it with questionable QB play in New York, which just proves he’s a target hog. Meanwhile, Thomas Jr. and Trevor Lawrence finally found that deep-ball rhythm. If you can trade a vet like Tyreek Hill (who is staring at the age cliff) for a package involving Thomas Jr., you do it yesterday.
The "Fades" Nobody Wants to Admit
- Chris Olave: The talent is there, but the concussions are a real concern. If he’s your WR1, you should be nervous.
- Dak Prescott: He’s going to throw for a million yards, but for how much longer? In dynasty, you’re looking for a five-year window. Dak is entering the "year-to-year" phase.
- Travis Hunter: He’s a unicorn. He plays CB and WR. But in fantasy, that’s a nightmare. Will he play enough snaps on offense to be a consistent WR1? Or will his defensive duties cap his ceiling? It’s a massive gamble at the 1.03 in rookie drafts.
Breaking Down the Tiers (Prose Edition)
Instead of a boring table, let's look at how you should actually build a roster in 2025. Your "Core 4" needs to be two high-end QBs and two "Alphas" at WR.
If you're starting a draft today, you want Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen as your anchor. In the second round, you’re looking for a guy like Saquon Barkley (who is somehow still elite in Philly) or CeeDee Lamb. By the time you get to the third round, you're eyeing Caleb Williams or Jordan Love. If you wait too long on your second QB in superflex, you end up starting Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith. They're fine, but they won't win you a week when your opponent's QBs combine for 60 points.
The tight end position is actually getting deep again. Brock Bowers broke every rookie record imaginable in 2024. He’s the TE1 now. Trey McBride is right behind him. If you aren't holding one of those two or Sam LaPorta, you might as well just stream the position and focus your capital elsewhere.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Trade
Stop holding onto "potential" that hasn't flashed in three years. Jaxon Smith-Njigba is a great example. People love him. But he's tied to Sam Darnold and a crowded Seattle room. If someone in your league still views him as a top-15 dynasty WR, sell him for a 2025 first-round pick and take a shot on a guy like Tet McMillan or Luther Burden III.
Next, look at your RB room. If you have Christian McCaffrey, his value is at its absolute peak right now before the wheels potentially come off. Trade him to a contender for a young RB like Jahmyr Gibbs or Bucky Irving plus a pick.
Lastly, check the waiver wire for Jaxson Dart or Tyler Shough if they were drafted late in your rookie rounds. Second-round QBs have a terrible hit rate, but in superflex, any starting QB has trade value. If they get a hot start, flip them for a veteran WR like Terry McLaurin to help your playoff push.
The 2025 season is going to be defined by how teams handle the "Jeanty Effect." If you don't have a top-three pick in your rookie draft, you better be moving up or moving out. There's a massive tier break after the top five players, and you don't want to be left holding the bag at 1.08.
👉 See also: How Old Is Balde? Why the Barcelona Star's Age Actually Matters
Take a look at your roster. Identify the guys over age 27. If they aren't named Josh Allen or Ja'Marr Chase, ask yourself if they'll still be productive in 2027. If the answer is "maybe," it's time to go shopping.