You might still call it Everest Re, but the market knows it as Everest Group, Ltd. (EG). Honestly, if you’re looking at the ticker "RE" and wondering why the charts stopped moving, you’ve missed the memo. In July 2023, this reinsurance giant shed its old skin. They rebranded, swapped tickers, and signaled to the world that they’re more than just a backstop for other insurance companies.
They're a different beast now.
Right now, in early 2026, the stock is sitting in a weird spot. As of mid-January, it’s hovering around $318 to $322. That’s a far cry from its 52-week high of $373. People are nervous. Why? Because the insurance business is messy, and Everest just had a rollercoaster of a year.
The Identity Crisis That Isn’t One
Most retail investors think Everest is just a reinsurance play. That’s the first mistake. While they are a global titan in reinsurance, their primary insurance wing has been the real story lately. CEO Jim Williamson has been steering the ship toward "disciplined execution." Basically, that’s corporate-speak for "we’re stopping the bleeding in bad sectors to make more money elsewhere."
📖 Related: US Dollar to SL Rupees Today: Why the Rate You See Isn't Always the Rate You Get
They recently decided to exit global retail insurance. That’s huge. They want to double down on reinsurance and specialty lines. It’s a move that says they’d rather be masters of a few high-margin domains than a "jack of all trades" struggling with social inflation in every corner of the globe.
Why the Stock Price is Acting So Moody
Let’s look at the numbers because they don’t lie, even if they’re a bit depressing at first glance.
- Q3 2025 was a gut punch. They reported an EPS of $7.54. Analysts were expecting $13.39. You don’t need to be a math genius to see that's a massive miss—nearly 47%.
- The Culprit? Casualty reserves. They had to pour about $478 million into prior-year loss reserves.
- Combined Ratio: It spiked to 103.4%. In insurance, anything over 100 means you’re paying out more in claims and expenses than you’re taking in from premiums. That’s bad for business.
But here’s the kicker: if you strip out those reserve adjustments and the catastrophe losses, their "attritional" combined ratio was actually a healthy 88.8%. The underlying engine is purring; it just hit a very large, very expensive pothole.
Everest Group Ltd Stock: The Analyst Divide
Wall Street is split down the middle on this one. It's almost funny. You’ve got the bulls at Barclays raising price targets to $377, while others are slashing them. Mizuho recently nudged theirs down to $358.
The "Hold" crowd is the loudest right now. About 60% of analysts are telling people to just sit tight. They want to see if the management’s plan to fix the insurance segment actually works.
Is it Undervalued?
Some valuation models, like the ones from Alpha Spread, claim the intrinsic value is way higher—potentially over $700. That seems a bit optimistic, maybe even wild. However, even conservative estimates suggest a fair value around $364.
If you buy at $320, you’re essentially betting that the "bad news" is already baked in. You’re buying the dip. But it’s a deep dip. The stock has underperformed the S&P 500 recently, which has left a lot of long-term holders feeling pretty salty.
The Dividend Safety Net
If there’s one thing that keeps the lights on for investors, it’s the dividend.
- Current Payout: They’ve been holding steady at $2.00 per share quarterly.
- Yield: It sits around 2.5%.
- Growth: They’ve increased it for five consecutive years.
It’s not a "get rich quick" yield, but it’s dependable. It shows that despite the earnings miss, the Board isn't panicking about cash flow. They generated $1.5 billion in operating cash flow in Q3 2025 alone. They have the money; they just had a messy accounting quarter.
What to Watch for in 2026
We are looking at a big "show me" year. The Q4 2025 earnings are set to drop around February 4, 2026. That’s going to be the "make or break" moment for the current price level.
If they show that the casualty reserve issues are truly behind them, the stock could snap back to the $350 range quickly. If there’s another "surprise" adjustment? Expect $300 to be tested.
They also just hired Christopher Kujawa as the new Chief Human Resources Officer. Now, usually, an HR hire doesn't move a stock. But Kujawa came from Conduent and has a background in "large-scale corporate transformation." That’s a signal that Everest is serious about changing its internal culture to be leaner and more profitable.
Navigating the Risk
Reinsurance is a gamble on the weather and human litigation. Social inflation—where juries award massive payouts—is a nightmare for companies like Everest. They’re fighting back by raising rates, but there’s a limit to how much they can charge before clients walk away.
✨ Don't miss: Joann Fabric Newport News: Why This Storefront Actually Matters Right Now
Also, keep an eye on Longtail Re. Everest set up an "Adverse Development Cover" (ADC) with them. This is basically insurance for the insurance company. It protects Everest from further losses on those old casualty files up to $1.2 billion. It’s a safety net that should, in theory, prevent another $400 million surprise.
Actionable Insights for Investors
If you’re looking at Everest Group Ltd stock, don't just stare at the daily ticker. The noise is loud right now.
- Check the February Earnings: Look specifically at the Insurance Segment Combined Ratio. If it stays above 100, the "transformation" is taking longer than planned.
- Monitor the ADC Utilization: Watch the SEC filings to see if they start eating into that $1.2 billion cover from Longtail Re. If they do, it means their original reserves were even worse than they thought.
- Compare with Peers: Look at RenaissanceRe (RNR) or Arch Capital (ACGL). If they are soaring while Everest is flat, the problem is internal, not a market-wide insurance slump.
- Set a Floor: If you’re a buyer here, a stop-loss around the $302 mark (the 52-week low) makes sense. If it breaks that, the technical damage might be too much to ignore.
The company is currently trading at a forward P/E of about 6.6x. That is incredibly cheap compared to the broader financial sector. But it’s cheap for a reason. The market is waiting to see if Jim Williamson can actually turn "disciplined execution" into "consistent profit."
Wait for the Q4 report before making a massive move. If the reserves are stable, the upside to $370 is very real.