It was a strange sight. You probably remember the photos—runners gasping for air, brass players with bells poking through fabric, and diners trying to navigate a "new normal" that felt anything but. When the New York Times first began reporting on the face covering with an opening, it wasn't just a fashion quirk. It was a desperate, mechanical response to a world that needed to breathe and communicate while staying shielded. People were cutting holes in masks. It sounds counterintuitive. It is counterintuitive. But the science behind why these designs exist, and where they actually fail, is a lot more complex than just "putting a hole in your protection."
The Physics of the Gap
A mask is basically a filter. If you poke a hole in a filter, the air—and the pathogens hitching a ride on those microscopic respiratory droplets—will take the path of least resistance. That is fluid dynamics 101. When the New York Times covered the emergence of these modified masks, they weren't necessarily endorsing them; they were documenting a cultural pivot toward "harm reduction" for specific groups.
Think about a professional flutist. You can't play the flute through a solid layer of polypropylene. You just can't. So, designers created masks with a horizontal slit. The idea was that the instrument's mouthpiece would plug the gap during play. Does it work? Sorta. A study by the International Coalition of Performing Arts Aerosol Study, led by researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder and the University of Maryland, found that while these "opening" masks aren't as good as a standard N95, they are significantly better than nothing. They found that most of the aerosol spray from a wind instrument is captured if the mask fits tightly around the instrument itself.
But for the average person walking into a grocery store? A face covering with an opening is a disaster. If the slit doesn't have a structural overlap—like a flap or a valve—you're basically wearing a chin strap.
When the Opening Makes Sense (And When It Doesn't)
There are really only three scenarios where a gap in a face covering isn't a total safety failure.
💡 You might also like: I Cant Handle Change: Why Your Brain Rebels and How to Fix It
First, let's talk about the hard-of-hearing community. This is where the Times really focused its human-interest reporting. Traditional masks are a nightmare for lip-readers. Clear masks with a transparent plastic "opening" (though technically sealed) became a lifeline. However, the DIY versions—where people simply cut out a square—defeated the entire purpose of source control.
Second, the "straw hole." We've all seen them at outdoor festivals. A small, grommeted hole designed for a drink. Honestly, if you're outside and socially distanced, the risk is low. But the moment you step into a crowded elevator with that hole exposed, the mask's efficiency drops by upwards of 50 to 70 percent because of air leakage.
Third, the valved respirator. You’ve seen these—the plastic "buttons" on the front of N95s. Technically, that is a face covering with an opening. It’s a one-way valve. It protects the wearer perfectly because it closes when you inhale. But it stays open when you exhale. This is why many hospitals banned them early on. You were protected, but everyone else was at the mercy of your unfiltered breath.
🔗 Read more: Male Healthy Weight Chart: Why Your Doctor Might Be Giving You Bad Advice
Why the Design Failed the "Discovery" Test
Google's algorithms and health experts have become incredibly sensitive to "mask hacks." For a while, "face covering with an opening" was a trending search term because people were looking for ways to eat in restaurants without taking their masks off.
It didn't work.
The CDC and the World Health Organization (WHO) eventually had to issue specific guidance against masks with exhalation valves or holes. They noted that any opening that allows air to escape unfiltered bypasses the very "source control" that makes masking effective in a community setting.
💡 You might also like: The Truth About Healthful Spice Blends NYT Readers Are Obsessing Over Right Now
The Nuance of Material Science
If you're looking at a mask with a flap—sometimes called a "double-layer overlap"—the protection level depends entirely on the "seal." If you have two inches of overlapping fabric, the air has to make a sharp 180-degree turn to escape. This creates a "baffle" effect. It’s not a perfect seal, but for someone who must use a straw or an instrument, it’s a compromise.
- Standard Cloth: 20-30% filtration.
- Cloth with a Hole: 0-5% filtration.
- Surgical Mask: 60-70% filtration.
- N95 (Solid): 95%+ filtration.
Basically, if you're adding an opening, you're dropping into the "better than nothing, but barely" category.
Practical Insights for High-Risk Environments
If you are in a situation where you feel you need a mask with an opening—perhaps for a medical procedure or a specific vocational requirement—you have to be smart about it.
- The Overlap Rule. Never use a mask with a raw, open hole. Ensure there is a magnetic or velcro flap that stays sealed when not in use.
- Context Matters. An opening is okay in a well-ventilated, low-occupancy area. It is a massive risk in a basement bar or a crowded plane.
- Double Up. If you use a clear mask for communication, ensure the plastic insert is fog-resistant and properly sealed to the fabric edges. Most "cheap" clear masks have huge gaps at the cheekbones.
The face covering with an opening remains a fascinating relic of a time when we were trying to balance the biological reality of a virus with the social reality of being human. It was an era of "good enough" engineering. But as we've learned from countless peer-reviewed studies in the years since, the best mask is still the one that actually stays closed.
Moving forward, if you're choosing a mask for protection, skip the gimmicks. If you need it for a specific task like playing an instrument, look for the specialized designs vetted by the performing arts coalitions rather than a DIY "NYT-inspired" hack you found on social media. True safety isn't found in a slit in the fabric; it's found in the integrity of the filter.
Actionable Steps for Mask Selection
- Check for the Seal: If you can feel air hitting your eyes when you exhale, the mask isn't working, regardless of whether it has a hole or not.
- Prioritize "Clear" over "Open": If communication is the goal, use a NIOSH-approved transparent respirator rather than a modified cloth mask.
- Verify the Valve: If your mask has a plastic valve, remember it protects you, not the people around you. In 2026, social responsibility in health still leans toward dual-protection.
- Dispose and Refresh: Any mask that has been cut or modified loses its structural integrity and should be replaced with a purpose-built professional model.