Look at any standard map of New York and Staten Island and you’ll notice something immediately. It’s hanging out there in the harbor, looking like it’s trying to make a break for New Jersey. Honestly, that’s kind of the vibe of the place. It is the "Forgotten Borough," a massive chunk of land that often gets cropped out of tourist maps or relegated to a tiny inset box at the bottom left corner.
But if you actually zoom in, the geography is fascinating.
Staten Island is basically a giant, hilly triangle. It's roughly 58 square miles of suburban sprawl, dense industrial corridors, and surprisingly lush wetlands. When you look at the map of New York and Staten Island, you aren't just looking at a piece of the city; you’re looking at the highest point on the Atlantic seaboard south of Maine—Todt Hill. It’s weird to think about, right? In a city defined by skyscrapers, the natural "peak" is tucked away in a residential neighborhood on the island.
Why the Map of New York and Staten Island Looks So Different From the Rest
New York City is a collection of islands, mostly. Manhattan is an island. Long Island holds Brooklyn and Queens. But Staten Island is the outlier. If you pull up a digital map and track the borders, the Arthur Kill and the Kill Van Kull are these narrow, winding waterways that separate the borough from New Jersey. It's so close to the Garden State that you could practically throw a baseball across the water in some spots.
Geologically, it belongs to the Newark Basin.
That matters because it explains why the map of New York and Staten Island feels so disconnected. While the rest of the city sits on hard metamorphic rock like Manhattan Schist, Staten Island has a lot of serpentinite. It’s softer. It’s greener. The streets don't follow a grid. They twist. They turn. They follow the old Dutch paths and the natural contours of the hills. If you’re used to the 1-2-3-4-5 layout of Manhattan, the Staten Island map will give you a headache.
There’s no "North" or "South" in the way people think. Locals talk about the "North Shore" and the "South Shore," plus "Mid-Island." It’s a social geography as much as a physical one.
The Bridge Problem and the Ferry Reality
You can’t talk about the map of New York and Staten Island without talking about the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. It’s the giant umbilical cord connecting the island to Brooklyn. When it opened in 1964, it changed everything. Before that, the island was mostly farms and quiet woods. After? Boom. Suburbia.
But look at the map again.
There is no subway connection. None. Zero.
Every other borough is stitched together by the MTA’s subterranean veins, but Staten Island is an island in the most literal sense for commuters. You have the Staten Island Railway (SIR), which looks like a subway and acts like a subway, but it doesn't actually go to the "City." It just dumps you at St. George so you can catch the ferry. This creates a weird "island time" mentality. On the map of New York and Staten Island, that orange line representing the ferry is the most important transit link in the entire harbor.
The Greenbelt: The Secret in the Middle
People see the gray blocks of the city map and assume it’s all concrete. It isn't. Right in the center of the Staten Island map is a massive splash of green. This is the Staten Island Greenbelt. It’s roughly 2,800 acres of public parkland. That is more than three times the size of Central Park.
Think about that.
If you’re hiking the white trail in the Greenbelt, you’d never know you were in the most populous city in the United States. You have glacial ponds, migratory birds, and actual silence. It’s a topographical anomaly. Mapping this area is a challenge for hikers because the terrain is genuinely rugged. It’s not just "flat city walking."
The West Shore and the Industrial Edge
Flip your eyes to the left side of the map of New York and Staten Island. The West Shore is a different world. It’s the land of logistics. You’ll see the massive cranes of the New York Container Terminal. This is where the stuff you buy on Amazon actually enters the city.
It’s also where Fresh Kills is.
For decades, the map showed Fresh Kills as the world’s largest landfill. Now, it’s undergoing one of the most ambitious ecological transformations in history. It’s becoming Freshkills Park. It’s nearly 2,200 acres. On the newest maps, you’ll see it transitioning from a brown-coded industrial site to a green-coded recreation space. It’s a wild example of how a map can change its "color" over a generation.
Understanding the Neighborhoods on the Map
If you’re trying to navigate, you have to realize that names on the map of New York and Staten Island carry a lot of weight.
- St. George: The "downtown." This is where the ferry lands, where the ballpark is, and where the courthouse sits.
- Tottenville: The southern tip. It’s actually closer to Philadelphia than it is to the Bronx. It feels like a small town in New England.
- New Dorp: The commercial heart of the island. If you need a car or a suit, you go here.
- Grymes Hill: Where the colleges are. The views of the Manhattan skyline from here are better than the views from the Empire State Building because you can actually see the water.
Navigating these areas requires a car. Period. While the map of New York and Staten Island might show bus routes (the S-numbers), the frequency is a nightmare compared to the subway. It's a "driving borough." If you’re planning a trip using just a map, you have to account for the "Staten Island crawl" on the Staten Island Expressway (I-278).
The Mystery of the "Shooters Island" and Small Outliers
Look really closely at the map where Staten Island, Newark, and Bayonne meet. You’ll see a tiny speck called Shooters Island. It’s technically split between New York and New Jersey. It used to be a shipyard where they built massive vessels. Now? It’s a bird sanctuary. It’s a ruin.
Then there’s Hoffman and Swinburne Islands. These are two man-made islands off the South Shore. You can see them clearly on a satellite map of New York and Staten Island. They were used as quarantine stations in the 1800s for immigrants arriving with cholera or yellow fever. Today, they are off-limits to humans, reclaimed by harbor seals and cormorants. They are ghost islands.
Practical Steps for Navigating the Island
If you are actually using a map of New York and Staten Island to plan a visit or move, don't just look at the lines. Look at the elevations and the transit gaps.
First, download an offline version of the map. Some of the wooded areas around the Greenbelt have notoriously spotty cell service. It’s easy to get turned around near High Rock Park.
Second, check the "Flood Zones." Because it’s an island with a lot of low-lying coastal land (especially the East Shore near Midland Beach), the map looks very different when you overlay FEMA data. Hurricane Sandy changed the physical and psychological map of this borough forever. Many areas that look like standard residential blocks are now being converted back into "blue belts" to manage rainwater.
Third, use the "Satellite View" to find the secret beaches. Everyone knows Coney Island. Nobody knows Wolf’s Pond Park or Lemon Creek Park. These are spots where the map shows the city ending, but the actual experience is more like a rugged coastline in the Carolinas.
👉 See also: Finding the Perfect Picture of Hawaiian Islands: What Most People Get Wrong
The map of New York and Staten Island is a document of a place caught between two worlds. It is part of the greatest city on earth, yet it's physically tied to the geography of Jersey. It is a place of massive bridges and tiny, forgotten cemeteries. To truly understand New York, you have to stop ignoring that big triangle at the bottom of the map. It’s not just a ferry ride; it’s a completely different version of what "New York" can mean.